1.65k likes | 16.35k Views
Modern Europe I HIS-106. Unit 10 - The French Revolution. What is a Revolution?. A “revolution” can be broken down into four requirements: An overthrow of the existing government but not just a simple coup d’etat The placement of a new governmental system to replace the old
E N D
Modern Europe IHIS-106 Unit 10 - The French Revolution
What is a Revolution? • A “revolution” can be broken down into four requirements: • An overthrow of the existing government but not just a simple coup d’etat • The placement of a new governmental system to replace the old • The participants of the revolution must be “home grown” and not be pushed by an outside group • It occurs in the modern period as most of the ideas of “revolution” come out of the Enlightenment of the 17th and 18th centuries
Importance of the French Revolution • There are three things that made the Revolution important: • What occurred in France becomes a model for future revolutions in Europe even up to modern day • It changed the political map of Europe for the rest of the modern period • It brought the people into politics • Before, politics had been limited to the upper classes, the nobility, and the clergy • Afterwards, the masses were able to participate in government
What Makes France So Special? • In the 18th century, France was the most advanced and powerful country in Europe • It was one of the dominant military powers, rivaled only by Britain • France helped the Americans win their independence from the British • It was the most populous country in Europe • The population of France was around 24 million which was even larger than Russia before the divisions of Poland • Paris was only rivaled by London in size
What Makes France So Special? • France was also the center of the Enlightenment and the radical ideas of the time • This was ironic since it was also one of the most oppressed countries in Europe when it came to freedom of speech • The philosophes set down the modern political and social theories that sparked many of the revolutions • French culture also dominated Europe • French became the “official” language of many of the courts of the time • When the revolution breaks out in France, it was going to have a major impact on Europe, for good or for bad
France Before the Revolution • The Ancien Régime • The ruling dynasties were the Valois and Bourbon (1328-1792) • It was a period of aristocratic privilege similar to the old feudal system of the Middle Ages • Starting in the 18th century, tensions arose among the various classes • Aristocrats resented the freedoms the monarchs had allowed the middle class • Middle class resented a society of privilege that was outmoded • Peasants resented the increasing demands of the central government
Causes of the French Revolution • Four categories of causes of the French Revolution • Intellectual Causes • Mainly based on the influence of Enlightenment ideas • Liberal ideals • “Rights of Man” - Life, liberty, and property • Self-Determination - A government “by the people” • Equality under the law • End to Feudalism and State-Controlled Economy • American Revolution also played a role • Creation of a Free Republic • Many French fought in the American Revolution
The Three Estates • Social causes of the Revolution are based on the archaic three estate system • First Estate (premier état) - The Church • Second Estate (deuxieme état) - The Nobility • Third Estate (tiers état) – Everybody else • Power was in the hands of the first two estates • Made up only around 5% of the population • Controlled most of the wealth and political power • Third Estate paid most of the taxes • Did not enjoy any political power even though its wealth and numbers were growing
The Three Estates • First Estate - Clergy • Made up 1% of the population (~100,000) • Owned 10% of the land in France • Exempt from property taxes • This estate collected a tithe, a 10% annual tax • Second Estate - Nobility • Made up around 2.5% of the population (~400,000) • Owned 20% of the land • "Noblesse d'épée" - ("Nobility of the Sword“) – Old Nobility • 50,000 new nobles created between 1700 and 1789 • "Noblesse de Robe" - ("Nobility of the Robe“) – New Nobility
The Three Estates • Third Estate – Everybody else • Made up approximately 97% of the population • Mainly peasants who paid most of the taxes • Owed obligations to landlord, church, and state • Direct and indirect taxation a heavy burden • The corvée • Social boundaries between noble and non-noble ill-defined • Most noble wealth was proprietary (tied to land) • Influx of new wealth from banking, shipping, slave trade, and mining • Bourgeoisie identified with the nobility, not the common people
Louis XVI • (1774-1792)
