190 likes | 208 Views
Young Researcher Forum, Brussels, 13 th November 2013. Surveillance of gastroenteritis using drug sales data in France Mathilde Pivette, PharmD, MPH mathilde.pivette@ehesp.fr Pr Avner Bar-Hen Dr Pascal Crépey Dr Judith Mueller. Context. Drug sales Non-specific surveillance data
E N D
Young Researcher Forum, Brussels, 13th November 2013 • Surveillance of gastroenteritis using drug sales data in France • Mathilde Pivette, PharmD, MPHmathilde.pivette@ehesp.fr • Pr Avner Bar-HenDr Pascal CrépeyDr Judith Mueller EHESP
Context • Drug sales • Non-specific surveillance data • Outbreak detection • Infectious disease surveillance • Gastroenteritis • High frequency disease • ~ 3 millions GP consultations • 50 000 hospitalizations < 5 years old EHESP
Objective • To assess the value of drug sales data as an early epidemic detection tool for gastroenteritis in France • By assessing correlation with reference data • By determining if drug data could provide an early signal of seasonal outbreak • By assessing prospective outbreak detection EHESP
Data • Stratified sample of pharmacies • 1647 in 2009 to 4627 pharmacies in 2013 (20%) • Number of boxes sold of all products • Prescribed/ Non-prescribed • Data obtained at D+1 • Geographic location of the pharmacies (region) EHESP
Indicator drug selection • Intestinal antiinfectives antidiarrhoeals (A07A) • Intestinal adsorbents antidiarrhoeals (A07B) • Antidiarrheal microorganisms (A07F) • Other antidiarrheals (A07X) • Motility inhibitors (A07H) • Antiemetics and antinauseants (A04A9) • Oral rehydration solutions • Dietetic products for diarrhea and vomiting Selection of 8 groups (256 products) • Reference data • Sentinel network of 1300 GP throughout France (www.sentiweb.fr) • Acute diarrhea cases reported each week EHESP
Sales of drugs for gastroenteritis and number of reported cases (Sentinel network), 2009-2012, France Results Cross-correlation EHESP
Epidemics detection Detection Method : Serfling method • Epidemic periods • Upper limit of the CI : threshold • Periodic baseline level • Evaluation : • Detection window : Start of epidemic from Sentinel network +/- 4 weeks • Evaluation criteria: • Sensitivity • False alert rate • Timeliness Selection of model parameters that optimize the 3 criteria EHESP
The selected detection model for non-prescribeddrugs allows the detection of seasonal outbreaks 2.25 weeks earlier • Detection performance of the selected model (IC 95%, cut-off 30%) • Sensitivity : 100% • False alert rate : 0% • Mean timeliness: -2.25 weeks (min -3; median -2.5, max -1) Detection week (Drugs) EHESP
The selected detection model for prescribeddrugs allows the detection of seasonal outbreaks 0.2 weeks earlier • Detection performance of the selected model (IC 99%, cut-off 30%) • Sensitivity : 100% • False alert rate : 0% • Mean timeliness: -0.2 weeks (min -2; median 0, max +1) • Drug sales EHESP
Detection of epidemic 3 weeks earlier than sentinel network in 2012-2013 Training period • Prospective detection during 2012-2013 • Non-prescribed Drug sales • Detection week (Drugs) • Threshold EHESP
Next step : regional analyses • Example of the 2012/2013 seasonal epidemic. • First epidemic week from drug sales • First epidemic week from Sentinel network • Detection from non-prescribed drugs 3 weeks earlier than detection from reference data, with a beginning at the east of France. EHESP
Discussion • Confirmation of the potential of drug sales analysis for gastroenteritis surveillance • Prescribed drugs: high correlation with reported cases / No benefit for early detection • Adequacy between the 2 sources • Non prescribed drugs :Detection on average 2,25 weeks earlier (daily analysis: 16.7 days earlier, detection after 7 epidemics days) • Purchase of drugs during the early phase of illness • Reflects patient behaviors EHESP
Advantages • Limits • Selection of indicator drugs : specificity • Use of medications vary by demographic factors • Population source not precisely known : incidence ? • Relevant tool to determine dynamics and detect outbreaks • Reporting lag of one day • rapid assessment of Public Health situation • prospective analyses • Automatically collection of data EHESP
Conclusion • Useful and valid tool for real-time monitoring of GI • Earlier indicator of gastroenteritis outbreak • Other infectious diseases EHESP
Thank you • QUESTIONS ? EHESP
ANNEXES • Epidemics detection • Detection Method (Serfling method) : • Periodic regression models • Key parameters : • highest pruning percentile (varying from 15% to 40%) • prediction interval (varying from 90%,95%,99%) • Number of consecutive weeks to detect an epidemic
The selected detection model for non-prescribeddrugs allows the detection of seasonal outbreaks 2.25 weeks earlier • Detection performance of the selected model (IC 95%, cut-off 30%) • Sensitivity : 100% • False alert rate : 0% • Mean timeliness: -2.25 weeks (min -3; median -2.5, max -1) EHESP
The selected detection model for prescribeddrugs allows the detection of seasonal outbreaks 0.6 weeks earlier • Detection performance of the selected model (IC 99%, cut-off 30%) • Sensitivity : 100% • False alert rate : 0% • Mean timeliness: -0.6 weeks (min -2; median 0, max +1) EHESP