1 / 12

英文中國哲學史著作讀書會 國立台灣大學哲學系 魏家豪 2008.10.11

A Source Book in Chinese Philosophy Ch. 18: Negative Taoism in the Lieh Tzu and the “ Yang Chu Chapter ”. 英文中國哲學史著作讀書會 國立台灣大學哲學系 魏家豪 2008.10.11. 導讀大綱. 本章之解釋 評論. 導讀大綱. 本章之解釋 評論. 本章的解釋. 學派關係 兩個不同的著作： 〈 楊朱 〉 hedonism + 其它 Negative Daoism. Daoism Equality of all things

caroun
Download Presentation

英文中國哲學史著作讀書會 國立台灣大學哲學系 魏家豪 2008.10.11

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. A Source Book in Chinese PhilosophyCh. 18: Negative Taoism in the Lieh Tzu and the “Yang Chu Chapter” 英文中國哲學史著作讀書會 國立台灣大學哲學系 魏家豪 2008.10.11

  2. 導讀大綱 • 本章之解釋 • 評論

  3. 導讀大綱 • 本章之解釋 • 評論

  4. 本章的解釋 • 學派關係 • 兩個不同的著作：〈楊朱〉hedonism + 其它 • Negative Daoism • Daoism • Equality of all things • Indifference to life and death • Following one’s nature • Accepting fate

  5. 本章的解釋 • Negative aspects • Hedonistic philosophy vs. no desire (楊朱) • Inaction as complete abadonment of effort • Forgetting about “nourishing nature” • Constructive aspect • Scepticism

  6. 本章的解釋 • 寫作年代 • 西元3世紀 (escapism) • 非原來的《列子》、〈楊朱〉 • Some original teachings (名實) • 《列子》 • 列子：西元前5世紀 • 《列子》西元前2世紀：遺失 • 大部分來自於其它的書，尤其是《莊子》

  7. 本章的解釋 • 〈楊朱〉 • 楊朱：大約西元前 440-360 • 大部分來自於其它的書 • Self-preservation (internal contradiction with indifference towards life and death) • Indulging in pleasure is not 楊朱’s position

  8. 本章的解釋 • 翻譯 – 挑選 • 〈楊朱〉 • 《列子》 • Skepticism 〈湯問〉、〈天瑞〉 • Fatalism 〈力命〉

  9. 導讀大綱 • 本章之解釋 • 評論

  10. 評論 • 待討論的觀點 • 來自於其它的書 • 名實 • Contradiction between self-preservation and indifference to life/death • Scepticism

  11. 評論 • 西方學者的研究 • Graham 1960-1961 以後，《列子》被忽略 • Deliberate forgery • 285年 以後 – 張湛以前 • 考證方法 • Shared passages (1/4) • Linguistic evidence • Unidentified material 1. Lost works 2. Designed according to Liu Xiang’s description

  12. 評論 Graham, A.C. 1960-1962 (1986). “The Date and Composition of the Lieh-tzu.” Asia Major, n.s. 8, 139-198. Reprinted In Studies in Chinese Philosophy and Philosophical Literature, edited by A.C. Graham. Singapore: National University of Singapore. 216-282. Loewe, Michael, ed. 1993. Early Chinese Texts: A Bibliographical Guide. Early China Special Monograph Series, no. 2. Berkeley: The Society for the Study of Early China and the Institute of East Asian Studies, University of California. 298-308.

More Related