1 / 47

Twistor string inspired developments in perturbative gauge theory

Twistor string inspired developments in perturbative gauge theory. B. Spence. Cambridge April 2006. References. Review article: Cachazo + Svrcek hep-th/0504194 Short review: Dixon hep-th/0512111 Oxford Twistor Workshop – January 2005 Queen Mary Twistor Workshop – November 2005.

arvid
Download Presentation

Twistor string inspired developments in perturbative gauge theory

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Twistor string inspired developments in perturbative gauge theory B. Spence Cambridge April 2006

  2. References Review article: Cachazo + Svrcek hep-th/0504194 Short review: Dixon hep-th/0512111 Oxford Twistor Workshop – January 2005 Queen Mary Twistor Workshop – November 2005 Queen Mary research: Brandhuber,Spence,Travaglini, Bedford, McNamara hep-th/ 0510253, 0506068, 0412108, 0410280, 0407214 (+ Zoubos, now at QM, hep-th/0512302 + earlier)

  3. Background ● Quantum Field Theory, first course: Perturbation theory  do Feynman diagrams ● Conceptually beautiful, but can be seriously impractical: ● Does it matter if perturbation theory is complex? - Yes : there’s a much better way to do it, which points to a new formulation of gauge theory - Yes: LHC 2007 (soon!) Experimental tests need more scattering amplitudes

  4. Eg: Five gluon tree level scattering with Feynman diagrams: (Slide from Zvi Bern’s talk, Oxford Twistor Workshop January 2005)

  5. Experimentalists need predictions for, eg, multi-jet events: ( V Del Duca, Queen Mary Workshop Nov 2005)

  6. Spinor Simplicity ● Surprise: Sum many Feynman diagrams  very simple results, when written in spinor variables Massless spin one particle. Describe by spinors and helicity (null) momentum:  spinor variables helicity ● Strip out the gauge group dependence of amplitudes into products of traces The coefficients of these are the colour-stripped n-particle amplitudes ● These depend on the spinor variables and the helicities

  7. This the Maximal Helicity Violating (MHV) amplitude (Notation i is the particle label) Colour-stripped amplitudes ● These contain the essential information of perturbative gauge theory ● They can be remarkably simple – for example, n-gluon tree MHV amplitudes ● This simplicity is unexpected from Feynman diagrams – how can one explain it ?

  8. Amplitudes in twistor space Witten hep-th/0312171 ● Scattering amplitudes in spinor variables are simpler: eg MHV ● Idea: Look at amplitudes in twistor space  twistor space coordinates ( = Fourier transform of ) ● Then: ● ie MHV tree amplitudes localise on a line in twistor space

  9. Amplitudes in Twistor Space II ● Localisation of gauge theory tree amplitudes in twistor space appears generic: Eg: MHV< - - ++…++ > localise on a line next to MHV < - - - ++….++ > localise on two intersecting lines Eg: 3 points  Z are collinear if ● Explicit check: twistor space coord’s and the above becomes a differential equation satisfied by the amplitude in spacetime: ● (Loop level: also get localisation – see later) What can explain this localisation ?

  10. Twistor string theory I Witten hep-th/0312171, Nair ● Idea:Localisation on curves in target space – this is a feature of topological string theory ● The correct model is: *** Topological B model strings on super twistor space CP(3,4) *** (plus D1, D5 branes) ● Can then argue that: -loop N=4 super YM amplitudes with negative helicity gluons localise on curves in CP(3,4) of degree and genus ● This explains the localisation of YM amplitudes and gives a weak-weak duality between N=4 SYM and twistor string theory

  11. X X X X X X X X X X Twistor String Theory II: Tree Level ● In twistor space, tree level scattering amplitudes vertex operators moduli space of curves degree d, genus 0 (degree d  (d+1) negative helicity gluons) ● A surprise: due to delta functions, the integral localises on intersections of degree one curves: Curve Amplitude MHV < - - +…+ > nMHV < - - - +…+ > nnMHV < - - - - +..+ > X X X X X X

