340 likes | 564 Views
Missing the Forest for the Trees. Science with the Byrd Green Bank Telescope K.K. Dyer - NRAO. The zero-spacing problem:. Interferometers work by adding signals between antennas. Short baselines measure large scale flux.
E N D
Missing the Forest for the Trees Science with the Byrd Green Bank Telescope K.K. Dyer - NRAO
The zero-spacing problem: • Interferometers work by adding signals between antennas. • Short baselines measure large scale flux. • Long baselines provide high resolution -- they sample small scale structure. • Therefore there is an angular size scale beyond which you cannot observe structure.
Observational Status Summary ....structures on angular scales significantly larger than the fringe spacing formed by the shortest baseline are not measured. No subsequent processing can fully recover this missing information, which can only be obtained by observing in a smaller array configuration, using the mosaicing method, or with an instrument (such as a large single antenna) which provides this information
How much do you lose? • Smallest scale information = /D • D = distance between antennas • For the VLA in D array at 20 cm ~ 17 arcminutes
What kind of observations does this affect? • Nearby galaxies • Galaxy clusters: Coma, Virgo • Supernova remnants • Planetary nebulae • Galactic plane • HI
CARMA and ALMA • 12 meters, 90 GHz = 1 arcminute • 15.4 meters, 490 GHz = 10 arcsecond So this will be a problem EVERYWHERE
Smallest scale measured is different at each frequency! • 6 cm: 2.7 Jy • 20 cm: 18.5 Jy What we should get: 7 Jy 15 Jy
What is in a name? • G327.6+14.6 • RA 15 02 50, DEC -41 56 • SN1006 X-ray image, Jack Hughes
Technical Details How low can you go? Dec -41º • Choose a method
Using GBT data to inform the VLA data • Fake synthesis • Joint deconvolution • Merge (add in the image plane) • Single dish as starting image GBT 20 cm observation of SN1006
Listening to your elders... total collecting area antenna efficiency system temperature bandwidth VLA=GBT small dishes vs. large dishes Time to reach the same point source sensitivity at 1.4 GHz 6 years Proof by Contradiction
constant noise fallacy Even at the VLA we don’t observe to constant noise: Each configuration gets x 4 20 seconds per GBT beam = 8 hours GBT time A config 20 hours B config 6 hours C config 2 hour D config 1 hour
goal: constant signal to noise Don’t observe longer once you’ve hit the systematics. 0.5 seconds per beam= 2 hours of observing time Note: Fourier plane method make everything four times worse! We achieve 50:1 SNR in 1 sec
The result: VLA contributes 300 mJy/beam GBT contributes 10 mJy/beam on 8.5’ scales Noise is different on different scales!
Conclusions: • Interferometers do high resolution well, total flux poorly • Worry about small spacing scale • SN1006 -- optical & x-ray • On to M82 and FarIR-radio!
Science issues affected by zero spacing problem Supernova remnants: • Testing particle acceleration • Determining magnetic field
Example 2:The magnetic field across the shock in SN1006 • Critical example of shock acceleration • Disagreement over nonthermal x-ray emission • Confirm the magnetic field GBT 20 cm observation of SN1006