170 likes | 187 Views
Explore the determinants shaping future urbanization, housing development, and land use in the 21st-century Indian city. Delve into demand drivers, supply effects, public sector roles, and socio-economic impacts of public housing policies. Gain insights from global housing schemes and U.S. housing policies.
E N D
The 21st Century Indian City:Developing an Agenda for Urbanization in India New Delhi, India March 23-25, 2011
Panel #5: The Politics and Economics of Land and Housing March 24, 2011 12:00 Noon – 1:45 p.m.
The Determinants of the Future of Urbanization, Housing and Land Development By Robert H. Edelstein Fisher Center for Real Estate and Urban Economics University of California, Berkeley
Outline of Lynchpin Issues • International Context • Demand Drivers • Supply and Legacy Effects • Public Sector Multi-faceted Roles
Longer-Run Complications and Impediments to Growth • World Demographic Drivers • Retirement • Health Care • India Demographic Dividend • International Resource Competition • Energy Supply and Demand • Protein Upgrade • Pollution Control • Clean Industry • Inflation Scenarios
B. Demand Drivers • Housing Demand is a Derived Demand • Income, Financial Resources, and Housing Prices • Transportation Networks • Congestion/Density/Quality of Life
India-Center Issues • Income Distribution • Middle Class • Urban vs. Rural • Demographic • Growth Rate • Age Distribution • Hierarchy of Cities • Premier, Secondary, & Tertiary Areas
National Urbanization % Urban Population
India, China: Age Distribution Source: World Bank
C. Supply and Legacy Effects • Land Use Density Determinants – • Transportation Network • Land Usage Rules and Practices • Construction Industry and Technology • Spatial Employment Distribution • Technological Component • Existing Ownership Patterns and Land Use Governance • Competitive Hierarchy of Cities • Industrial Location and Mix • Export/Import Models
D. Public Sector Multi-faceted Roles • Demand Side Policies • The Singapore Model • The U.S. Private-Public Model • Supply Side Policies • Land Use Planning, Use Control, and Management • Infrastructure Optimization • The Regulatory Functions of the Residential Financial System • The U.S. Great Depression Structuring vis-à-vis the Subprime Crisis • Consumerism and Financial Rights • Financial Institutional Oversight • Secondary Market Organization and Monitoring
Socio-Economic Impact of Public Housing: Lessons from Singapore • A singular feature of the residential market in Singapore is the existence of a small private housing sector alongside a large state-sponsored and regulated public housing sector. Almost 86% of Singapore’s population live in public housing. • Capital gains from the HDB (public) secondary market are a significant factor in easing entry into higher quality private housing. • Public housing supports upward mobility from entry level housing; helps generate initial wealth accumulation. • Public housing is key determinant of overall housing market dynamics.
US National/State and Local Housing Policy • Supply side • Developer Tax credits for low income housing units • Redevelopment programs with tax increment financing set asides for housing (package deals) • Local fair share and below market rate requirements • Demand side • Homeowner mortgage interest tax credit • First-time homebuyer credits (temporary) • Mortgage guarantee system and GSEs • Rental housing vouchers
Lessons from Affordable Housing Schemes from Around the World • Impact of zoning • Stringent quality standards can reduce supply • Allocation of land to non-residential uses • Fiscal zoning, i.e. stress on commercial usage • Clear relationship between regulatory bottlenecks, land-use regulations and supply elasticities on one hand and house prices on other
Daily Vehicle- Miles of Travel per Capita v. Residential Density Source: Bardhan, Edelstein and Kroll from from U.S. Department of Transportation Smart Growth America
HOUSEHOLD DEBT AND INCOME Sources: IMF, ADB, Euro Stat, CEIC, TIM Analysis