1 / 27

Economics of Sports Bob Donchez Robert.Donchez@Colorado

Exploring the economics of sports leagues, team costs, competition limits, and revenue sources to understand profit-maximizing strategies in the sports industry. Discover the importance of leagues, setting rules, and revenue-sharing dynamics in professional sports.

annienelson
Download Presentation

Economics of Sports Bob Donchez Robert.Donchez@Colorado

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Economics of SportsBob Donchez Robert.Donchez@Colorado.edu Unit 3 Team Costs, Profit, Winning

  2. Profits Are A Touchy Subject • Team owners are condemned if they worry about profits • Corporate CEOs are condemned if they don’t worry about profits • But bad things happen if teams ignore profits • Consider the 2002-2003 Ottawa Senators • They had the NHL’s best record • They also filed for bankruptcy

  3. The Importance of Leagues • Leagues did notalways exist • Professional baseball formed 7 years before MLB • Professional football existed 44 years before the NFL • Before this teams barnstormed • Traveled from town to town • The returns were very uncertain – tied to winning • The function of leagues • They set rules for behavior on the field – and off • They promote competition on the field • The limit competition off the field • They promote the sport

  4. Setting Rules • Helps the sport to spread • Teams must agree on how to play the game • Baseball grew only after it adopted the “Knickerbocker Rules” • Outlaws undesirable behavior • Betting on games • Performance enhancing drugs • Helps sports become more popular • NBA has changed several rules • Allowed the 3-point basket • Outlawed – then reintroduced – zone defenses

  5. Limits Competition Off The Field • Limits the size of the league • Too many teams hurts competition & fan interest • Too few leaves room for competing leagues to enter • As American League did in 1901 • Protect each team’s territory • To move into Los Angeles, the NBA’s Clippers had to pay a fee to the Lakers

  6. The Economics of Clubs • What is right size of club (or league)? • New members are a new source of revenue • Entry fees are now hundreds of millions of dollars • Expansion also provides access to new markets • New members might also be a drain • Teams must share revenue with more members • Competitive balance may become a problem

  7. Finding the Right Size • MLB had only one league in the 1890s • That’s why the National League is the “senior circuit” • National League feared having too many teams • Limited league to 8 teams • But many cities grew rapidly in the 1890s • More cities were able to support teams • The NL became vulnerable to entry • In 1901, the American League entered “open” cities

  8. Table 5-4Pro Sports League Rivalries (slide 1 of 2)

  9. Table 5-4Pro Sports League Rivalries (slide 1 of 2)

  10. Table 5-5Team Movement in Pro Sports (slide 1 of 2)

  11. Table 5-5Team Movement in Pro Sports (slide 2 of 2)

  12. Leagues as Marketers • Individual teams do not provide enough marketing • Teams have little incentive to pay for advertising that benefits other teams • Everyone want to free ride • League-wide marketing is a public good • Non-rivalry: • Team A’s benefiting from league-wide marketing doesn’t prevent Team B from benefiting • Non-exclusion: • Team A cannot prevent Team B from benefiting from league-wide marketing

  13. Maximizing Profit • p = TR – TC • Leagues differ in the level of profit • NFL by far the most profitable • NHL by far the least profitable • Leagues differ in the variability of profit • NFL team profits are by far the most even • Surprisingly, the Yankees are one of least profitable team in MLB

  14. Gate Revenue • Revenue from ticket sales • If only gate revenue mattered • Baseball would still be king • Hockey would rival football • NFL shares the most • Home team keeps 60% • 40% is shared league-wide • Policy originated from the early weakness of NFL • It is one reason why team profits are so close • Baseball now shares 34% • NBA teams share nothing • Making the playoffs is a vital source of revenue

  15. Revenue from Broadcast Rights • TV became the largest revenue source in the 1960s • TV is why football surpassed baseball • Commissioner Pete got the teams to agree on a single contract for the entire league • Needed a limited antitrust exemption • That’s why there are no NFL games on Saturdays until December • Doubleheader Game makes a national game • The NFL’s contract now gives each team $? M/year

