190 likes | 312 Views
Juvenile Justice in Malaysia. Presentation to First ASEAN Juvenile Justice Organizing Committee 1 st September 2014 – 4 th September 2014 Bangkok, Thailand. Definition of Juvenile Justice. Situation of children coming into contact with the justice system:
E N D
Juvenile Justice in Malaysia Presentation to First ASEAN Juvenile Justice Organizing Committee 1st September 2014 – 4th September 2014 Bangkok, Thailand
Definition of Juvenile Justice • Situation of children coming into contact with the justice system: • Suspected or accused of committing an offence • Deemed beyond parental control also known as status offence • Child – below the age of 18 • Age of criminal responsibility – 10 years
Definition of Juvenile Justice (cont.) • Juvenile Justice involves the following aspects: • Process of arrest or referral • Decision made • How they are dealt with • Implications of sentencing options • Prevention of juvenile offending • Social Reintegration of offenders
Delinquent Behavior • Show a steady increase – 3862 children in 2009 to 4465 children in 2010 and to 5547 in 2011 • Boys are more likely than girls to commit criminal offences • Majority of the children involved in crimes against property – however a substantial increase is observed in the number of drug-related offences • Girls come into contact with the system more for status offences • Majority from the age group of 16 – 17 years
Causes of Delinquency • Environment in the family is a major contributory factor • Lack of parental support and guidance • Adolescents have a lot of free time which is not spent in useful activities • Identify strongly with peer groups/ peer pressure
Juvenile Justice System in Malaysia • First established with the introduction of the Juvenile Courts Act (JCA) 1947 • JCA replaced by the Child Act 2001 and came into force in August 2002 • Recognized to have separate system for handling children in conflict with the law • Premised on the concept of prevention, treatment and rehabilitation • Measures are taken to ensure that children are separated from adults and afforded special care and protection
Child Act 2001 • Standardizes the definition of a ‘child’ – under the age of 18 • Neutral and non-stigmatizing terminology of children in the criminal justice system • Juvenile court renamed the Court of Children • Basic framework remains largely intact • Balance traditional rehabilitative orientation with sanctions for chronic offenders • Whipping for a male child is introduced • Probation order not permitted for grave crime
Child Act 2001 • Role of the family to take center stage in efforts to manage delinquency • Parents required to attend court during all proceedings • Mandatory for the court to bind over the parents of a child to exercise proper care and control in addition to any other punishment it may imposed • Child offenders detained in lieu of the death penalty • Compulsory for the Board of Visiting Justice to make a review at least once a year • Strengthening community-based supervision and rehabilitation through the introduction of interactive workshop
Child Act 2001 • Part X Child Act 2001 outlines structures, processes and procedures of handling children committing crimes: • Arrest, bail, remand, trial and sentencing of children • Roles and responsibilities of police, probation officers, courts and other related institutions • Part VII Child Act 2001 provides procedures for children committing status offences
Challenges • Approach is grounded in formal police and Court-based interventions and institution-based rehabilitation. Need to look into global trends such as diversion and more effective community-based responses. • Need to revisit the rehabilitation strategy in institutions. Presently focus is on standardized regime of discipline, religious instruction and vocational training – not enough to address the complex range of risk factors in child offending behavior. • Need to ensure high and same level of understanding and commitment in handling children in conflict with the law.
Challenges (cont.) • Channeling of resources: • Manpower – probation officers/police • Dedicated Courts for Children • Institution vs community-based rehabilitation programs • Need to ensure community-based rehabilitation and supervision are more effective • Need to focus on preventive measures especially at the community level, schools and family