  12. M M M M MHV Diagrams – Tree Level Cachazo, Svrcek, Witten M ●Idea: Since MHV tree amplitudes localise on a line in twistor space (~ point in spacetime), think of them as fundamental vertices. Join them with scalar propagators to generate other tree amplitudes: M MHV nMHV nnMHV (spacetime) (twistor space) M ● This works and gives a new, more efficient, way to calculate tree amplitudes Next: more new developments at tree level 

  13. Recursion Relations: Tree level Britto, Cachazo, Feng, Witten ● Study the behaviour of tree level scattering amplitudes at complex momenta  ● ● ● = - can use this to reduce tree amplitudes to a sum over trivalent graphs ● Applications: -- efficient way to calculate tree amplitudes (eg 6 gluons <- - - +++ > : 220 Feynman diagrams, 3 recursion relation diagrams) -- useful at loop level (see later) -- can be used to derive tree level MHV rules (Risager) So, new results for tree level gauge theories…what about gravity 

  14. DeWitt – Quantum Theory of Gravity III (1967) 3 point vertex – 171 terms in total (with symmetrisation) 4 point vertex – 2850 terms in full “We shall make no attempt to exhibit 5 or higher point vertices” Trees: Gravity ● Gravity amplitudes in momentum space – studied by DeWitt (1967) ● Gravity amplitudes in spinor helicity variables are much simpler - eg n point MHV gravity amplitudeBerends, Giele, Kuijf (1988)

  15. Trees: Gravity II ● Recursion relations also found for gravity amplitudes Bedford, Brandhuber, Spence, Travaglini; Cachazo, Svrcek ● Applications: -- find new tree amplitudes -- new form of MHV amplitudes -- derivation of MHV diagrams for gravity permutations Bjerrum-Bohr, Dunbar, Ita, Perkins, Risager (non-trivial due to polynomial dependence on tilded spinors – twistor space localisation is via “derivative of delta functions” )

  16. Trees: Summary ● Gauge theory tree amplitudes localise on simple degree d curves in twistor space ● This is explained by a twistor string theory on super twistor space ● Localisation corresponds to MHV diagrams – MHV amplitudes as spacetime vertices ● Study of amplitudes at complex momenta  new recursion relations for tree amplitudes. This reconstructs amplitudes from singularities and can be used to prove the MHV approach ● All of this structure is also found with gravity amplitudes ( it is remarkable to learn something new about tree amplitudes…. )

  17. Loops - Background ● Prior to 1990’s: severe difficulties in using Feynman diagrams to calculate multi-particle one-loop or higher loop amplitudes in gauge theory ● 1990’s: Spinor helicity methods + unitarity  many advances Spinor helicity: use variables Unitarity: The scattering matrix S must be unitary: Im(A)  discontinuities in amplitude  deduce A

  18. 3 1 2 4 s cut cut Loops - Unitarity I The scattering matrix S must be unitary: ● Example: 4 point, mass m, scalar scattering 1+2  3+4: ● Scattering depends on the Lorentz invariants (s,t): ● Consider A(s,t), at fixed t, in the complex plane. There are poles at s = 4m^2, 9m^2,… (production of particles). In fact there is a branch cut from s=4m^2 to infinity (and also one along the negative s axis due to poles in the t-channel) A(s):

  19. s cut cut C Loops - Unitarity II ● Now consider the contour integral of A(s) around C: ● This gives ● Then, using ● Idea: amplitudes can be reconstructed from their analytic properties

  20. P q s p Q Loops - Unitarity III ● Various general results were found for loop amplitudes in gauge theories in the 1990’s ● Example: N=4 super Yang-Mills. n-gluon one-loop MHV amplitude t F is a box function – these are fundamental in one-loop diagrams also many new results in N=1 SYM and QCD 

  21. Loops - Unitarity IV As noted above, unitarity methods and the spinor helicity formalism led to many new quantum results in the 1990’s: One loop general results: N=4 – all MHV amplitudes N=1 – all MHV amplitudes N=0 – (cut-constructible parts of) all MHV amplitudes (for adjacent negative helicities) ● ● Other particular results: Various nMHV results at one loop Two loop results (4 point function N=4) Others (nnMHV,…) ● But – nnMHV – difficult higher loops – difficult …reaching the limits of this approach by the early 2000’s

