240 likes | 378 Views
Next Speaker:. Alexandra K. Glazier, JD, MPH Why Gift Law Matters: The Law and Ethics of Donor Designation. Sponsored by.
E N D
Next Speaker: Alexandra K. Glazier, JD, MPH Why Gift Law Matters: The Law and Ethics of Donor Designation Sponsored by
Why gift law matters: the law and ethics of donor designationAlexandra K. Glazier, JD, MPHVP General Counsel, New England Organ BankChair, OPTN/UNOS Ethics CommitteeFaculty, Boston University School of Law
Legal Basis of Deceased Donation in the U.S. • The Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (UAGA) • Primary legal authority for organ and tissue donation • Model legislation enacted as state law • First drafted in 1968, revised in 1987 and 2006
Legal Basis of Deceased Donation in the U.S. • State law • Consent a reserved power of the states • Federal regulation of transplantation • Every state passed original UAGA • 47 states have now enacted the 2006 version
True or False ?The law requires informed consent for deceased organ donation. • True • False
Legal Basis of Deceased Donation • UAGA is notbased on informed consent principles • authorization • legal permission • Informed consent is a legal principle that applies to healthcare treatment decisions • risks and benefits to the patient • doctor patient fiduciary relationship
Legal Basis of Deceased Donation • Other decisions do not fall under the informed consent legal principles • advanced directives • burial / cremation
Legal Principles of Gift law Gift defined: A gift is a voluntary and legally binding uncompensated transfer
Legal Basis of Deceased Donation • Gift law as primary legal principle in UAGA • Gift law requires 3 elements: • Intent • Transfer • Acceptance
Legal Basis of Deceased Donation • The gift is conditional • Death • Clinical suitability • The gift is limited • Transplant / therapy • Research • Education
First Person Authorization Adult individuals have the right to make a legally binding anatomical gift prior to death.
Legal Basis of First Person Authorization • Under the UAGA an anatomical gift can be made: • By an adult prior to death • By a surrogate decision-maker at death
UAGA: First Person Authorization • Document of gift • Satisfies first legal element of gift law • Signed by adult prior to death
Which of the following are legally recognized ways to make an anatomical gift? • Signing up for the donor registry at the DMV • Written statement in a will • Verbal statement • All of the above • A and B but not C
Approximately how many registered donors in the U.S.? • 5 million • 25 million • 50 million • Over 100 million
Donor Designation in the United States 110,277,329 as of 3/31/13
Impact on Donation, 2007-2012 Designated Donors Among Recovered Donors
UAGA: First Person Authorization • Disclosure of donor designation to family • Required by some state laws • CMS regulations • OPO practice • Coordination of donation • Legal permission is the floor not the ceiling • Families are an integral part of carrying out the donor’s gift
Ethical Basis of First Person Authorization • Self-determination concept that adult individuals should be able to make their own decisions about donation of organs after their death • Consistent with ethical principles behind other advanced directives
True or False ?Family can revoke donor designation at the time of a patient’s death. • True • False
What happens when families object? • Law • First person authorization is a legally binding anatomical gift that family cannot over-ride • Gift can be accepted or declined • Legally protected and granted immunity from liability if follow UAGA in good faith. • Ethics • Respect the autonomy rights of the donor • Maximize the potential good (lives saved)
How to move forward • Hospital staff knowledge of the law • Escalation protocol in place • basis of family objection • transplant potential • Coordinated decision between OPO and Hospital
“A ship is safe in the harbor, but that's not what ships are for.” - William Shedd
4 things to know about the legal and ethical principles of donation • The Uniform Anatomical Gift Act is the law that governs deceased donation in the U.S. • It is based on gift law principles not informed consent • Adults can make their own legally binding donation decision prior to death • The ethical principle of autonomy supports first person authorization