1 / 37

A Cross-Cultural Perspective On Managing Diversity

A Cross-Cultural Perspective On Managing Diversity. International Human Resource Management IBUS 618.02 March 12, 2005 Khemais Boujema Azza Hararah Michel Harms Stefanie Schmidt. Agenda. Introduction Comparison: United States and United Kingdom (Stefanie) Managing Diversity

arden-preston
Download Presentation

A Cross-Cultural Perspective On Managing Diversity

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. A Cross-Cultural Perspective On Managing Diversity International Human Resource Management IBUS 618.02 March 12, 2005 Khemais Boujema Azza Hararah Michel Harms Stefanie Schmidt

  2. Agenda • Introduction Comparison: United States and United Kingdom (Stefanie) • Managing Diversity The Transition from HRM to IHRM (Khemais) • “Bridging the Gap“ Practical Issues and Implications (Azza) • Case Study: Pfizer and AstraZeneca Recap (Michel)

  3. Country Profiles: UK and US

  4. United Kingdom Area: 244,820 sq km Population: 60,270,708 = 646 per sq mi Age structure: 0-14 yrs: 18 % 15-64 yrs: 66.3 % 64+ yrs: 15.74 % Pop. growth rate: 0.29 % Fertility rate: 1.66 United States Area: 9,631,418 sq km Population: 293,027,571 = 83 per sq mi Age structure: 0-14 yrs: 20.8 % 15-64 yrs: 66.9 % 64+ yrs: 12.4 % Pop. growth rate: 0.92 % Fertility rate: 2.07 Country Profiles: UK and US

  5. United Kingdom Ethnic groups: White: 92.1 % Black: 2 % Asian: 4 % Other: 1.9 % Religions: Anglican / Roman Catholic: 66.4 % Muslim: 2.5 % Presbyterian: 1.3 % Methodist: 1.3 % Sikh, Hindu, Jewish: 2.2 % Other / None: 26.3 % United States Ethnic groups: White: 77.1 % Black: 12.9 % Asian: 4.2 % Native: 1.8 % Other: 4 % Religions: Protestant: 52 % Roman Catholic: 24 % Mormon: 2 % Jewish, Muslim: 1 % each Other: 10 % None: 10 % Country Profiles: UK and US

  6. United Kingdom GDP: $ 1.66 trillion (2003) GDP real growth rate: 2.2 % GDP per capita: $ 27,700 Pop. below poverty line: 17 % Household income: Lowest 10 %: 2.3 % Highest 10 %: 27.7 % United States GDP: $ 10.99 trillion (2003) GDP real growth rate: 3.1 % GDP per capita: $ 37,800 Pop. below poverty line: 12 % Household income: Lowest 10 %: 1.8 % Highest 10 %: 30.5 % Country Profiles: UK and US

  7. United Kingdom Labor force: 29.6 million Labor force by occupation: Agriculture: 1 % Industry: 25 % Services: 74 % Unemployment rate: 5 % (2003) United States Labor force: 147.4 million Labor force by occupation: Agriculture: 0.7 % Industry: 22.7 % Services: 76.7 % Unemployment rate: 6 % (2003) Country Profiles: UK and US

  8. Geert Hofstede Cultural Dimensions • Power Distance (PDI): degree of equality / inequality between people in the country´s society • Individualism (IDV): extent to which the society reinforces individual or collective achievement and interpersonal relationships • Masculinity (MAS): extent to which the society reinforces the traditional masculine work role model of male achievement, control, and power • Uncertainty Avoidance (UAI): level of tolerance for uncertainty and ambiguity within the society • Long-term Orientation (LTO): extent to which the society embraces long-term devotion to traditional, forward thinking values

  9. Geert Hofstede Cultural Dimensions UK: 35 – 89 – 66 - 35 - 25 US: 40 – 91 – 62 – 46 – 29 World Average: 55 – 43 – 50 – 64 – 45

  10. Managing Diversity and the Transition from HRM to IHRM Literature Review

  11. Diversity In The U.S. And The U.K. The workforces in the United States, and the United Kingdom, are amongst the most racially and ethnically diverse in the world. “..and it is now projected that by the year 2050, the population of the U.S. will be evenly split between whites and non-whites” (Cox, 1994).

  12. Managing Diversity Managing diversity is an active phenomenon—it involves supervising or coordinating the differences of individuals with diverse backgrounds to ensure that the organization’s goal are effectively met. “A way of thinking' toward the objective of creating an environment that will enable all employees to reach their full potential in pursuit of organizational objectives". (Thomas, 1991)

  13. Implications For IHRM Managing diversity is at the core of the transition from HRM to IHRM. International HRM involves: • The need for a broader perspective • More involvement in employee’s personal lives • Risk exposure • Broader external influences

  14. The Multicultural Organizations Literature findings suggest that multicultural organizations are more productive because they: • Are more able to recruit and retain culturally diverse staff • Increase their ability to attract new clientele • Create new work and management styles • Develop new patterns of personal relationships • Build structures that better meet the need of diverse staff and clientele

  15. Flaws In The Existing IHRM Literature The dominant IHRM literature is increasingly unsustainable in a rapidly globalizing business environment • Much of the existing IHRM literature is old • Much of the early research into IHRM was predicated upon limited or non representative samples • The business environment is changing rapidly

