460 likes | 1.5k Views
Defluoridation by Adsorption. Presented By: Emily Stewart, Rachel Sparks, Sajeev E . M . , & Erin Kennedy. Agenda. Problem Statement Groundwater Situation in Odisha Defluoridation Methods Preliminary Analysis Specifics on Adsorption Technique Common Adsorption Materials
E N D
Defluoridation by Adsorption Presented By: Emily Stewart, Rachel Sparks, SajeevE.M., & Erin Kennedy
Agenda • Problem Statement • Groundwater Situation in Odisha • Defluoridation Methods • Preliminary Analysis • Specifics on Adsorption Technique • Common Adsorption Materials • Selection Criteria & Recommendation • Additional Questions & Information Required
The Problem • India’s economy dependent on agriculture • There has been a shift from seasonal to year-round cropping to address food security • Groundwater used to supplement irrigation • Quality and quantity of groundwater degraded by natural and human activities • Detrimental effect on the quality of crops and public health
Solution Methodology • Define area of study • Amount of groundwater used for irrigation • Extraction methods • Chemical composition of water • Type and intensity of cropping • Effects of contaminated water on crops and health • Suggest point/on-farm treatment methods
Groundwater in Odisha • Total usable groundwater resource= 12.6 BCM (12.6x1012 L), 2007-2008 • Around 390,000 groundwater structures employed for irrigation,2004 • Dug well (92%) • Shallow tube well (4%) • Filter point tuber well (3%) • 4.7 BCM of groundwater was used for irrigation in 2001 • Projections indicate groundwater use for irrigation could rise to 9.4 BCM by 2050
Groundwater in Odisha cont. • Groundwater affected by: • High fluoride concentration (>1.5 mg/L) • High iron concentrations (>1 mg/L) • High nitrate concentrations (>45 mg/L) • Presence of these pollutants in groundwater causes health issues and affects the quality/yieldof crops • Study focuses on treating high fluoride concentrations in ground water
Defluoridation Methods • Common methodsinclude: • Adsorption and ion exchange • Precipitation • Membrane filtration process • Distillation • Membrane filtration and distillation are advanced and not deployable in developing countries • Conduct preliminary analysis to select treatment method
Preliminary Analysis • Green – Most suitable • Orange – Average suitability • Red – Not suitable
Adsorption Through Ion Exchange • Process involves passage of water through a contact bed where fluoride is removed by ion exchange or surface chemical reaction with solid bed matrix • Water is filtered down through column packed with an ion exchange resin • When adsorbent becomes saturated with fluoride ions (F-), material must be backwashed (recharged) with a mild acid or alkali solution to clear and regenerate it • Exchange reaction: • AB + CF AF +CB where A and C are cations and B and F are anions • Double replacement occurs with the fluoride anions exchanged leaving the remaining water with less fluoride.
Selection Criteria & Recommendation Activated Alumina • Reasons • Used mostly for drinking water, but seems feasible to increase capacity for irrigation • Relatively low cost • Effective (85-95%) at pH of 6.5 • Material available locally • Easy to implement • Socially acceptable, but training necessary on handling of chemicals • Key Selection Criteria • Use of treated water • Cost of method • Effectiveness • Problems due to break point • Effect of other chemicals • Size and capacity of method • Quality of water (high pH issues and other chemicals) • Social acceptance
Additional Questions/Info Required • Chemical composition of groundwater? Effect of interference due to other contaminants? • Factors affecting fluoride uptake capacity: • Grade of activated alumina • Particle size • Water chemistry: pH, alkalinity, fluoride concentration (effective range of process), temperature • Exact source of irrigation water at specific farms? Groundwater or surface water or both? • Does Odisha (and specifically the local community we are working with) treat water for irrigation? How much do they treat water for drinking water requirements?
Additional Questions/Info Required • What volume of treated water is needed? • Irrigation water rotation between surface and treated groundwater may still be a possible option. • What time is available/acceptable for treatment? • Additional costs: apparatus materials, regeneration chemicals, maintenance tools/materials, preliminary treatment chemicals, testing equipment? • Type and intensity of crops? • Further information on exact effect of fluoride on crops: stunting growth/damaging of crops or indirect damage to health from human consumption of crops?