  16. Contrast to Baseball • MLB was reluctant to put on TV or • Even opposed radio at first • They felt that fans watching at home should be no better off than the fan in the worst seat • MLB favored local coverage over national • That’s why MLB has “small-market teams” • But the NFL does not

  17. Venue Revenue • Revenue from stadium – other than tickets • Naming rights • Signage • Parking • Especially luxury boxes • Boxes are why the Dallas Cowboys are so valuable • It shares most of its media revenue evenly with NFL • It keeps only 60% of its gate revenue • BUT it has more luxury boxes than an other team

  18. Luxury Boxes • Cowboy Stadium has 300 luxury boxes • Far more than any other team • Big source of revenue • Rent for 10s or 100s of thousands per season • Teams do not share most box revenue • They count only admission in revenue sharing • Most box revenue counts as concessions

  19. Naming Rights • Team sells right to name facility • Originated in 1973 • Rich Foods paid Buffalo Bills $1.5 M over 25 years • Citigroup is now pay the Mets $400 M over 20 years • Is it worth it? • Study by Leeds, Leeds, and Pistolet (2008)find that naming rights do little for the sponsor’s bottom line • Citigroup is latest sponsor to fall victim to the “naming rights curse” (received $45 B bailout from government)

  20. Revenue Sharing • Sharing varies among leagues • NFL shares the most • MLB and NHL have recently increased sharing • NBA shares very few sources of income • But its large – shared – TV contract dominates other revenue • Some perverse results • Weak MLB teams like the Nationals and Marlins have higher profits than the Yankees • The Bengals were highly profitable despite fielding very weak teams in the 1990s and 2000s

  21. Costs • By far the largest is player salaries • Others include travel, venue costs, and player development • Opportunity costs are a major reason why teams have moved • Dodgers were profitable in Brooklyn but were even more profitable in Los Angeles

  22. A Paradox • Ted Turner once owned both the Atlanta Braves and TBS, which showed the games • But the Braves made very little TV revenue • Augustus Busch once owned the St. Louis Cardinals and Anheuser-Busch • But the Cardinals made very little from “pouring rights”

  23. Paper Losses and Real Profits • Operating Income v. Book Profit • Operating income does not include interest payments • Operating income does not include depreciation • The distinction allows teams to increase profit in fact by losing money on paper

  24. Depreciation, Taxes, and Bill Veeck • Veeck was MLB’s most innovative owner • He was a creative marketer • Used 3’7” Eddie Gaedel as a pinch hitter • Introduced exploding scoreboards • He was a principled owner • Integrated the American League in 1947 • Opposed MLB’s reserve clause • Saw unique loophole in tax laws • Team can depreciate their players

  25. An Example of The Veeck Loophole • In 1964 a group bought Braves for $6.2M • The claimed team was worth $50k • They attributed most of the value ($6.1M) to the players • Declared players as depreciable assets • Straight-line depreciation over 10 years • Allowed the owners to deduct $612k/yr over ten years • At a tax rate 50%, this cut taxes by ~$300k/yr • Over 10 yrs taxpayers paid half the purchase price

  26. The “Subchapter S” Variant • A sole owner can declare a “Subchapter S” firm’s income as personal income • This makes little sense if one looks at tax rates • Corporate rates were lower than personal rate • Veeck faced CTR=52% & PTR=72% • Paper losses can be profitable – consider the Braves • Braves $300k write-off could turn a $200k operating profit into $100k book loss • At 52% CTR could write off $52k against corporate income • At 72% PTR could write off $72k against personal income

  27. Loophole’s Loose Ends • What happens when the team is fully depreciated? • Is the owner stuck with high-tax asset? • There are two ways out • Tax laws allowed a one-time switchback from Subchapter S status • The owner can sell the team and the new owner can start from scratch • Veeck revolutionized the reason for owning a team • The loophole fell out of favor in the 1970s & 1980s • Tax rates were reduced and flattened • The value attributable to players was limited • Recent tax changes have made it more popular again

More Related