910 likes | 926 Views
Explore the significance of cultural understanding in global interactions, featuring insights on American and German similarities, pitfalls of cultural ignorance, and strategies for effective cross-cultural communication. Reflect on the impact of socialization within your own culture and uncover the hidden aspects of cultural diversity. Learn the secrets to becoming a successful global manager through empathy, observation, and adaptability.
E N D
How do people understand one another when they don’t share a common cultural experience?
Similarities • Anglo-Saxon background • monochronic • direct and honest • being on time • competitive and practical
The Trap of Similarity
Wal-Mart’s billion euro fiasco in Germany arrogance and ignorance managers culturally naïve, simple-minded driven by “time is money” didn’t create enough economies of scale
The unconscious projection of values is the source of cultural mishaps.
Understanding oneself and one’s own culture
Who understands others as well as oneself will be granted success in a thousand encounters. 3000 year-old Chinese proverb
“Culture hides more than it reveals and strangely enough what it hides, it hides most effectively from it’s own participants. Years of study have convinced me that the real job is not to understand foreign culture but to understand our own.” Edward Hall
Culture ? Life style of a people, I.e. the learned and shared patterns of beliefs, behaviors and values of a group of interacting people. (Bennett) Culture is the collective programming of the mind. (Hofstede) Culture is the water we live in. It surrounds us and defines us. (Chinese definition)
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.” The Declaration of Independence, 1776
Think about your own culture How did socialization take place in your own life? Try to recall some of the behaviors and values you were taught early in life. How do they affect you now?
Culture is to us what water is to a fish.
Culture is like an iceberg observable Not observable
Observable Not observable • • Manners • Clothes • Food • Newspapers, books • Monuments • Rituals, festivals • • History • Friendship • Time and space • Negotiation style • Communication style • Solutions to problems
Interculturalcommunications Everything is relative — no right or wrong solutions
Cross-cultural success Understanding the inner logic of a culture
The Four Secrets of Effective Global Managers They “know that they don’t know” Assume difference until similarity is proven, not the other way around. 2. They emphasize description Observe what is actually said and done rather than interpreting or evaluating. 3. They practice role reversal (empathy) Attempt to understand an international situation through the eyes of others. 4. They treat explanations as guesses, not as certainty. Check with colleagues from home and abroad if guesses are plausible.
Definition of a theory • mental viewing of how something might be • not meant to be exact
German American (Ger) (Am) Serious Easy-going Ger stereotype 3 Ger exception 2 Am exception 4 Amr stereotype
Hofstede’sDimensions • • Individualism / collectivism • Respect toward hierarchy • Desire for structure • Masculinity / femininity
Individualism Collectivism • • “we” society • group identity • important: harmony • relations over tasks • extended family • • “me” society • self-identity • important: pro-active • tasks over relations • success of individual
Individualism Collectivism GRE JAP ITA FRA PORT GER CAN SLO NETH SING GB KOR PL USA 0 20 40 60 100 80
More Hierarchy Less Hierarchy • • Inequalities not OK • Privileges/status not OK • Boss democratic • Flat hierarchy • Staff gives advice • • Inequalities OK • Privileges/status OK • Boss paternalistic • Strong hierarchy • Staff follows orders
More Hierarchy Less Hierarchy ITA USA FRA JAP NETH PL SPA GER SIN GRE GB POR SWE SLO 20 40 60 80 100 0
More Structure Less Structure • • Uncertainty O.K. • Willing to take risks • Non-orderly situations • Hope for success • Rational generalists • • There must be order • Many rules • Consensus • Desire for security • Experts und knowledge
More structure Less structure SLO PL KOR ITA SWE GER SPA SIN GB NETH JAP CAN POR FRA USA GRE 0 20 40 60 80 100
Should a manager have precise answers to subordinates’ questions?
