110 likes | 233 Views
Budgetary Oversight and Accountability in Ukraine: The Case of General Secondary Education. Sergii Slukhai. Current State and Problems. Growing transparency on the national level Strict fiscal control over local budgets exerted by the national authorities
E N D
Budgetary Oversight and Accountability in Ukraine: The Case of General Secondary Education Sergii Slukhai
Current State and Problems • Growing transparency on the national level • Strict fiscal control over local budgets exerted by the national authorities • Low accountability of local governments concerning fiscal issues
What to control in education? Legality of money spending versus Efficiency of money usage (cost-efficiency and meeting the local demands for educational services)
Correlation between total expenditures per student and school size in Sokal District, Lviv oblast
Factors influencing accountability • Legal prerequisites (quite good) • Institutions (obsolete) • Motivation to control (mostly not significant) • Public access to information (almost absent)
National level state bodies: • Concentrating on efficiency and long-term sound fiscal management rather than on formal budgetary oversight • Introducing of formula-based money allocation mechanism instead of the existing non-transparent and subjective one • Creating conditions for inter-school competition through the voucher system • Decentralizing school administration
Educational bodies of county level • A partner rather a than a commander in relation to educational units • Regulation of the local market of educational services • Enhancing school cooperation through clustering or school districts
Schools: • Separate budgets (not budget estimates) for each school • Legalization of off-budget funding • Flexibility in budget execution • New role of school councils concerning fiscal issues
How to make it work? • Changing the legislation • Re-training educational managers • Involving the local NGOs into local educational policy making • Providing better public access to information
Why is it worth doing? • Quality education • Switching from routine of command administration to creative work • More stability and a non-biased attitude to funding educational institutions