320 likes | 353 Views
Challenges for teachers in the digital area. Over the Pedagogical triangle Philippe Gabriel LIRDEF, and University of Avignon. Introduction. Reflexive teacher Challenges Conclude. A few words of presentation. educational psychologist
E N D
Challenges for teachers in the digital area Over the Pedagogical triangle Philippe Gabriel LIRDEF, and University of Avignon
Introduction • Reflexive teacher • Challenges • Conclude
A few words of presentation • educational psychologist • research laboratory : 'Laboratoire Interdisciplinaire de Recherche en Didactique, Éducation et Formation' (LIRDEF) of the University of Montpellier and the University Paul Valery • professionnal development and assessment
Introduction • Reflexive teacher • Challenges (3) • Conclude
I. Reflexive teacher • A reflexive professional • A practitioner in a situation • Someone teaching for learning
Reflexive teacher (1) • A reflexive professional • Decision-making background • Representation of learning ICT Changes in professional posture
Reflexive teacher (2) • A practitioner in a situation • Families and school • Classroom life and relationships • Learning spaces ICT Questions, choices and deals, identity and values
Reflexive teacher (3) • Someone teaching for learning • Curriculum • Pedagogy • Assessment ICT ICT competencies and their connection with subject knowledge
II. Challenges in the digital era • Resilience • Reason • Result
1. Resilience (to avoid the negative) • Mrs. Oublier’s syndrom (Cohen, 1990) • To graft innovative practices onto traditional ways of teaching
Negative: mechanical reproduction • How, as a teacher, am I equipped for teaching? • Decision-making background • Representation of learning
2. Reason (to keep our heads) • For my students, what is the added-value of using digital technology in the classroom?
Influences on achievement using 900+ meta-analyses Hattie, J. (2011). Visible learning for teachers. Routledge: New York Major domains of interest (teacher, curricula, teaching, student, home and school)
Rank these 11 effects: • Reducing disruptive behavior in the class • Feedback • Acceleration of gifted students • Reading Recovery • Integrated curriculum programs • Homework • Individualized instruction • Ability grouping • Open vs. traditional classes • Retention (holding back a year) • Shifting schools from 1 = highest effect to 11 = lowest effect
Rank these 11 effects: answers • Reducing disruptive behavior in the class .86 • Feedback .72 • Acceleration of gifted students .60 • Reading Recovery .50 • Integrated curriculum programs .40 • Homework .30 • Individualized instruction .20 • Ability grouping .10 • Open vs. traditional classes .00 • Retention (holding back a year) -.16 • Shifting schools -.34
Rank these 8 effects: • Television • Distance education • Web based learning • Distance education • Audio-based teaching • Computer assisted instruction • Hypermedia instruction • Visual based/audio-visual teaching from 1 = highest effect to 8 = lowest effect
Waldorf School of the Peninsula Parents are happy to delay their children's engagement with technology Some education experts say that the push to equip classrooms with computers does not clearly show that this leads to better test scores or other measurable gains.
Separate the wheat from the chaff Useful practice vs Fashion effects or Zombies ideas (Technologies are promoted as solutions to serious educational problems, despite the evidence of past failures of technology to transform teaching and learning).
Is there a place for the digital world in education ? Yes • Coding (the king path) • Goals – challenging (.56) • Problem solving teaching (.61) • Meta-cognition strategies (.67) • Feedback (.70) • Creativity programs (.70)
Animation, Robotic and Fablab with 3D-printing … Scratch Kodable Tynker.
Other ways, and usual challenges • To find effective practices • Simulation tools • Digital games • Video • Interactive whiteboard • Artificially intelligent software • ...
3. Results (to reflect) • How does digital technology impact my practice? • How does the use of technology influence the way my students learn? • …
For instance • What about a possible effect on student’s emotions and metacognitive ability • Kalyuga & Liu, 2015; Park et al., 2015 & Mayer, 2008
Educatore-literacy:a specific categoryof beliefs and knowledge
To conclude • A requirement in most schools: • Teachers’ techno-pedagogical awareness and capacities • A triple challenge: • Resilience/Reason/Result • An additional dimension: • The Pedagogical triangle in the digital era?
The Pedagogical triangle + Technology Technical trend and determinism (Leroi-Gouran, Simondon) Technology
The good news Digital tools may help to support change
References • Cohen, D. (1990). A Revolution in One Classroom: The Case of Mrs. Oublier,” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 12(3), pp. 311-329. • Hattie, J. (2011). Visible learning for teachers. Routledge: New York. • Pollard, A. & alii. (2014). Reflective teaching in schools. Bloomsburry: London. • Simondon, G. (1989). Du mode d’existence des objets techniques. Aubier:Paris,
Challenges for teachers in the digital area Over the Pedagogical triangle Philippe Gabriel LIRDEF, and University of Avignon