Louis XVI (1774-1792) • The political cause centered around the reign of Louis XVI • Louis XVI came to the throne at the age of 19 • He had no interest in running the government • Like his grandfather, he was more concerned about hunting • On July 14, 1789, he put in his hunting journal only one word: “rien” (“nothing”) • Hired Jean-FrédéricPhélypeaux, Count of Maurepas, to be his chief advisor • Suggested the revival in the use of the parlements • These had been abolished during the reign of Louis XV • Louis thought this would increase his popularity with the nobility
Louis XVI (1774-1792) • In France, there were 13 parlements • The parlements did not write legislation • Instead, they were only required to ratify laws and take care of some administrative tasks • The king always had the right to veto any act of parlement • The most powerful of the parlements was the one in Paris • Here was where the king would request a lit de justice to have royal edicts passed • For a short period of time during the reign of Louis XV, the parlements were given the right to veto a king’s act • As their members came from the Second Estate, they were unwilling to bring about any reforms that would threaten their power
Louis XVI (1774-1792) • Louis also did not show much interest in producing an heir to the throne • Married Marie Antoinette in 1700 at age 15 • However, the marriage was not consummated until seven years later • May have been due to immaturity, impotence, or may have had a condition known as phimosis • Marie Antoinette was not very popular • She dispensed patronage among her friends • In 1783, the Hameau de la Reine ("The Queen's hamlet") was built for her by Louis XVI • In 1785, there was the Diamond Necklace Affair
Marie Antoinette • (1755-1793)
Economic Causes of the Revolution • Major cause of the Revolution: Economics • Played a role both in the long and short term • By 1780s, French economy was failing • Massive national debt • Accumulated during the reigns of Louis XIV and Louis XV • Due to the number of wars • Old tax system could not pay off the debt • The debt was viewed not as the country’s debt but the king’s • By 1764, the national debt was up to 2.3 billion • Worth ~ $15.5 billion in 2010 currency • Interest on these loans was costing 60% of the annual budget
Economic Causes of the Revolution • Many countries in Europe were also in debt • Due to wars and economic depressions in the mid-1760s • Their tax systems were more efficient • Wartime taxes • Tried to extend wartime taxes to help pay these debts • Parlements opposed them • Focused instead on paying the interest rather than principle • Antiquated tax system • Taxes were collected by tax “farmers” • They collected the indirect taxes, such as tailleand gabelle(salt tax) • Able to keep a percentage of the taxes collected
Economic Causes of the Revolution • Only the Third Estate paid all the taxes • Taxation tied to social status and varied from region to region • It was mainly paid by the peasantry whose incomes were the lowest in the country • Not enough money going into the royal treasury • Yet France was considered one of the wealthiest countries • Attempts to reform taxes • Were attempts to tax nobility • All were opposed by the parlements • This conflict peaked during the reign of Louis XVI
Anne-Robert-Jacques Turgot • French Finance Minister • (1774-1776)
Rising Economic Crisis • Louis hired a number of financial ministers to help with the debt • Anne-Robert-Jacques Turgot • He strongly followed laissez-faire styled economics • Wanted to implement a property tax • Parlements vetoed Turgot’s proposals • Could have saved France? • Jacques Necker • “Old school” economist and mercantilist • Managed financing for the American Revolution • Got loans to pay for the 1.3 billion livre cost • Ended up making the debt much worse
Jacques Necker • French Finance Minister (1777-1781)
Rising Economic Crisis • Tensions between the central governments and the provincial parlements slowed reform • Parlements defend nobility’s exemption from paying taxes to pay for the Seven Years’ War • Charles-Alexandre de Calonne • Was appointed as finance minister in 1783 • By August 1786, France had a deficit of 112 million livre • The loans accumulated since 1776 totaled 1.25 billion in debt • At this point, France had no way of paying all of its debts • Calonne realized that minor changes would not help the government get out of debt
Rising Economic Crisis • Calonne proposed a tax on all the people of France • This would include the nobility • General tax on all landowners to replace the taille • Calling of the Assemblée des notables • Calonne knew he would have problems getting these taxes through the Parlements • Called an Assemblée des notables instead • If they supported his plan, he would have little difficultly getting it passed in the Parlements • Assembly of Notables was called on February 22, 1787 • There were 144 people in attendance • Included the highest of the nobility, church, and bourgeoisie
