1 / 24

The Study

Study on the Social and Labour Market Integration of Ethnic Minorities Contract No. VC/2006/0309 of the European Commission Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA) December 3, 2008 Bremerhaven. The Study. Conducted October 2006 - December 2007 by the

dea
Download Presentation

The Study

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Study on the Social and Labour Market Integration of Ethnic MinoritiesContract No. VC/2006/0309of the European CommissionInstitute for the Study of Labor (IZA)December 3, 2008Bremerhaven

  2. The Study Conducted October 2006 - December 2007 by the Institute for the study of Labor (IZA) for the HLG and EC

  3. Outline of the Study • Ethnic Minorities in the European Union: An Oveview • Country Studies • Attitudes • IZA Expert Opinion Survey • A Policy Matrix • Evaluation of Integration Initiatives • Policy Conclusions

  4. Ethnic Minorities in European Union:An Overview • Severe lack of data • However, no picky debate about measurement concepts can hide the worrisome reality of ethnic minorities in Europe • Ethnic minorities tend to have • higher unemployment rates • lower occupational attainment and wages • lower participation rates

  5. Ethnic Minorities in European Union:An Overview • In Western Europe the at-risk ethnic minorities are typically of immigrant origin • In Central and Eastern Europe it is the (indigenous) Roma that face the most serious risks of exclusion

  6. Country Studies • Surveyed countries: • Denmark, France, Germany, Hungary, Latvia, The Netherlands, Romania,Slovakia, Spain, The United Kingdom • Key observations: • Main integration barriers include human capital gap, the lack of language skills, and discrimination (in the labor market and beyond) • Economic growth seems to reduce but not eliminate labor market gaps • Immigration policy and self-selection of immigrants are some of the key determinants of immigrants’ labor market integration • Immigration and integration policies vary, more recently language courses and entry requirements applied • The main integration barriers in Germany • Neglect of integration issues under the misperception of the temporary character of migration • Low human capital (e.g. lack of vocational training) of immigrants • Concentration in parts of Germany undergoing restructuralization • Often negative attitudes

  7. Country Studies: Germany • Unemployment: Positive and growing labor market gap

  8. Attitudes • Negative attitudes one of the greatest integration barriers • Self-reported ethnic discrimination in % of total population, European Social Survey (ESS)

  9. Attitudes • Self-reported discrimination in % of minority population, ESS • Analytical results using the ESS • Young, educated, or working people have more positive attitudes

  10. IZA Expert Opinion Survey • Insights into the opinions of various expert stakeholders • non-governmental organizations • governmental institutions • employers’ and employees’ associations • Threefold objective: • measure the experts’ perceptions and concerns about the labour market integration of ethnic minorities • capture the experts’ opinions about the perceptions of ethnic minorities in their country on various issues concerning their labour market integration and integration policy initiatives • identify business and private, non-governmental, and public initiatives aimed at labour market integration of ethnic minorities and evaluate their success. • Online questionnaire • 215 experts from 27 EU countries (almost 30% ethnic minority) • 192 integration initiatives

  11. Risk of Exclusion: Level • Medium to high. Social and labor market exclusion a serious problem

  12. Risk of Exclusion: Trend • This risk is increasing

  13. Minorities at Greatest Risk • Africans and Roma or Sinti

  14. Changes Desired? • Almost all minorities want to change their situation

  15. Where Changes Desired? • Especially in paid employment, attitudes, education and housing

  16. Who is Responsible for Changes? • National and local governments, but also the EC and EU and minority representatives

  17. Preferred Policy Principles • Equal treatment

  18. Integration Barriers • Discrimination, education, language, institutions (legal provisions)

  19. Desired Intervention • Especially public

  20. Integration Initiatives: Success Factors • Besides the usual efficiency factors, acceptance by minority and majority, fair treatment, and communication are essential.

  21. The Policy Matrix • A tool to compare and scale the minorities’ situation • Measures the risk of LM exclusion risk and its trend • IZA Expert Opinion Survey, 4 largest m. • The NE corner requires most policy attention

  22. Case Studies: Integration Initiatives • Qualitative approach • 22 examples of integration initiatives successful in some aspects • Covers all regions of the EU, small and large companies, mostly business initiatives • Good practice • Fairness vis-à-vis all partners and transparent rules facilitate trust, social relationships and positive perceptions • Voluntary participation and strict and transparent selection rules ensure motivation and positive image. • Fair and equal treatment mitigates resentment, facilitates public support, and alleviates stigmatization of the minority • Positive action is accepted as a transitory measure to overcome exclusion • Merit based remuneration creates feelings of self-worth, prompts work discipline, and strengthens the support of the majority • Cooperation between stakeholders breeds functional relationships • Long term commitment is on of the most important success factors

  23. Policy Conclusions • The situation is worrisome • Integration is possible • Targeted action is necessary, must take into account specific issues • General integration measures serve to combat discrimination and create environment empowering stakeholders to take targeted action • General and targeted actions need to be balanced, complementary and reinforcing • All measures need to be persistent to allow for time necessary to become effective and flexible to account for changes in the society • Persistence is especially important when tackling cultural issues such as perceptions and attitudes.

  24. Martin Kahanec (IZA) IZA, P.O. Box 7240, 53072 Bonn, Germany Phone: +49 (0) 228 - 38 94 -529 Fax: +49 (0) 228 - 38 94 180 E-mail: kahanec@iza.org http://www.iza.org

More Related