E N D
ICT and Education IndicatorsUNESCO Institute for Statisticspresented by: Ko-Chih Tung, Regional Advisor for the UIS and Jon Kapp, Assistant Programme Specialist, UISwith contributions from Simon Ellis, UIS HQand the ICT in Education Unit, UNESCO BangkokJoint UNCTAD-ITU-UNESCAP Regional Workshop on Information Society Measurements27 July 2006
Context • World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) • Global monitoring role of UIS • AIMS-UIS Asia and Pacific Regional Office • UNESCO Bangkok
Introduction UIS and Information Society: • ICT and Education • establishing core global indicators for the Partnership • Potential for regular data collection for education statistics • ICT skills assessment through hhld survey: • Literacy Assessment and Monitoring Programme (LAMP) & Programme for International Assessment of Adult Competency (PIAAC) • Content and use of ICTs • work on Linguistic diversity • press and broadcast surveys
AIMS-UIS Regional Office • Supporting capacity building in the areas of monitoring, assessment and analysis of disparities in access to education • Planning for and coordinating the EFA Mid-Decade Assessment (2006-2007) • Developing manuals, guidelines and tools and instruments for better study, analysis and reporting on education data
Capacity building Requires: • prior political commitment from a Ministry concerned based on a policy commitment in national development plans • A co-ordinated approach including; regulators, NSOs, Ministries, ISPs/telecomms companies and NGOs • Sustained assistance in a groups of countries over a numbers of years to change the institution as well as the staff.
Need for stronger co-ordination • Need to co-ordinate statistical activities between regulators, Internet Service Providers, phone companies, ministries, and national statistics offices • Need to include ICT data collection in existing surveys • UNESCO’s help to countries in this major task • UIS statisticians permanently stationed in Africa, Asia and Latin America
Performance indicators on ICT use in education UNESCO Asia-Pacific ICT in Education Programme
UNESCO recognizes the potential of ICT to achieve EFA goals, in particular its ability to: • Enable the inclusion of groups with no access to education • Improve the quality of teaching & learning • Increase the efficiency & effectiveness in planning & administration
Our aim is to empower • Learners, • Teachers, educators • Principals, administrators • Leaders
Scope of the UNESCO Programme 6. Research & Knowledge Sharing 1.Education Policy 5. Monitoring & Measuring Change 2. Training of Teachers www.unescobkk.org/education/ict 3. Teaching & Learning 4. Non-Formal Education
Monitoring and Measuring Change Performance indicators are required to: • Monitor the use and assess the impact of technologies in education. • Demonstrate accountability
Indicators Project • Developing, pilot testing and promoting the institutionalization of indicators for ICT use in education systems. • Assessing the impact of ICT use on the teaching-learning process. • Pilot testing in India, Philippines and Thailand
Output Objectives The main objective of the manual is: • to provide practical guidelines on how to adopt/adapt the ICT indicators in measuring in turn the use and impact of ICTs in the educational system and in teaching and learning.
Contents • Definition, conceptual framework, purposes and criteria for validating ICT for education performance indicators • Validated matrix of indicators specifying the purposes of each indicator, source of data, how to collect, and the corresponding survey instruments for collecting data • Synthesis of three countries’ experiences and survey reports in pilot testing the performance indicators • Lessons learned in pilot testing the performance indicators
Contents, continued… • Steps in using the validated set of indicators to measure impact of ICT in education which cover survey design, data collection and processing • Ways in using the indicators to analyze the use of ICT in education • Ways of applying and mainstreaming indicators into the ICT for education programme and in the educational management information system. • Advocacy for the integration of performance indicators into the education system.
Proposed Performance Indicators Approximately 50 indicators, classified in 5 categories: • ICT-Based Policy and Strategy • ICT Infrastructure and Access • Curriculum/textbooks • Teaching Professionals Use and Teaching • Student Use and Learning
Thai pilot survey ~ students • Percentage of students with cell phone 20.1% with computer at home 40.1% with e-mail 5.9% • Percentage of students who can use a computer 22.7% use digital camera 7.8 % write a webpage 0.16% • Percentage of student using internet for education 9.9% internet at school 9.0% internet every week 3.2%
Thailand pilot survey ~ Teachers • ICT trained teachers 338,726 or 42.48% • Teachers per 1 PC in Primary schools 20:1 in Secondary schools 2:1 • Amongst teachers using ICT 85% used for instruction 15% used for administration • Percentage of teacher with cell phone 79% • Percentage of teacher with e-mail 13.7%
Other international data sources • Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA): • Important source of information on ICT for education at the primary and secondary levels • 2000 cycle: 28 OECD and 4 non-OECD countries participated • 2002 cycle: additional 11 countries participated • The PISA 2000 Technical Report: the first to provide a good picture of access, usage and impact of ICT in schools
UIS ICT and Education Paper and the Core Indicators • Was presented at WSIS Tunis • To establish a core set of indicators for ICTs in Education • Focussed on capacity of developing countries • Minimise burden of data collection and response • Use existing indicators to maximise existing data on survey design sampling etc. • Use school survey based data which can largely be collected through administrative systems and linked directly to educational processes
Suggested Basic Core of Indicators for ICT in Education Basic Core: 1.% of schools with electricity (by ISCED level 1-3) 2.% of schools with radio used for educational purposes (by ISCED level 0-4) 3. % of schools with television sets used for educational purposes (by ISCED level 0-4) 4. Student to computer ratio (by ISCED level 0-4) 5. % of schools with basic telecommunication infrastructure or telephone access (by ISCED level 1-4) 6. % of students who use internet at school (by ISCED level 1-4)
Indicators- contd.. • Extended Core: (i) % of students enrolled by gender at the tertiary level in an ICT-related field (by ISCED level 5-6) (ii) % of ICT qualified teachers in primary and secondary schools (of the total no. of teachers) (Note: all indicators should be collected by sex, grade and age)
Other areas of education work ICT skills assessment • LAMP; Literacy Assessment and Monitoring Programme. Includes questions on use and access to ICTs • PIAAC; Joint OECD/UIS adult skills assessment programme. First phase for implementation before 2009 includes questions on ICT skills
Challenges: Language • Language is the 1st barrier in using the Internet • UNESCO upholds rights of speakers of minority and endangered languages in society and in education • Language presents many technical barriers eg. coding
Languages ~ results so far • No agreement on count of web pages by language • Potential for regional observatories • Press and broadcast surveys will examine the use of mixed channels including Internet for distribution • Work underway to assess the quality of existing data on languages and how UNESCO can improve it • UIS literacy assessment and communications programmes looking at functional context for languages and learning
For further information, please visit: • www.unescobkk.org/aims • www.unescobkk.org/ict • or contact the AIMS unit: • Assessment, Information Systems, Monitoring and Statistics Unit (AIMS) • Office of the Regional Advisor for the UNESCO Institute for Statistics (UIS) • UNESCO Bangkok • Mom Luang Pin Malakul Centenary Building • 920 Sukhumvit Road • Bangkok 10110 Thailand • tel: +66 2 391 0577 fax: +662 391 0866