80 likes | 193 Views
CS 268: Lecture 25 Indirection. Ion Stoica Computer Science Division Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences University of California, Berkeley Berkeley, CA 94720-1776. DNS Server. Home Agent. “foo.org”. (IP home ,data). foo.org IP foo. IP home IP mobile. IP foo.
E N D
CS 268: Lecture 25Indirection Ion Stoica Computer Science Division Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences University of California, Berkeley Berkeley, CA 94720-1776
DNS Server Home Agent “foo.org” (IPhome,data) foo.org IPfoo IPhome IPmobile IPfoo (IPmobile,data) (IPdst:Pdst,data) (IPfoot,data) IPfoo IPmofile DNS Mobile IP NAT Box (IPM,data) (IPnat:Pnat,data) IPnat:Pnat IPdst:Pdst Internet (IPMIPR1) (IPMIPR2) (IPR2,data) (IPR1,data) IPdst IPR2 IPR1 NAT IP Multicast Indirection is Everywhere!
Why Indirection? • Decouple sender behavior from receiver behavior • Receiver movements and address changes transparent to sender • Changes in the number of receivers, transparent to sender • …
Discussion • Control • Indirection point point wherecontrol is transferred from sender to receiver • Translation/forwarding entry usually controlled by receiver • Resolution • Early binding (e.g., DNS, SIP, HIP) • Late binding (e.g., Mobile IP, NAT,IP multicast, IP anycast)
End-host Empowerment • Both the sender and receiver should be able to explicitly control the service-path • Note: multiple indirection points possible Internet Application Layer Service (ALS) 1 ALS 2 ALS 3 ALS 4 Receiver Indirection point (tussle boundary) Sender sender control receiver control
ALS 2 (S2) ALS 1 (S1) ([idS1,idR], data) i3 idS2 S2 ids1 S1 R Internet i3 Name resolution infrastructure (e.g., OpenDHT) idS2 S2 idS1 idS1 S1 idR R S1 idS2 R idR S2 ([idS1,idS2], data) idS2 idR R idR [idS2,R] ALS 1 (S1) ALS 2 (S2) Internet DOA Realization: i3 vs DOA
Discussion: DOA vs. HIP vs. i3 (1/2) • Naming: Flat ID space • DOA: two levels of IDs • EID: end-host IDs • SID: service IDs • Resolution: (SIDEID); (EIDIPaddr) • HIP • HIT: host identity tag • Resolution: (HITIPaddr) • i3 • ID: identifies “anything” • Resolution: (ID[IPaddr:Port]), where [IPaddr:Port] represents de-multiplexer
Discussion: DOA vs. HIP vs. i3 (2/2) • Resolution: • HIP and DOA: early binding • i3 : late binding: • Lookup & Forwarding • i3: combines lookup & forwarding infrastructure • Degenerates to a lookup infrastructure when shortcuts are used • DOA: forwarding state at ALSes