  22. -loop N=4 YM amplitudes with negative helicity gluons localise on curves in CP(3,4) of degree and genus x x x x Loops – Twistor String Theory I ● As we saw, gauge theory tree amplitudes localise in twistor space, what about loop amplitudes? Twistor string theory – general arguments  ● ● This can also be seen explicitly in space-time for some examples eg – one loop N=4 SYM MHV amplitudes (Cachazo, Svrcek, Witten) these localise on two lines in twistor space

  23. Twistor string theory – B model on CP(3,4) --- N=4 SYM One loop open string = = tree closed string (quartic in derivatives) Loops – Twistor String Theory II ● Loop level in open string theory – generate closed strings ● this is also true for twistor string theory (Berkovits, Witten) -- at one loop level the fields of N=4 conformal supergravity contribute. This has fields and action ● avoid this if possible… the one loop twistor space localisation suggests there is a corresponding pure gauge theory spacetime description  MHV loop diagrams

  24. M M M M M M M x x x x Loops – MHV diagrams I ● For tree amplitudes – spacetime MHV diagrams work (twistor space) (spacetime) -- direct realisation of twistor space localisation ● Study of known one loop MHV amplitudes  twistor space localisation on pairs of lines ● This suggests that in spacetime, one loop MHV amplitudes should be given by diagrams

  25. Coordinates null reference vector null vector M M Loops – MHV diagrams II ? ● = MHV amplitude ● Technical issues: The particle in the loop is off-shell. But particles in MHV diagrams are on-shell  need an off-shell prescription -- Result should be independent of reference vector; -- Use dimensional regularisation of momentum integrals ● Then: multiply MHV expressions, simplify spinor algebra, perform phase space (l) and dispersion (z) integrals.....non-trivial calculation ● Result 

  26. ● The known answer is ● These agree, due to the nine-dilogarithm identity Loops - MHV Diagrams III ● The result of this MHV diagram calculation is (Brandhuber, Spence, Travaglini hep-th/0407214)

  27. Might MHV diagrams provide a completely new way to do perturbative gauge theory? Loops – MHV diagrams IV ● So – spacetime MHV diagrams give one loop N=4 MHV amplitudes a surprise - no conformal supergravity as expected from twistor string theory Bedford, Brandhuber Spence, Travaglini Quigley Rozali ● Remarkably: MHV diagrams give correct results for -- N=1 super YM -- N=0 (cut constructible) -- these calculations agree with previous methods and also yield new results -- another surprise – one might have expected twistor structure only for N=4 Bedford, Brandhuber Spence, Travaglini

  28. Loops – MHVdiagrams V ● MHV diagrams are equivalent to Feynman diagrams for any susy gauge theory at one loop: Brandhuber, Spence Travaglini Proof: (1) MHV diagrams are covariant (independent of reference vector) Use the decomposition in all internal loop legs  term with all retarded propagators vanishes by causality; other terms have cut propagators on-shell  become tree diagrams : Feynman Tree Theorem and trees are covariant (We looked at the relevance of this at the suggestion of Michael Green) • MHV diagrams have correct discontinuities  use FTT again • (3) They also have correct (soft and collinear) poles  can derive • known splitting and soft functions from MHV methods. This is evidence that MHV diagrams provide a new perturbation theory

  29. More new results at one loop: Loops: d- dimensional unitarity I ● Unitarity arguments: find amplitudes from their discontinuities (logs, polylogs) ● Supersymmetric theories: amplitudes can be completely reconstructed from their discontinuities ● Non- supersymmetric theories (eg QCD) : amplitudes contain additional rational terms has rational part e.g. one loop five gluon QCD amplitude ● In d-dimensions, the discontinuities should also determine these rational terms

  30. Loops: d- dimensional unitarity II ● d-dimensional unitarity should give the full amplitudes ● New techniques with multiple cuts developed (see reviews for references) ● eg: QCD: multiple cuts in d-dimensions – 4-point case Brandhuber, McNamara, Spence, Travaglini Triple cut Quadruple cut Result: Various integrals ● This is the correct QCD result

