1 / 17

Some Shortline Railroad Finance Basics

AAR Annual Meeting of the Railroad Treasury/Finance Division Naples, Florida 11/6/2007 Roy Blanchard, The Railroad Week in Review. Some Shortline Railroad Finance Basics.

adina
Download Presentation

Some Shortline Railroad Finance Basics

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. AAR Annual Meeting of the Railroad Treasury/Finance Division Naples, Florida 11/6/2007 Roy Blanchard, The Railroad Week in Review Some Shortline Railroad Finance Basics www.rblanchard.com

  2. “There is a need to work more closely with short lines in the light of growing regulatory and legislative pressures now facing the industry.” -- Mark Schmidt, BNSF, 3Q07 Short Line Newsletter www.rblanchard.com

  3. Short Lines and Class Is (FY 2006) www.rblanchard.com

  4. The Shortline Railroad Universe: • More than 500 shortline (regional and local) names, 43,000 route miles, 12 mm cars per year (cpy)* • 32 S&Ts (BRC et al), steel roads (EJ&E) have 2600 route miles, 5.2 mm cpy • NS has most (253), CP fewest (61) • Top 20 SL ops companies (ex steel, S&T) - 174 roads, 27,000 miles, > 4 mm cpy • Top 5 Commodities 2007 thru Q3: 16% forest products (lumber, panels, paper and related), 14% chemicals, 11% grain, 12% coal, 9% metals and related *More accurately, revenue units (I’ll explain) www.rblanchard.com

  5. Leading North American Short Line Operators www.rblanchard.com

  6. How Short Lines Earn Their Money • Revenue per carload, mostly from Class I divisions, allowances or fees; some ancillary fees (demurrage et al), property leases, short-haul intra-line moves. • Class I pays short lines out of revenue per EITF99-19; can discourage short line participation if market manager performance is measured on total revenue. • Common short line compensation schemes: ISS, handling fee, Jct Settlement, switch fees; the folly of car-hire reclaim. • How fuel surcharge revenue is shared varies widely. www.rblanchard.com

  7. Shortline Economics • Class I average FY 2006 revenue per merchandise load was US$1996. • Shortline pro forma allowance still US$250-$300 per revenue load, does not go up with Class I RPU increases • Double-digit Class I volume YTD 2007 decreases in low-rated commodities (forest products, aggregates, waste) hit allowance-based short lines the hardest • Proposed regulatory and legislative limits to rate increases will hurt ISS short lines the most www.rblanchard.com

  8. Short Line 3Q07 YTD Commodity Trends www.rblanchard.com

  9. Class I vs. Short Line Expense Comparisons www.rblanchard.com

  10. Measuring Short Line Results • Rules of thumb: Rule of 100, $5,000 per mile per year for track maintenance to meet FRA Class 2 specs, fuel burn 8-10 gallons per revenue unit per year • Resources consumed per revenue unit (Watco): man-hours, car hire, fuel burn, switching hours, etc. • EBITDA vs. Operating ratio: No tax advantage to capitalizing major expenditures, below-the-line items have little meaning for core values; puts focus on cash-generating capabilities of property. • EBITDA margin 40% - 50% for well-run short line; CP estimates DM&E will be at 40% for CY 2007 www.rblanchard.com

  11. Shortline Growth • Most roads started as Class I branch lines • Staggers Act encouraged spin-offs; effects of new STB ruling? • Lines transferred at low cost on assumption that short line would continue to feed Class I core exclusively • Some short lines “bought their freedom” (A&M/BNI) • Recent short line transactions have been leases (BNI), Joint Ventures (NSC) • Until recently SL pct volume growth > Class Is; Masking Class I losses? • A bright spot: BNI short line units up 8% through 3q07 www.rblanchard.com

  12. Short Line Realities • Better than Class Is for gathering and distribution, small-customer service, local infrastructure funding • Free up scarce Class I resources (locos esp) for core ops • 60% of short lines may not meet minimum economic thresholds; exceptions are single-purpose lines w hi vols • The most successful understand and complement Class I financial, commercial and operating goals www.rblanchard.com

  13. Shortline Consolidation • Bethlehem Steel roads to Lehigh Valley Rail Mgt., Georgia Pacific to GWR, Alcoa to RailAmerica • Consolidation among shortlines: RailNet to OmniTrax, Savage; Rail Management Group, Maryland Midland to GWR • Second-tier moves – Caney Fork & Western to Cundiff Group • Class Is wary of buyers over-paying www.rblanchard.com

  14. The Capacity Question • AASHTO: Predicts 70% growth in freight volume by 2020. • National Freight Infrastructure Capacity and Investment Study: Rails need to invest $135 bn in capacity over the next 30 years to meet demand. • The AAR: HR 2116, S 1125: the Rail Freight Infrastructure Act of 2007, provides for 25% tax credit for new railroad capacity in both infrastructure and locomotives. See also www.aar.org/itc/itc.asp . • Public-Private Partnerships www.rblanchard.com

  15. Short Line Capacity • ASLRRA: Current federal tax credit program offsets up to 50% of the amount invested in new or rebuilt track. • Railroad Rehabilitation and Improvement Financing (RRIF) Loans – Administered by FRA. Direct loans or loan guarantees for the acquisition, development, improvement or rehabilitation of existing or new intermodal or rail equipment facilities.  • State and local rail infrastructure funding varies by state, some more generous than others. • Save Our Service (SOS) rail customer coalition lobbying for the tax credit extension www.rblanchard.com

  16. Closing thoughts: Possible Implications for Short Lines in a Re-regulated Railroad Environment • Cost of Capital: Rate ceilings, low-rated commodities most, shortline concentration. • Small Rate Cases: Risks of customer filing to remove commodity from exempt list. • HR 2125: “Railroad competition and Improvement” Act does none of the above; nobody calls it “re-regulation.” • Paper Barriers: Class Is holding off; “buying your freedom.” • Competitive Access: A bad deal all around. A fable. www.rblanchard.com

  17. Thanks For your kind attention. Now for the fun part… It’s Q&A time! www.rblanchard.com

More Related