100 likes | 211 Views
Lecture 4 – The Problems of Mind ( Think , pp.49-65). Thinking about the mental The mind-body problem The problem of intentionality The problem of consciousness Persons and Personal Identity (Next week). Thinking About the Mental. Three General Questions: 1/ What are minds?
E N D
Lecture 4 – The Problems of Mind(Think, pp.49-65) Thinking about the mental The mind-body problem The problem of intentionality The problem of consciousness Persons and Personal Identity (Next week)
Thinking About the Mental Three General Questions: 1/ What are minds? How are mind and body related? What are persons? What does it mean to be the same person over time? Could machines have minds? Inentionality Consciousness
2/ How do we gain knowledge about minds? Our own minds? First-Person Authority and Privileged Access Other Minds? Argument from Analogy Non-Humans
3/ What are the “contents” of our minds? Cognitive states (Have a “direction-of-fit”) -Beliefs -Suppositions -Knowledge Affective states (Have a feeling associated with them) -emotions -perceptions -feelings -moods
The Mind-Body Problem Substance Dualism -mind and body distinct substances -causal interaction? -interactionism (Descartes) -occasionalism (Malebfranche) -pre-established harmony (Leibniz)
Property Dualism (Donald Davidson – “Anomalous Monism”) -mental properties distinct from physical properties -mental properties not reducible to physical properties -not committed to existence of two distinct kinds of substance
Materialism and the Mind Identity Theories (Type vs. Token) Eliminative Materialism Behaviourism Functionalism
Intentionality What makes our mental images/ beliefs about things in the world??? -causal connections? -resemblance/similarity??
The Problems of Consciousness The phenomenological aspect of the mental was ignored for some time -can there be a scientific account of consciousness? -can there be a materialistic theory of consciousness
Some Problems Raised by Consciousness Ownership Mechanism “Zombies” Inverted Spectrum Location of pains