  31. ● ● = Loops – recursion relations ● Recursion relations for tree amplitudes: ● There are analogous relations at loop level – eg one loop QCD amplitude, recursion relations give decompositions like: loop Bern, Dixon, Kosower, hep-th/0507005 tree ● This allows one to reconstruct (parts of, in general) amplitudes from simpler pieces

  32. = M M One Loop : Summary ● One loop amplitudes (like trees) localise in twistor space ● There is a related MHV diagram construction in spacetime, eg and MHV diagrams give correct answers for any supersymmetric gauge theories as well as the cut-constructible part of QCD amplitudes ● New generalised unitarity methods, combined with recursion relations, enable major new calculations of amplitudes in super Yang-Mills and QCD

  33. = number positive, negative helicity gluons One Loop: Progress Lance Dixon, Oxford Twistor Workshop talk, Jan 2005 ~ post twistor strings (2004) ~ pre twistor strings • Plus 2005 on – eg • N=1, 6 gluons, split helicity • N=0, 6 gluons, split helicity • rational terms, electroweak • ● Note: • - Power of new techniques and rapid progress • Applications to QCD, etc relevant to LHC • Essentially all inspired by twistor string theory eg Glover, Stirling and collaborators (Durham) see reviews cited earlier for references

  34. Beyond One Loop, a Bigger Picture Some areas of current interest: ● New ways to do perturbation theory ● Gravity ● Twistors ● Recursive structures and integrability

  35. New perturbation theory for YM ● MHV diagrams give a new way to calculate one loop amplitudes in super Yang-Mills ● There are general arguments (Feynman tree theorem, singularity structure) why this works ● Is this true at all loops – do MHV diagrams give an alternative perturbation theory? ● A Lagrangian derivation ? – some initial steps have been made to develop this ~ light cone formalism. So far trees only, but suggestions of one loop all-plus vertex (for QCD) from the PI measure. Mansfield, hep-th/0511264 Gorsky and Rosly, hep-th/0510111

  36. Gravity ● Gravity tree amplitudes – exhibit similar features to those in gauge theory: -- spinor helicity methods work well -- recursion relations exist -- MHV diagrams exist ● Twistor space localisation also is found: -- at tree level – “derivative of delta function” support -- also localisation at loop level – eg one loop box coefficients Bern, Bjerrum-Bohr, Dunbar, Ita, hep-th/0501137,0503102 ● There are general arguments supporting twistor space localisation – using a gravity analogue of the Chalmers-Siegel chiral formulation of Yang-Mills theory Abou Zeid, Hull, hep-th/0511189

  37. Twistors Some of the work not discussed here: ● Berkovits twistor string theory -- equivalent open string version, uses world sheet current algebra Berkovits, hep-th/0402045 Berkovits, Motl, hep-th/0403187 ● Twistor string theory duals have been studied for other cases: -- orbifolds of N=4 SYM -- marginal deformations of N=4 SYM -- super complex structure deformations of CP(3,4) Giombi, Kulaxizi,Ricci, Robles-Llana, Trancanelli, Zoubos. Kulaixizi, Zoubos; review hep-th/0512302 Park, Rey Chiou, Ganor, Hong, Kim, Mitra ● Mirror symmetry and S duality have been explored for twistor strings  A/B models on CP(3,4)/Quadric, spacetime foam Aganagic, Vafa; Neitzke Vafa; Kumar, Policastro; Nekrasov, Ooguri, Vafa; Hartnoll Policastro; Policastro talk hep-th/0512025 ● Recent work in the twistor community – twistor actions for SYM (and conformal gravity) on CP(3,4), twistor action for super quadric, twistor diagrams, links with recursion relations Mason, hep-th/0507269 Movshev hep-th/0411111 Mason, Skinner, hep-th/0510262 Hodges,hep-th/0503060,0512336