Should a manager have precise answers to subordinates’ questions? 78% 66% 53% 46% 44% 38% 28% 23% 18% 17% Yes: DEN NETH USA GB CH BEL GER FRA ITA JAP
Understanding new behavior D = detect I = interpret E = evaluate
American meetings • An informal, relaxed attitude • Confident, positive approach • Brainstorming • Come to the point quickly • Active participation • Give credit for others’ achievements (piggyback)
Working on Projects Germans Americans Americans Germans tend to…. tend to think tend to…. tend to think PROJECT...collect “Why are they …chat informally “Why aren’t they IDEA information doing this?” about an idea doing anything?” PROJECT …get down to “They are cold and …begin with small “They are wasting MEETINGS business unfriendly.” talk time.” …present detailed “How can they …begin with “ They are not plans discuss the details brainstorming prepared for the at this stage?” meeting.” …express criticism “They don’t like …be enthusiastic “They are not openly each other.” about all the ideas sincere.” PROJECT …work individually “They don’t …hold frequent “They are too PROCESS on the tasks communicate or meetings; change many meetings; we assigned to them work as a team.” tasks as circum- can’t get our work stances change done.” believe clearly …believe continuous defined milestones contact guarantees guarantee success coordination
Cognitive Styles of Germans and Americans Interaction with reality, extracting, organizing and applying knowledge BASIC Germans Americans OUTLOOK tend to be more cautious, conceptual tend to be more optimistic, pragmatic OPENING Do we really need…? Can we have…? QUESTION ACQUIRING Structured way of knowing Hypothesis, testing way of knowing KNOWLEDGE Want solid theories, coherence Speculate with probabilities, risk taking Deductive: acting on the basis of one’s Inductive: understanding a situation through thorough understanding of the situation experimentation Declarative thinking: focusing on Procedural thinking: focusing on how to get description and explanation of situation things done Gather information from experts, logical Active experimentation: learn from peers, analysis of ideas brainstorming, “think out of the box” Importance of background information Importance of measurement data, and facts (historical context, “Zeitgeist:, sociology) (how tall, how much, statistics, etc.) APPLYING Development of strategic analysis Ability to get things done KNOWLEDGE Systematic planning Trial and error, learn by doing, can do Decisions are binding Decisions are guidelines
Masculinity Femininity • • Good working atmosphere • Care for others • Harmony • Solidarity • Modesty • People over materialism • • Performance • Polarization • Assertive • Competitive • Displaying success • Materialism over people
Masculinity Femininity USA GB NETH FRA CAN SLO GER ITA SPA PL SWE SIN JAP POR KOR GRE 0 20 40 60 80 100
Culture is communication Edward Hall
Hall’s Definition Culture determines the style of communication: indirect or direct
Direct (low context) Indirect (high context) • • Explicit • Context not important • Thinking-focused • Result-oriented • Masculine • • Implicit • Context important • Feeling-focused • Relationship-oriented • Feminine
Direct Indirect ITA NETH PL GER SPA FRA CH USA GB JAP 0 20 40 60 80 100
German directness British indirectness Jürgen wird an die Decke springen. Jürgen might tend to disagree. Kommen wir gleich zur Sache. I was wondering if could talk. Du sagst nur Blödsinn. I am not quite with you on that. Das kann nicht wahr sein. Hm, that’s an interesting idea. Wir werden dies nie unterschreiben. We’ll have to do our homework.
Monochronic Polychronic • • One activity at a time • Schedules very important • Task-oriented • Linear • Punctual • • Parallel activities • Plans are changed • Relationship-oriented • Interruptions • Punctuality unimportant
Monochronic Polychronic ITA NETH PL GER SPA JAP FRA CH USA GB 0 20 40 60 80 100
Lesson to be learned • US-German communication and co-operation • might not be as simple as it appears — • especially for Germans
Why do we stereotype?
Why do we stereotype? Natural impulse to categorize when reality is too complex to handle.
Stereotypes are helpful when: • consciously aware it’s a group norm • descriptive and not evaluative • modifiable
Cross-cultural perceptions perception of Americans perception of Germans • • process-oriented • • specialized, expert • • systematic, orderly • • precise, data-oriented • too formal • direct • • unstructured • energetic • first-name • seem happier • overly self-confident • narrow perspective of world
Visitors’ perceptions of Germans Those who speak German Those who don’t speak German • • perfectionist • slow to get to know • meticulous about deadlines • systematic, orderly • fair to a fault • eager to do right • • excessively detailed • • standoffish • • pushy • • stubborn • obsessed with rules • afraid of making mistakes