1 / 19

in Action

Democracy. in Action. The HFE Act and Parliament. Democracy. in Action. An interface of regulation, politics, ethics and science. US physician Richard Cabot - ethics and science “ need to shake hands ”.

akeem-graves
Download Presentation

in Action

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Democracy in Action The HFE Act and Parliament

  2. Democracy in Action • An interface of regulation, politics, ethics and science • US physician Richard Cabot - ethics and science “need to shake hands” • Latest developments (Edinburgh, Toronto) - importance of effective framework to foster responsible innovation in an ethically and scientifically complex area • Barak Obama – Federal funding – Embryonic Stem-cells • Baroness Warnock - “The law must not outrage the feelings of too many people; but it cannot reflect the feelings of them all. It must therefore be drawn with a view to the common good.” -1990

  3. March 2004: House of Commons Science and Technology Committee - inquiry into Human Reproductive Technologies and the Law Democracy in Action • March 2005: Committee publishes report; Ian Gibson MP Chairman

  4. Democracy in Action • Report covers regulation of assisted reproduction, problems with 1990 HFE Act, operation of the HFEA, provision of infertility services and legislative and regulatory models • Committee calls for new legislation to define nature of inter-species embryos and make their creation legal for research purposes subject to 14-day rule and prohibition on implantation in a woman - called for greater liberalisation with artificial gametes, sex selection for family balancing • Series of divisions on the draft report in Committee; Special Report is produced setting out concerns of Committee members about the process of agreement • Government responds August 2005

  5. August 2005: Government launches consultation on the 1990 HFE Act (closing date November 2005) Democracy in Action

  6. Democracy in Action • Committee follow-up session and Estimates Day debate in the House of Commons in July 2006 • White Paper published in December 2006 – includes proposal to ban hybrid embryo research subject to later parliamentary legislation

  7. January 2007: Science and Technology Committee launches Inquiry on Government proposals for the regulation of hybrid and chimera embryos Democracy in Action • April 2007: Committee publishes Report

  8. Democracy in Action • Government’s White Paper proposals “unnecessarily prohibitive” and calls for legislation to allow research using some forms of human-animal chimera or hybrid embryos through licensing • Unanimous report • Government responds June 2007

  9. Shining a light on a difficult area Science Community • Stephen Minger – Kings London • Lyle Armstrong – Newcastle University Science Journalists • Pallab Gosh – BBC • Mark Henderson – The Times • Alok Jha - Guardian • Nic Flemming - Telegraph

  10. May 2007: Draft Human Tissue and Embryos Bill published and Joint Committee appointed Democracy in Action • August 2007: Joint Committee publishes report • Opposes creation of RATE, recommends free vote on hybrid embryo research • October 2007: Government responds – agrees not to create RATE and makes proposals on regulation of inter-species embryos

  11. Key Individuals Baroness Deech Ian Gibson Lord Mackay of Clashfern Sir Robert Winston

  12. Content of the Draft Bill • Establishment of Regulatory Authority for Tissue and Embryos (RATE)? • Balance between the role of Parliament and the Regulator? • Legal definitions for ‘Embryo’ and ‘Gamete’ (including artificial gametes)? • Licence conditions for storage, use and donation of gametes and embryos? • Fresh Gametes and Internet supply? • Consent for use of stored embryos or gametes? • Screening and selection of gametes and embryos?

  13. PGD and Sex Selection for family balancing? • Access to information for donors or children? • Payment for donors or surrogacy? • Creation of cytoplasmic hybrid embryos for research • Use of embryos for Research? – stemlines? • Welfare of the child – need for a father ? • Terminations/Tissue Retention/Organ Donation

  14. The Committee made a series of recommendations on the draft Bill Democracy in Action • Including the development of “a clear framework based on the principle of devolved regulation” (para 56) • It found the evidence against establishing a Regulatory Authority for Tissue and Embryos (RATE) “overwhelming and convincing” (para 92) • It proposed its own working definition of inter-species embryo (para 176): An inter-species embryo is an embryo which— (a)contains genetic material of human and animal origin, and (b) in which the genetic material of human origin consists of at least a complete haploid set of human chromosomes in one or more cells.” In this definition genetic material means DNA in a form capable of being expressed, mutated and replicated heritably (i.e. genes).” The Committee recommended a free vote on the creation and use of inter-species embryos for research purposes (para 177).

  15. June 2007: Science and Technology Committee announces inquiry into Scientific Developments Relating to the Abortion Act 1967 Democracy in Action • October 2007: Committee publishes Report • Covers upper gestational limit, access and procedure, foetal abnormality and women’s health • Rules out a consideration of “ethical and moral issues”

  16. Democracy in Action • HFE Bill introduced into the House of Lords 8 November 2007 • Government made a few concessions to science community consent in respect of: • The use of existing cell lines where informed consent not possible for the creation of embryos • The use of sick children’s cells to create embryos for medical research with parental consent • Liberalisation of the use of HFEA held data prospectively and regulations promised on use of existing data • Large majorities in support of IVF and embryo research

  17. Democracy in Action • Into Commons 5 February 2008 • Report stage and Third Reading 22 October 2008 • Amendments relating to abortion selected as being within the scope of the bill but not reached for debate under terms of Government programme motion • Royal Assent 13 November 2008 • Minority report on evidence selection and de-selection: rejected by 6 votes to 1

  18. Democracy in Action • Where next? • Majority of the Act to be brought into force on 1 October 2009. Provisions relating to legal parenthood will be introduced on 6 April 2009 • Funding • Department of Health consultation on regulations closes at the end of March 2009 • A Parliamentary Standing Committee on Bioethics?

  19. Democracy in Action The HFE Act and Parliament

More Related