  38. Recursive Structures and Integrability ● N=4 super Yang-Mills: study of collinear limits of 4 point two loop MHV amplitudes led to the result Anastasiou, Bern, Dixon, Kosower, hep-th/0309040, 0402053 (see also Eden, Howe, Schubert, Sokatchev, West, hep-th/9906051,0010005 for some earlier work on recursive structures in N=4) ● This is non-trivial, involving intricate cancellations ● This cross-order relation has recently studied using differential equations for amplitudes 

  39. Recursive Structures and Integrability II ● Cross-order relation (4 point MHV N=4 SYM): ● This has recently been proved using differential equations Cachazo, Spradlin, Volovich, hep-th/0601031 4 point loop amplitudes. General form (Mellin-Barnes) ~ One can use this to show that Fixing the kernel of this operator by IR and collinear limits, one can prove the cross order relation above ● A natural conjecture for an L-loop operator is…

  40. constants O(e) constants, independent of number of legs n loop expansion parameter ● Note that this expresses the L-loop n-point MHV amplitude in terms of the one loop amplitude. Recursive Structures and Integrability III ● All-loop N=4 n-point MHV conjectured recursion relation Bern Dixon Smirnov, hep-th/0505205 ● It gives the two loop relation given earlier. It has also been checked for 3 loops: 

  41. (2/3 of the) two loop function from Bern, Dixon Kosower Recursive Structures and Integrability IV ● Conjectured general cross-order relation: ● Tested at three loops (4 point function): ● This is rather involved: ● Two-loop, 5 point also tested recently Cachazo, Spradlin, Volovich, hep-th/0602228 ● Cross-order relations also argued for some deformations of N=4 Khoze, hep-th/0512194

  42. Recursive Structures and Integrability V ● One major consequence of the BDS cross-order relation is a prediction for the finite part of the n-point L-loop MHV amplitude for N=4 SYM: … … ● This has been calculated in two other places to certain orders (1) 3-loop QCD calculation – Moch, Vermaseren, Vogt hep-ph/0403192, Kotikov, Lipatov, Onischenko, Velizhanin, hep-th/0404092 -- agrees with above (2) and 

  43. Recursive Structures and Integrability VI ● Past few years: integrable structures found and studied in super YM and string theory duals ● On the gauge theory side, this has yielded predictions for the anomalous dimensions of gauge theory operators using spin chains e.g. sl(2) Bethe ansatz: (solve the first two equations for then the third equation gives the anomalous dimension)

  44. Recursive Structures and Integrability VII Sl_2 Bethe ansatz, large S limit of twist 2 operators six loop prediction for anomalous dimension Agrees up to 3 loops with the results of KLOV and BDS earlier Eden, Staudacher QM Twistor workshop 11/05

  45. Recursive Structures and Integrability VIII ● Recall BDS conjecture for the finite part of the all-loop N=4 SYM MHV amplitudes: ● Very recently (Eden, Staudacher, hep-th/0603157) an integral equation has been given which completely determines the (depends on Bessel functions J) From this, can be expanded in powers of a (the result has integer coefficients times products of zeta functions…). ● The derivation of the equations above uses the large spin limit of the asymptotic all-loop Bethe ansatz. The result then links the spacetime S matrix with the worldsheet S matrix. To the conclusions

  46. Achievements of twistor string theory and its applications ● The original twistor string theory and later related twistor developments – new weak-weak dualities between gauge theory and string theory. ● Major progress in calculations -- N=4: new amplitudes, more legs, loops -- N=1: many new amplitudes also -- N=0: new results for QCD and E-W, relevant to LHC ● New ideas for perturbative gauge theory (and gravity) -- new perturbation theory and MHV diagrams -- new recursion relations between amplitudes -- new developments with unitarity methods -- cross-order relations – links with recent integrability work

  47. To Do List ● Twistors: -- twistor string dual of pure (super) YM -- twistor string dual of Einstein gravity -- general picture: A,B models, CP(3,4) and quadric -- higher loops -- more legs -- more LHC relevant amplitudes ● Applications: ● Structure of perturbative gauge theory -- MHV diagrams and perturbation theory – test -- higher loops and differential equations -- iterative structure in N=4 and relationship with integrability Much has been found, but there is much more to learn…..

More Related