1 / 15

ASSETnet: Assets and ethnicity network

ASSETnet: Assets and ethnicity network. Dr Omar Khan , Head of Policy Research. About Runnymede. The Runnymede Trust is an independent policy research organisation fighting for racial justice through: High quality research and analysis Engaging communities Influencing policy.

darryl
Download Presentation

ASSETnet: Assets and ethnicity network

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. ASSETnet: Assets and ethnicity network Dr Omar Khan, Head of Policy Research

  2. About Runnymede • The Runnymede Trust is an independent policy research organisation fighting for racial justice through: • High quality research and analysis • Engaging communities • Influencing policy

  3. About ASSETnet Aim is to spread awareness and raise interest • About asset-building policies among race equality and other organisations • About ethnicity among those already committed to asset-building Three elements • Social media site (please join!) • National workshops/events (UK, Germany, Hungary, Spain, Belgium) • Policy conference in Brussels (February 2012)

  4. Why Assets Matter: Evidence Assets are far more unevenly distributed in the UK than income • Anywhere from 10–20% of people have no assets at all • Wealthiest 1% owned approximately a fifth of the UK’s marketable wealth... Half the population shared only 7% of total wealth • Two-thirds of British households in Britain have less than £3000 in non-housing savings and assets. • Housing: • 40% of the total wealth in the UK, or £6875 billion, is held in housing. • In 2003, half the UK population owned only 1% of non-housing assets. • Consequences: less choices, social mobility, ability to provide for children, and social cohesion

  5. Why Assets Matter: Ethnicity • 60% of Asian and Black British people have no savings at all, twice the rate for white people. Less diverse too.

  6. Why Assets Matter: Arguments • Social mobility: fair life chances as well as efficient markets require more people to have assets • Behavioural: ‘while income feeds people’s stomachs, assets change their minds’ (Sherraden, 1991) • Freedom: Expands choices • Citizenship; people hold a ‘stake’ in their society. Integration/Cohesion Different arguments for asset-building lead to different policies

  7. Why Assets Matter: Policies Policies in UK focused on savings and behavioural arguments (start habit). Not redistributive, citizenship or freedom. • Child Trust Fund, Saving Gateway: scrapped • NEST: auto-enrolled pensions scheme for low-income. Growth and security • Housing: shared ownership, other schemes • Asset inequality and taxation: • No asset-based tax policies for low-income people; tax incentives on ISAs and pensions as asset-based policies for upper income quintiles • Inheritance tax and wealth tax? • Council tax or property tax? Revenue used to provide assets for all? • Shared or collective ownership: a variety of policies for everyone to own in (part-)publicly owned institutions or in public goods. Details important.

  8. Ethnicity and asset-holding in the UK • Evidence that 60% have no savings • Bangladeshi and African with less than one tenth White British asset-holding • Following slides explain labour market experience • However, might expect migrants to have less • No intergenerational inheritance • Labour market access: social networks, qualifications, (perceived) language • But evidence that British-born BME men more likely to be unemployed than foreign born fathers (Heath and Li)

  9. Low income and ethnicity Income poverty rate by ethnicity, 2002-5 • Bangladeshi (65%), Pakistani (55%), White British (20%) • Reflects unemployment but also poor quality work

  10. Proportion of working population in self-employment by ethnicity, 2007 Self-employment (%) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 White All BME Pakistani Bangladeshi Chinese Mixed Indian Other Black Black African Self-employment and ethnicity • Pakistani and Bangladeshi with highest rates • Most British-born groups lower than migrants, except above • Discrimination as cause? In recruitment(DWP survey), and progression (RfO research)

  11. Ethnicity and self-employment by sector Chinese (72%) and Bangladeshi (63%) much more likely to be in Catering. Pakistani (36%) and Black African (17%) much more likely to work in Transport . Higher income volatility, greater chance of business failure, and no employer pensions contribution or other benefits Industry of self-employment by ethnicity (males), 2001 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Chinese Bangladeshi Indian Pakistani White Black Caribbean Black African DistHotelCater Manufacturing Transport Construction Finance Other 11

  12. Conclusion: Questions for microfinance • Do we want ‘repeat’ customers? Danger is that lose best clients as they build up savings or improve credit score or business skills to get ‘mainstream’ loan. • Why people need microfinance: in part because they have no savings or assets • Can microfinance institutions develop alternative policies, including short-term AND long-term savings? • Should all assets be ‘leveraged’ • If focus on self-employment and entrepreneurship, how ensure social protection and rights, in particular pensions? • Are we reaching migrants and ethnic minorities, or are they being channeled into particular sectors?

  13. Contact us • To discuss our research and work, please contact • Omar Khan • omar@runnymedetrust.org • 020 7377 9222

  14. BME people and pensioner poverty • Risk of pensioner poverty by ethnicity, 2007-8 • All (18%), Black Caribbean (30%), Pakistani & Bangladeshi (49%)

  15. Why are BME people poor when older? • Less likely to have pensions… (2005-6) • Less able to compensate with other assets – • Savings • Home ownership (2005)

More Related