  16. Earlier Assumptions Earlier perspectives of IHRM theories include some underlying assumptions: • IHRM is essentially concerned with the management of long-term Western PCNs employed by multinational companies • The ‘failure’ rates for such expatriates are extremely big • The ‘hardship’ of international relocation demands considerable ‘compensation’ (especially financial) to encourage Western Expatriates to accept such assignments

  17. Wrong Assumptions! The previous assumptions are not valid today because: • The term ‘expatriate’ has a broader definition that includes short term and frequent travelers which only few studies have centered on • Several authors have suggested there is little evidence to support the the validity of high expatriate ‘failure’ rates and sharply criticized the data collection methods used in many of the important research studies • A recent survey by Foster-Higgins (1996) reported that 34% of their respondents had actively reduced expatriate payments. Another study in the same year found that 31% of their 351 multinational companies provided no foreign service premiums (Sheley, 1996:64)

  18. New Approaches To IHRM • Innovative international staffing techniques--use global staffing and recruit the best within and outside the country • Moves towards ‘flexpatriate’ payment systems (Senko, 1990; Dolins, 1998), and away from fixed expatriate packages based upon salary adjustments and allowances • Accommodate a ‘staged’ approach to the selection and preparation of international staff appropriate to their level of interaction with the host-country

  19. “Bridging the Gap”United States & United Kingdom Practical Issues & Implications – Everyday Life

  20. Reality Check • Highest number of failed int’l assignments involve Americans in UK and Britons in the US • Companies invest in training primarily for countries where English is not official language • Expectations of similarity can set-up expats for failure and underachievement

  21. British Say… Holiday or hols Bank Holiday To table (an idea) To put aside To strike out To fail To knock-up Pear-Shaped Up to you really Americans Say… Vacation National Holiday To put out for discussion To table To go after something To strike out To visit Disaster Don’t do it/Reconsider English-to-English DictionaryNow What Did You Really Say… HR Magazine December 2004

  22. Communications Styles • AMERICANS • Loud and clear • Speak one’s mind • BRITISH • Understated and indirect • Much of what they mean is in what is NOT said

  23. AMERICANS VIEWED AS: Over-the-top Pushing Difficult to work with Hire and Fire Culture Enterprising Arrogant Superficial Uncultured BRITISH VIEWED AS: Phlegmatic Imperialist Isolationist Overly cautious Consensus oriented Constantly seeking approval Unreliable - near perfect record for late delivery PerceptionsVS

  24. Communication & Work Style Challenges British with Americans • British harbor a degree of mistrust towards Americans in the workplace • American enthusiasm – always coming up with the solutions, even when solution not asked for • What else drives the British crazy… • American Ambition • Tendency to speak one’s mind • Emphasis on getting things done – the faster the better • Willingness to take risks – “Just Do It”

  25. Communication & Work Style ChallengesAmericans with British • Americans are easily frustrated with British need for consensus and cautious approach to making decisions • British “live and let live” approach at odds with American intensity • Meetings are a big source of frustration for Americans: • British approach to decision making • British tendency to sit quietly while one or two key people make decisions • British hesitation to push forward new ideas

  26. A Case Study Pfizer & AstraZeneca

  27. AstraZeneca (U.K.) • Workforce in over 25 countries • Over 50,000 employees

  28. Company Awards • 46th best company to work for (2002) • One of the 'Best Places to Work (2003 ) • 5th top employer in Science Magazine (2004) • Ranked top 10 of most desirable company (2004) • Lead the top 10 Companies for Executive Women

  29. “Chemistry is a useful and transferable skill" • International assignments are encouraged • Project work that requires traveling • Taking assignments overseas • 6 months – 2 years

  30. AstraZeneca’s Policy • Equal opportunities • Open management • “Total Rewards” strategy • competitive base & incentive pay • generous health and welfare benefits • healthy work/life balance • opportunities for growth, creativity and development.

  31. Total Reward Strategy

  32. Diversity Three different areas • Marketplace • Programs to address different communities • Workforce • Increase visible diversity • Workplace • Employee Network Groups (ENG`s)

  33. Pfizer (U.S.) • Workforce in over 60 countries • Over 122,000 employees • Majority works outside U.S.

  34. Global Perspective • Combination of racial and gender diversity with thought and perspective • Defining global employees’ value proposition • Identifying key rewards that employees value • Building competitive compensation & benefit programs • Creating common language • Assessing and improving “work content” • Increasing commitment • Attending various diversity conferences • Cross-pollination of learning

  35. Diversity • Popular among African-Americans • Special recruitment programs • Partnerships with HBCU’s • Relocation programs • Cross cultural counseling & language assistance • Focus on the spouse • Package deals

  36. Recap • Managing diversity is supervising and coordinating people´s differences to give the organization a competitive advantage • The existing IHRM literature is not keeping pace with the change in the international business environment • Today´s IHR professionals have to adopt new and innovative approaches for staffing, compensation, and training • Companies that invest in training do so primarily for countries where English is not the official language • YET the highest number of failed assignments involve Americans and Britons • AstraZeneca and Pfizer are excellent benchmarks on how diversity can be well-managed

  37. The End Thank you all! ;-) Questions ?

More Related