130 likes | 150 Views
Value of Enterprise Risk Management. MetLife Ruth Sayasith - Vice President & Actuary Corporate Risk Management July 29, 2003. ERM & Envisioned Future. Board and Exec Mgmt Know the Top Ten Risks Strategic Planning is Focused on Risk Appetite and Optimizing Risk versus Return
E N D
Value of Enterprise Risk Management MetLife Ruth Sayasith - Vice President & Actuary Corporate Risk Management July 29, 2003
ERM & Envisioned Future • Board and Exec Mgmt Know the Top Ten Risks • Strategic Planning is Focused on Risk Appetite and Optimizing Risk versus Return • Operational Risk is Minimized Through Effective Compliance and Audit Functions • Aggregate Level and Concentration of Risk is Transparent • Risk Culture is Pervasive
Scenario Testing Oversight Risk Returns on Risk Capital Operational Risk Control Enterprise Risk Management
Scenario Testing Oversight Risk Returns on Risk Capital Operational Risk Control Enterprise Risk Management • Oversight • Board and CEO • Audit Committee • Internal Audit • Controllers
Scenario Testing Oversight Risk Returns on Risk Capital Operational Risk Control Enterprise Risk Management • Operational Control • Self-Assessment • Process Mapping • Compliance
Scenario Testing Oversight Risk Returns on Risk Capital Operational Risk Control Enterprise Risk Management • Returns on Risk • Economic Capital • Diversified Risks • Strategic Planning • Ratings and Regulatory Capital
Scenario Testing Oversight Risk Returns on Risk Capital Operational Risk Control Enterprise Risk Management • Scenario Testing • Liquidity • Predominant Risk Stress Testing • Extreme Scenario Analysis
Economic Capital “A Picture of How it’s Done” Total Enterprise Volatility * Market Benchmarks Required Capital x = Attribution back to risk elements based on their contribution to Enterprise Volatility Vol. Vol. Vol. Vol. ... Risk Elements 200 + * Annual Standard Deviation of Market Value of Surplus
Economic Capital - Fundamentals • Shareholder Perspective - Market Value Focused • Risk Defined in Terms of Volatility and Uncertainty • “Right” Level of Capital for Measuring Risk versus Return (RAROC) • Consolidated across the Enterprise • Marginal Attribution to Products/Businesses (Diversification Measured)
Return on GAAP EquityA Good Indicator of Stock Price ROE Price to Equity 260% 17% 77% Correlation 220% 16% 15% 180% 14% 140% 13% 100% 12% 60% 11% 10% 20% Co. A Co. B Co. C Co. D Co. E Co. F Co. G
Risk-adjusted Return on Capital (RAROC)The Best Indicator of Stock Price RAROC Price to EC 260% 17% 98% Correlation 220% 16% 15% 180% 14% 140% 13% 100% 12% 60% 11% 10% 20% Co. A Co. B Co. C Co. D Co. E Co. F Co. G
Price to EC as predicted by RAROC A P R I C E T O E C 200% Benchmark RAROC where Price to EC = 100% C B D E F G 100% 0% RAROC
Strategic Planning • Rank Products/Businesses - Amount of Shareholder Value Added or Subtracted • Catalyst for Discussion about Risk Appetite and Optimizing Risk versus Return • Know Why We Are “Investing” in a Business and When It Will Payoff • Develop Strategy to Maximize Shareholder Value