1 / 23

Social Security Reform: The Latin American experience

Social Security Reform: The Latin American experience. Alvaro Castro-Gutiérrez Actuary ASA (Association of Swiss Actuaries) International Social Security Consultant Geneva, 2004. The social security reform debate The current situation : Is there still a debate?

coy
Download Presentation

Social Security Reform: The Latin American experience

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Social Security Reform: The Latin American experience Alvaro Castro-Gutiérrez Actuary ASA (Association of Swiss Actuaries) International Social Security Consultant Geneva, 2004

  2. The social security reform debate • The current situation: Is there still a debate? • The Latin American experience 2

  3. The social security reform debate • Mandatory national public pension schemes: • from funding to pay-as-you-go (PAYG) • Features: • Defined benefits (DB), changing contribution rates to ease financing • Problems: • (a) vulnerability of funded schemes to economic changes 3

  4. The social security reform debate • Mandatory national public pension schemes: • from funding to pay-as-you-go (PAYG) (2) • Problems: • (b) vulnerability of PAYG schemes to demographic changes • (c) Administrative issues 4

  5. The social security reform debate • National pension schemes: • Reasons for problems in DB schemes • - General: • Financial and economic cost • Demographic burden • Therefore: unsustainable in the medium-term 5

  6. The social security reform debate • Reasons for problems in DB schemes (2) • - Specific: • Low level of benefits provided • Limited coverage • Multiplicity of schemes 6

  7. The social security reform debate • Reasons for problems in DB schemes (3) • - Specific: • Costly schemes • Low investment returns • Contribution evasion • Poor (public) administration 7

  8. The social security reform debate • Current solutions: parametric changes • Raising contribution levels • Reducing benefit levels • Raising retirement age 8

  9. The social security reform debate • Current solutions: parametric changes (2) • Making qualifying conditions less generous for entitlements • Promoting complementary schemes • Parametric changes are difficult to implement from a political perspective 9

  10. The social security reform debate • The proposed solution: structural change by means of a: • Defined contribution(DC) • Individual accounts • Fully funded • Privately managed • mandatory pension funds system 10

  11. The social security reform debate • The debate has expanded to take account of social and other aspects: • An ideological issue: the role of the state • and the public sector in society • (or the appropriate public-private mix) • A general issue: A multi-pillar system of social security protection 11

  12. The current situation: Is there still a debate? • An enlarged debate: Five basic goals for pension reform • Social acceptability • Financial sustainability • Political feasibility • Coherence with economic • and labour market realities • Client-friendly management • and administration 12

  13. The current situation: Is there still a debate? • An enlarged debate: The multi-pillar principle • First: mandatory, contributory DB • Second: mandatory, privately managed, individual accounts DC • Third: voluntary, privately managed, savings • A political, social and economic issue: • Which should be the relative importance • of the different pillars? 13

  14. The Latin American experience • Eleven national structural reforms since 1981 • Three different approaches (or models): • Substitutive • parallel • mixed 14

  15. The Latin American experience • Substitutive • Chile (1981) • Bolivia and Mexico (1997) • El Salvador (1998) • Nicaragua and Dominican Republic (2003) • Old (public) sytem  Phased out • New private system 15

  16. The Latin American experience • Parallel • Peru (1993) • Colombia (1994) • Old (public) sytem  Reformed • Compete with a new private system 16

  17. The Latin American experience • Mixed • Argentina (1994) • Uruguay (1996) • Costa Rica (200) • Public scheme  Basic pension • Private scheme  Complementary pension 17

  18. The Latin American experience • Reform linked with political processes • Persistence of traditional problems • Resurgence of new areas of conflict • The fiscal cost of transition • Need to enhance the role of the State in • fundamental areas (regulation, monitoring, • supervision and control) of the system 18

  19. The Latin American experience • Role of the actuary: Past, present and future • No participation in the reform debate (when there was a debate); social security policy makers were also absent • Not relevant role at present, but potential development for actuarial expertise • Promising future role in investment and annuity areas 19

  20. The Latin American experience • Persistence of traditional problems • Limited population coverage • Non-compliance (high evasion) • Lack of confidence in the new systems due to lack of transparency 20

  21. The Latin American experience • Resurgence of new areas of conflict • High transaction and administration costs • Mergers and concentration of pension • funds administrators • Limited investment portfolio diversification • Likely low levels of future benefits 21

  22. The Latin American experience • The fiscal cost of transition • Public system deficit • Recognition bonds • Minimum pensions • Additional guarantees • Trade-off 22

  23. The Latin American experience • Need to enhance the role of the State • in fundamental areas • Regulation • Monitoring • Supervision • Control 23

More Related