170 likes | 275 Views
Accounting and Settlements. Method for covering the costs incurred by each entity involved in providing an international call Based on bilateral, route-specific negotiations between carriers at each end of the route. The Basic Idea. Athens, Ohio. Athens, Greece.
E N D
Accounting and Settlements • Method for covering the costs incurred by each entity involved in providing an international call • Based on bilateral, route-specific negotiations between carriers at each end of the route
The Basic Idea Athens, Ohio Athens, Greece Costs at this end: access charges to Verizon, hauling call to Gateway switch Costs of international link (cable, satellite, etc.) Costs to OTE for terminating the call
Who pays who? OU Student pays AT&T Collection Rate for the call AT&T pays Settlement Rate to OTE (accounting rate times 50%) AT&T pays Verizon access charges
Basic Definitions • Collection Rate: long distance charge the customer pays to the originating carrier • Accounting Rate: negotiated rate that theoretically reflects the cost of hauling the long distance call on that specific route • Settlement Rate: negotiated split of the accounting rate between originating carrier and the terminating carrier (usually 50/50)
More definitions • Rule of proportionate return: carriers return traffic in the same proportion in which they receive it • Whipsawing: single provider at one end of the route seeking concessions from multiple carriers at the other end of the route • Transit routes: are taken for technical or economic reasons
Proportionate return 25% MCI 45% PTT/ Carrier AT&T 30% Sprint
Transit Route Country A Country B Country B = Transit Route Country C
What can go wrong? • Asymmetrical traffic • Accounting Rate > Cost • Accounting Rate > Collection rate
Activism of the FCC • US settlement deficit in 1996: $5.78B • US settlement deficit in 2000: $4B • US settlement deficits from 1985-2000: $52.8 B • IB Docket No. 96-261 (August 1997) • Benchmarks set for settlement rates • $0.15/minute for upper income countries • $0.19/minute for middle income countries • $0.23/minute for lower income countries • US carriers required to negotiate at or below benchmarks • transition periods of one to five years depending on economic status of country
Examples of Settlement Rates • As of 10/5/05 (still the same in January 2012): • Afghanistan: $5.15 • Burma: $3.75 • Chad: $2.43 • Vietnam: $1.19 • Kyrgyz Republic: $2.00 (Benchmark $.23) • Iraq: $2.00 • North Korea: $2.92
US International Settlement Policy has been (ISP) • Non-uniform accounting rates allowed but FCC and competitors must be informed • Waiver required from FCC for accounting rates that diverge in structure from the norm • Settlement rate must be 50/50 • US carriers not to negotiate exclusive rates and not to get more than proportionate return
International Simple Resale (ISR) • FCC policy to encourage ISR as way to undercut accounting and settlement system • To avoid one-way bypass, FCC limits routes on which US carriers may provide ISR: • For WTO Member countries, only where settlement rates for at least 50% of traffic on route is at or below benchmark, or foreign market allows equivalent resale • For Non-WTO member, only where 50% of traffic is at benchmark rates and foreign market offers equivalent resale
Try to avoid one-way bypass AT&T is not allowed to terminate traffic In Greece* using resale, so cannot avoid Paying settlement rates. AT&T OTE If OTE were allowed to terminate traffic in The US using resale, it could avoid Paying settlement rates. *this is just an illustration; ISR is now allowed in Greece
Removal of ISP • FCC Docket No. CC 99-73 (May 1999), in order to encourage lower settlement rates, allows removal of ISP: • For settlement arrangements between US carriers and foreign carriers that lack market power; • For all settlement arrangements on routes where US carriers are able to terminate at least 50% of the traffic at rates at least 25% below benchmark rate.
Routes exempt from ISP • In 2003, there were only 16 routes • Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, Hong Kong, Ireland, Italy, The Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, UK, Saudi Arabia, Monaco, Bermuda, Bosnia/Herzegovina, Algeria • March 11, 2004, FCC added more routes, including all of the routes approved for ISR • As of January 2012, 38 countries were still listed as subject to ISP
Definition of market power • A foreign carrier lacks market power if it possesses less than a 50% market share in each of the following foreign markets: • International transport facilities or services, including cable landing station access and backhaul facilities • Inter-city facilities or services • Local access facilities or services on the foreign end
Avoiding settlements • VoIP • Cross border service providers