1 / 15

Chapter 4: Evaluating the Author’s Message

Chapter 4: Evaluating the Author’s Message. Academic Reading , Fifth Edition by Kathleen T. McWhorter. Learning Objectives:. To make inferences and understand implied meanings To assess an author’s credentials To distinguish between fact and opinion To identify the author’s purpose

cburson
Download Presentation

Chapter 4: Evaluating the Author’s Message

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Chapter 4: Evaluating the Author’s Message Academic Reading, Fifth Edition by Kathleen T. McWhorter

  2. Learning Objectives: • To make inferences and understand implied meanings • To assess an author’s credentials • To distinguish between fact and opinion • To identify the author’s purpose • To evaluate the data and evidence • To analyze the author’s tone • To annotate as you read • To synthesize your ideas

  3. Making Inferences • An inference is a reasoned guess about what you don’t know based on what you do know. • Authors do not always directly state what they mean. Instead, they may only hint at or suggest an idea.

  4. Making Inferences “As Agatha studied Agnes, she noticed that her eyes appeared misty, her lips trembled slightly, and a twisted handkerchief lay in her lap.” Inference: Agnes is upset and on the verge of tears.

  5. How to Make Inferences • Understand the literal meaning first. • Notice details. • What is unusual or striking about this piece of information? • Why is it included here?

  6. How to Make Inferences • Add up the facts. • What is the writer trying to suggest from this set of facts? • What do all these facts and ideas seem to point toward or add up to? • Why did the author include these facts and details? • Be alert for clues. • Look back at the facts to verify your inference.

  7. How to Make Inferences • Consider the author’s purpose. • To purchase something? • To convince you of an idea? • To inform? • Look back at the facts to verify your inference.

  8. Assess the Author’s Ideas • Is the author a qualified expert? • What are the facts and opinions? • What is the author’s purpose? • Does the author support his or her generalizations? • What assumptions is the author making? • Is the author biased? • How strong are the data and evidence?

  9. Fact or Opinion? • Facts • Birth rates declined from 1960 to 1979. • The proportion of married women in the work force has steadily increased in the past 40 years. • Opinions • A drastic change is soon to occur in family structure. • Parenthood is the most rewarding human experience.

  10. Is the Author Biased? • Pay attention to emotional language. • Notice descriptive language. How does the author make you feel? • Look for opposing viewpoints. If there are none, it is biased.

  11. How Strong Are the Data and Evidence? • Personal experience or observation • Statistical data • Examples, descriptions of events • Analogies or comparisons with similar situations • Historical documentation • Experimental evidence

  12. How to React to Ideas Presented • Annotate as You Read. (p. 103) • Analyze and Evaluate Ideas • What did the author intend to accomplish? • How effectively did he or she accomplish it? • What questions does the work answer? • What questions are ignored or left unanswered? • What contributions to course content is made? • How does this work fit with your textbook? • What are strengths and weaknesses of material?

  13. Synthesize and Compare Sources • Compare for: • overall theme or position • types and quality of supporting evidence • degree of bias shown in each work • authority of each author • purpose of each author • points of agreement and disagreement • effectiveness of each work to persuade you • style • audience

  14. Summary Questions • How do you make inferences as you read? • What questions do you ask to assess an author’s ideas? • What questions do you ask to react to an author’s ideas? • What questions do you ask to compare and synthesize several works?

  15. Read the articles on sociology/contemporary issues and answer the questions at the end of each selection. “Why Drug Legalization Should Be Opposed” by Charles Rangel “Let’s Retire the Drug War” by Jacob G. Hornberger

More Related