E N D
1. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow APTA Technical Standards CCTV Standards Workshop June 07 APTA Communications
Sub-committee & technical standards group
Dave Gorshkov (Digital Grape Business Services)
lead committee member
CCTV, Train-Line & DVR standards for transit related CCTV systems
2. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow
3. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow
Objective of CCTV Standard
Promote the appropriate use of CCTV technology in transit related applications
Reduce risk in adopting new technologies in transit related projects
Ensure that key CCTV technologies are reviewed and evaluated so as to provide Fit for Purpose systems
Communicate findings, via the standards process, to the wider APTA community
4. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Why do we need a CCTV standard for transit related applications?
No current guidelines for transit systems level of functionality for OCC or mobile applications (e.g. ASIS have no RP for camera resolution)
Need to Provide a Uniform baseline standard to ensure quality of service (QOS) for systems design in one standard covering:-
Cameras, Recording systems and high speed Trainline/Networks
Operators need guidelines in order to design, specify and procure CCTV, high speed digital networks and digital recording systems.
Standard enables minimum Quality of imagery and data recording
Ability to run advanced analysis software for post event evaluation
Introduces usable resolution requirements for playback systems
Enables interchange of data between agencies
Clarifies periods for data retention and use of data at judicial proceedings
Provides DHS with baseline standard for grant applications
5. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Main areas of standard
Review of on-board and static solid state camera technology
Analogue Cameras (minimum frame rate and resolution)
Digital Encoded Cameras (bit rate capabilities and application)
Review of Digital recording technologies
Capabilities (environmental)
Recording duration (resolution FPS / time)
Compression system architectures
Review of Train line high speed digital networks
High speed digital coupler (connection method)
Minimum transmission capabilities (100Mb/sec)
Minimum BER requirements for QOS (1 in 10-7 mean)
6. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Main Requirements:
Frame Rate & Resolution
Cameras
CCTV cameras will be colour 480TVL/4CIF or 704 x 576 pixel minimum resolution
Frame rates that are configurable must record at 15 (12) FPS minimum inside car, 30 (25) FPS when PEI activated. Non configurable must record at 30 (25) FPS.
External facing cameras (forward / rear facing mobile cams ) will run at 30 (25) FPS (capture of external events, grade crossings, platform events etc)
All camera locations must be designed for purpose and tested against a Rotakin, or similar, resolution test target.
7. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Digital Train Lines and Networks
Capable of carrying digital CCTV data throughout rail vehicles in real-time
Comply with the 100BaseT Ethernet industry standard
Allow for connection within the auto-coupler with minimum attenuation
Provide a minimum of 1 in 10-7 average BER at 20c running at 100Mb/sec
Wireless networks should not be used for primary CCTV transmission of data to recording medium (Must be locally recorded where possible)
8. F Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow
9. A quote from the recent 2006 NIST FR evaluation tests:
There are three primary components to the improvement in algorithm performance since the FRVT 2002:
a) the recognition technology,
b) higher resolution imagery, and
c) improved quality due to greater consistency of lighting. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow
10. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow
11. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Recorders
The use of VHS based systems are no longer recommended (low res) .
All camera outputs must be recorded individually in high res and must contain a digital signature or hashing code for evidential validation.
Compression systems must comply with MPEG2, MPEG4 profile 6 or JMPEG formats minimum, and ensure that latency is no more than 1.5sec average between I frames (MPEG).
Recorded images must achieve a minimum of 240 TVL of resolution , when tested against a ROTAKIN target or similar calibrated card, when observed in playback on a normal video monitor.
OCC systems must retain recordings for 31 days, Mobile 7 days.
12. Compression
There are numerous compression systems in use and the main issue are quality of the image and that the profile used is adequate for its purpose.
MPEG2 H263
MPEG4 H264
JMPEG Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow
13. Testing and SRS
The testing of the system is the overall test that your systems requirements specification (SRS) has been achieved for EACH camera location.
Testing must be carried out using calibrated targets such as RotakinŽ in order to determine if a given camera position meets the requirements of the SRS
See following sequence of slides for testing to achieve
Monitoring, Detection, Recognition and Identification.
Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow
14.
Example screen heights to:-
Monitor
5%R Rotakin occupies 5% of monitor screen height
Detect
10%R minimum
Recognise
50%R minimum
Identify
120%R minimum
21. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Contributing & Supporting organisations
22. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Subcommittee Member Organizations NYCT
CTA
PATH
Maryland DOT
LA -Metro
MUNI
Tri-Met
DART
TTC
CTTransit
BART
Caltrain
Lane Transit
King County Metro
Alcatel
Arinc
Alstom
GE Transportation Systems
Nortel
Siemens Transportation
Trapeze ITS
Idaho National Labs
LTK Engineering
Parsons Brinkerhoff
Digital Grape
Lamoreaux-Mclendon
Teumim Technical
23. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Subcommittee Member Organizations (cont) Sound Transit (Seattle)
Edmonton Transit
Port Authority (Pittsburgh)
VTA
MARTA
MTA- Metro North
Ann Arbor Transportation Authority
Metra (Chicago)
TARC (Louisville)
Honolulu
Hampton Roads Transit
Safetran
Quester-Tangent
HNTB
Lea & Elliott
Triunity Engineering
FTA
Dikata Engineering
Orbital
24. Investing Today for a Brighter Tomorrow Points of Contact Dave Gorshkov CCTV standard lead
Phone 561-504-7967 Email: dg@dgrape.com
Jon McDonald - Chair
Phone: 206-398-5458 Email: jmcdonald@ltk.com
Website: www.transitcommtech.com