Political cartoon of the Assembly of Notables “My dear creatures, I have assembled you here to deliberate on the sauce in which you will be served”
Rising Economic Crisis • Aristocrats used the financial emergency to extract constitutional reforms • Were willing to make some radical changes • This included the implementation of a land tax • Insisted that any new tax scheme be approved by the Estates-General • They refused to pass anything resembling a general tax • On April 8, 1787, Louis XVI fired Calonne • Replaced with Etienne Charles Lomenie de Brienne • Brienne was also unsuccessful at getting the tax laws passed
Rising Economic Crisis • Brienne turned to the clergy for help • Requested a large payment from them to help out the country’s finances • They refused • Brienne realized that there was nothing else he could do • Nothing would get passed without calling the Estates General • In August 1788, the financial crisis had worsened • On August 8, he announced that the Estates General would meet in May 1789 • On August 16, the government stops repaying loans
Qu'est ce que le Tiers Etat? • What is the Third Estate? By Abbé Sieyès (January 1789)
Calling of the Estates General • Estates-General had not been called since 1614 • The Three Estates elected delegates • Drew up the cahiers et doléances (list of grievances) • The delegates of the Third Estate represented the outlook of the elite • 25 percent lawyers, 43 percent government officials • Strong sense of common grievance and common purpose • Should the estates vote by estate or by individual? • Parlement of Paris stated that each of the estates would have only one vote each • Third Estate wanted double representation in the Estates
Calling of the Estates General • Double representation • On December 27, 1788, Louis allowed for double representation for the Third Estate • What is the Third Estate? (January 1789) • Pamphlet written by AbbéSieyès • Stated that the true desire of the Third Estate was to have true political power and have equal power to the first two estates combined • He also stated that the votes should be taken by head, not by estate • This sparked further debates throughout France • Lambasted the Second Estate as being useless without the Third Estate
The Estates General • The delegates for the Estates General met at Versailles on May 2, 1789 • First two estates were greeted by Louis in the Hall of Mirrors • Third Estate was forced to wait until four hours later to meet the king in a different part of the palace • The Estates General opened on May 5 • The three estates were to be seated in different chambers • The Third Estate refused to be segregated • Requested that all three estates sit in the same chamber • King announced that the voting would be by estate with each having one vote • Third Estate refused to pass any measures
The Estates General • On May 28th, the Third Estate began meeting on its own • They now called themselves the Communes (“Commons”) • AbbéSieyès also told the Commons that they should invite members of the other two estates to join them • They were hoping to attract the parish priests as many of them were poor • A number of clergy did join them • Commons wanted to create a new legislative body • This was because more than one estate was in attendance • AbbéSieyès stated that this body represented 98% of the country • It should start work immediately on the restoration of France
Abbé Emmanuel-Joseph Sieyès • (1748-1836)
The National Assembly • Creation of the National Assembly • Created by vote on June 17, 1789 • Passed a measure stating that all taxes could not be collected unless passed by the National Assembly • Assembly continued to invited members of the other two estates to join • By June 19, 1789, over 100 clergy and nobility had joined • Louis planned a séance royale(Royal Session) • The purpose was to try to get the three estates back on track • The location was to be in the Salle des États, the meeting place of the Assembly • When the National Assembly showed up to the Salle des États on June 20, 1789, they found the doors locked
The National Assembly • The Assembly moved to a nearby indoor tennis court • Tennis Court Oath (June 20, 1789) • The members in attendance gave the following oath: • “We swear never to separate ourselves from the National Assembly, and to reassemble wherever circumstances require, until the constitution of the realm is drawn up and fixed upon solid foundations.” • It was passed 576-1 by the members • This was a key action by the National Assembly • They were going to put together a constitution with or without the king • The Assembly had true power of the country as it represented the people
