220 likes | 386 Views
Parenting in South African mothers with a history of family violence. Shereen Moolla and Catherine L. Ward Department of Psychology University of Cape Town. UCT’s Safety and Violence Initiative ( SaVI ). Engineering and the Built Environment: Town planning Humanities:
E N D
Parenting in South African mothers with a history of family violence ShereenMoolla and Catherine L. Ward Department of Psychology University of Cape Town
UCT’s Safety and Violence Initiative (SaVI) • Engineering and the Built Environment: • Town planning • Humanities: • Anthropology; linguistics; film & media studies; psychology; religious studies; social development; sociology • Health sciences: • Forensic medicine; Gender, Health & Justice Research Unit; primary health care directorate; psychiatry; public health; surgery • Law • Law, Race & Gender Research Unit; criminology; public law
This presentation • Some background on intimate partner violence and child maltreatment in South Africa • Family violence and parenting • Methodology for our study • Findings: • Demographics • Mothers’ histories of family violence • Mothers’ parenting • Children’s behaviour • Risk and protective factors • Relationships among variables • Interpretations and implications
Thanks to: • Nicia de Nobrega, Abigail Miles and IngeWessels • The SaartjieBaartman Centre, REACH, the New World Foundation, Self-Help Mannenberg, Carehaven, the Westlake Community Centre, Place of Hope, Village Care, and the Islamic Resource Foundation of South Africa • The UCT University Research Committee and the National Research Foundation
Intimate partner violence in SA • 8.8% of men working in the Cape Town municipality report IPV against a partner in the last year (Abrahams et al., 2006) • At least half of female homicide victims are killed by their intimate partners (Seedat et al., 2009): • In 1999, this was therefore at least 1,899 women, or 12.4 per 100,000 • The rate of homicide for women (all causes) is 6x the average rate worldwide
Child maltreatment in South Africa • 44.6% of the homicides due to CAN • 35.7% of these due to abandonment in the first week after birth • 74% of the CAN homicides among children aged 0-4 Mathews et al., 2012
Consequences of family violence • Increased depression and anxiety • Increased substance misuse • Internalised model of violence as a way to solve problems
Risk and protection for parenting Child behavioural problems
Methodology • Mothers were recruited from NGOs serving women across Cape Town • Inclusion criteria: • Women with a child aged 3-8 • The child’s behaviour concerned mother • Had not received any parenting intervention • Interviewed 215 women, excluded 12: • 4 had children > 8 • 6 had too much missing data • 2 had either a “yes” or a “no” response set
Measures • Demographics • CTS-2 - intimate partner violence • ICAST-R - history of childhood abuse • PC-CTS - parent/child conflict • ECBI - child behaviour problems • PSOC - parent competence • PSI - parental stress • GHQ - maternal mental health • ASSIST - substance misuse • Duke Social Support Scale
Demographics • Mean age: 32.4 years old. • Marital status: mostly single (46.80%). • Language: mostly Afrikaans and isiXhosa (38.42 % and 42.37%) respectively. • Children: 65% had more than one child • 82.76% were unemployed • Education: 62.56% of the participants had not completed high school • Housing: • 53.21% participants lived in formal housing • 16.26% l in outbuildings in someone’s backyard • 8.87% in shacks • 20.20% in flats • 13% of the women interviewed were living in shelters for abused women at the time of the interview.
Poverty • Access to electricity, a phone, a television and a private motor-car: 12.32% had access to all four commodities. • Food security: 72.91% had ‘run out of money to buy food at least once that year’ • 34.48% ‘had to go to bed hungry sometimes’ • 81% received the child support grant
Relationships among variables • Higher maternal age was associated with child behaviour problems • Running out of money for food was associated with child behaviour problems • Getting income from work was associated with child behaviour problems • Mothers’ histories of family violence were significantly associated with child behaviour problems • This relationship is mediated by parental stress, parent-child conflict and parental competence • But not by maternal mental health, substance misuse, or social support
Parental Stress CR=4.841 CR = 10.308 CR =2.992 FamilyViolence CR =2.152 Child Behaviour Problems Parent/Child Conflict CR = 2.040 Parental Incompetence 2 = 8.683; df = 6; p = 0.192; CFI = 0.964; TLI = 0.986; RMSEA = 0.047 (0.000 , 0.110)
Implications • If women seek help for parenting, ask about their histories of family violence • If women seek help for family violence, ask about their children’s wellbeing • Prevent child maltreatment and intimate partner violence • Programmes that boost parental competence – parent training programmes – may well reduce parental stress and improve child behaviour