The National Assembly • On June 22, 1789, the Assembly found itself locked out of the tennis court • The group went on to meet in the church of St. Louis • Louis recalled over 18,000 soldiers to Versailles • He would use them disband the Assembly by force if necessary • By June 24, most of the clergy had joined the Assembly along with 48 nobility • On June 27, Louis ordered all the delegates to join the Assembly • On July 9, the Assembly renamed itself the National Constituent Assembly
Riots and looting in France • (March-May 1789)
Revolution from Below • There were two sides to the revolution • The middle- and upper-classes were bringing about change for the country via politics • The lower-classes were making changes through riots • Suffering lower classes • They endured increases in the taille, gabelle, and in feudal dues • Hoped that the calling of the Estates General would help ease their financial burdens • Bread shortages • During the 1780s, weather patterns had a negative impact on crops • It was a peak period in the “Little Ice Age” • Eruptions in Iceland from 1783-1785
Revolution from Below • These weather patterns led to a decline in crop outputs • Bad winter in 1787/1788 • Followed by severe hailstorm in July 1788 • Led to a sharp increase in the price of grain and bread • Bread was a mainstay of the peasant’s diet • By 1788, most peasants were spending upwards of 50% of their income just on bread alone • By 1789, 80% of their income went to bread (highest since 1714) • This led to a severe food crisis throughout France • From 1785 to 1789, the cost of living increased 62% • However, wages only went up 22%
Revolution from Below • No government relief • Due to the country’s poor financial status • Some towns attempted to fix the price of bread • Failed to stop the growing famine in many regions • Economic depression made matters worse • Incomes of many workers declined rapidly • Rise in unemployment • Many peasants stopped paying their feudal dues and taxes • Some moved into the cities but were unable to find work • In the towns and cities, labor revolts broke out in the spring of 1789
Revolution from Below • Increase in crime and vagrancy • Due to so many people out of work and searching for food • Growing paranoia • Lower-class was positive the king and nobility were going to shut down the Third Estate • Specifically, they were fearful that the king was going to forcibly disband the Constituent Assembly • Rumors circulated that Louis was about to stage a coup d’état • Many people and towns began to arm themselves for protection • Parisian workers (sans-culottes) organized a militia of volunteers
Storming of the Bastille • Riots and looting broke out on July 12, 1789 • Many were looking for food and for weaponry • The GardesFrançaises (French Guards) stood back and allowed the looting to occur as they were sympathetic to the people • July 14, a mob took weapons from the Hôtel des Invalides • They were able to take 28,000 muskets and ten cannons • However, they were not able to secure enough ammunition • The next target was the fortress of the Bastille • There was the belief that the Bastille held 250 barrels (20,000 pounds) of gunpowder • The mob ransacked the prison and took the governor and guards hostage
Great Fear of 1789 • On July 17, 1789, the Revolution spread to the countryside • The situation there was already tense • Increase in vagrants, beggars, and criminals • Convinced that the nobility had employed these people to terrorize them • Rumors that the king’s armies were on their way • The peasants responded by arming themselves in self-defense • The peasants wanted to destroy the manorial system • Burned the buildings where the taxes were collected • It escalated to sacking and burning down the manor homes • The nobility was forced to flee the countryside
August Days • On August 4, 1789, the Assembly voted to: • Give up their seigneurial rights and declared an end to serfdom • Declare an end to the tithe, special privileges, and tax privileges • The Declarations of the Rights of Man and Citizen • Issued by the Assembly on August 26, 1789 • Based on the ideas of the natural rights of man • Every citizen had the right to “liberty, property, security, and resistance to oppression” • All citizens were equal in the eyes of the law • “Law is the expression of the general will” • It called for the government by the people • The people were to decide how taxes were to be collected
August Days • The period of all of these changes became known as the “August Days” • Legislation the “August Decrees” • Working on a new government and constitution • The differing factors in the Assembly made this a difficult task • Conservatives wanted to keep the king as the main authority of the government with a bicameral legislature • Liberals wanted a unicameral legislative body • This was out of fear that the nobility in the upper house would give themselves back some of its power • Louis had refused to recognize the Declarations