350 likes | 493 Views
NIPPC’s IIBA Initiative Agenda 7 December 2007. Introduction – independent, integrated Balancing Authority (IIBA) Overview Why? What? How? When? Who? Costs/Benefits Tangible Assessment Intangible Assessment Operations (user interface) Optimal Generation Mix Contractual Structure
E N D
NIPPC’s IIBA Initiative Agenda7 December 2007 • Introduction – independent, integrated Balancing Authority (IIBA) • Overview • Why? • What? • How? • When? • Who? • Costs/Benefits • Tangible Assessment • Intangible Assessment • Operations (user interface) • Optimal Generation Mix • Contractual Structure • Procedural Next Steps • Timeline
Introduction • Pacific Northwest Independent Integrated Balancing Authority (IIBA) • Meeting Protocol • Project Participants: • Project Lead: • CECD - Constellation Energy Control & Dispatch • Technical, Operational and Policy Support • Energy Expert Services • NIPPC • Opatrny Consulting • The Energy Group • Versify Solutions • Legal and Contracting Support • K&L Gates • Van Ness Feldman • Generators • NIPPC generators • Potentially other generators
OverviewWhy is the IIBA a good idea? • It will enable generators to: • Get paid for what they provide now for free, e.g., frequency and voltage support, reactive supply • Reduce operating expenses, e.g., operating reserves, generation imbalance, integration charges • It will allow money-making opportunities and add value to competitive markets: • Redispatch around transmission constraints • Support the integration of wind (indirectly or directly) • Pool transmission • It will allow generators: • Greater autonomy • To play by market rules, not just BPA’s rules • New opportunities as well as new responsibilities • Last chance to operate as merchants • These opportunities need to be prioritized and sequenced
OverviewWhat is the IIBA? • CECD sets-up/implements/certifies the BA • The BA is a reliability function • The BA function requires communications links and AGC • The participating generators separately contract with CECD in order to: • Integrates resources • Maintains interchange-generation balance • Supports interconnection frequency • Manages transmission for these purposes • As a BA, the participating generators will be enabled to: • Sell regulation to support the integration of wind • Participate in operating reserve sharing (through the NWPP) • Self-providing or contracting with third-parties for operating reserves
OverviewHow is a BA Established? • Certification Decision • Prepare Questionnaire for NERC and WECC • On-site Visit • Address Minimum Operating Reliability Criteria • Generation Control Performance • Transmission • Interchange • System Coordination • Emergency Operations • Operations Planning • Telecommunications • Operating Personnel and Training • This Process Takes About Six Months; there is a Six Month Probation
OverviewWhen does this make sense to do? • Why not now? • There is a recognize lack of business opportunities in the region • There are no plans to aggregate BAs in the PNW • The region is hamstrung by hourly block markets • Transmission constraints are being operated through BPA federal resource redispatch and curtailment • BPA is projecting significant wind integration through 2010 (i.e., 6,000 MW) • The region is now “capacity” constrained • Light-load hours • Heavy-load hours • There is a need for within hour regulation • Renewable portfolio standards are drivers
OverviewWho could participate? • Operating Resources • Calpine • Hermiston, OR 630 MW gas CCCT • EPCOR • Fredrickson/Tacoma, WA 125 MW gas CCCT • Mint Farm Energy Center LLC • Longview, WA 286 MW gas CCCT • NESCO • Sumas, WA N/A gas CCCT • Sierra Pacific • Mt. Vernon, WA 28 MW biomass/cogen • Suez Energy America • Chehalis, WA 520 MW gas CCCT • TransAlta • Centralia, WA 1404 MW coal 248 MW gas CCCT • Resources Under Construction • Grays Harbor Energy Center LLC 650 MW gas CCCT • NW Energy Partners (enXco) 125 MW wind • Resources Permitted but Not Constructed • Horizon • Ellensburg, WA 125 MW wind • Arlington, OR 125 MW wind Source: Robert Kahn
Costs/BenefitsWhat will this Arrangement Cost? • Estimated Cost of Arrangement • Start-up/Implementation/Certification • $175,000 first entrant • $35,000 for each additional • Communications and hardware • Balancing Authority Service Operations • $60,000/month first entrant • $12,000/month for each additional • The CECD Balancing Authority Services Agreement is an instrument already in operation
Cost/BenefitsExperience of Other BAs • Value of Load-only or Gen-only BA • Greater control over future commodities purchasing, risk and price management • Eliminate exposure to Generation Imbalance charges • Become a front runner rather than a follower • Take active role in Business Management and Regulatory and Compliance Issues • Actively involved in managing Transmission
Cost/BenefitsWhat will this Arrangement Save? • The BA will result in direct savings • Generation Imbalance Charges • Integration Charges ($3.10 – $4.80/MWh) • Operating Reserves (BPA’s rate is $7.93/MWh) • The BA will enable intangible benefits • Provide needed in-hour services • Enhance redispatch opportunities • Reliability • Planning • Pool transmission • Avoid/reduce regulatory interface costs • Improve output profile (wind farm diversity) • Enhance Renewable Portfolio Standard Opportunities
Costs/BenefitsHow can benefits be analyzed? • Evaluate BPA Tariff • Generation Imbalance • Avoid Generation Imbalance (BPA) • Band 1: +2 MW or +1.5% of scheduled energy • No charge if returned • Charged, if not returned, at diurnally-differentiated incremental cost • Band 2: Greater than +2 MW or +1.5% of scheduled energy • Charged 110% incremental cost • Credited 90% of incremental cost • Band 3: Greater than +10 MW or +7.5% of scheduled energy • Charged 125% incremental cost; • Credited 75% of incremental cost • Operating Reserves (quantity and price) • Integration Charge (if applicable) • Intangible Benefits • Identify which benefits need further evaluation • Case-by-case, e.g., pooled transmission • Generic analysis using existing data sets
Company Overview • Headquartered in Chadds Ford, PA (Philadelphia) • Focused on software applications and tools in two areas of the power industry • Generation asset performance management (V-PerformanceTM) • Trading – LMP and market data analysis (V-TraderTM) • Advanced web-based software architecture with robust and secure data management capabilities and unique user interface • 15 customers and growing • Partnership with Constellation Energy Control and Dispatch
Key Functionality • Real time monitoring and full range of asset performance dashboard reports • Operational and performance dashboards • Unit performance reports • Daily operational reports • Key functionality enabled through web-based architecture • Integrates data from CECD PI, dispatch and other systems • Complete visualization of asset performance • Common view of operational status • Summary/graphical reporting with drill down capability • Simplifies data intensive collection and analysis • Security manager allows user-based report access
Applications Full range of software applications to analyze, monitor and report on plant operations • Dashboard Reports • Unit Status • Event Log • Real-Time Monitor • SCADA Query Tool • Daily Reports • Unit Performance
Dashboards The Operations Dashboard summarizes weather, energy, emissions data and reports KPI type data, such as availability and capacity factor.
SCADA Query Tool Ad hoc charting and reporting of SCADA/historical data to assist back office and settlement activities.
Optimal Generation Mix • Define Optimal Mix of Generators • Diversity in Fuel Mix • Anchor tenant resources • Sequencing additional resources • Diversity among same Fuel type, e.g., wind • Geographic Diversity in terms of Resource Location • Geographic Diversity in terms of Location of Loads • Various Renewable Portfolio Standards • Transmission Access • Constraints can further enable redispatch • Opportunities (e.g., counter-flows)
IIBA Participants Sierra Pacific 28 MW Biomass EPCOR 125 MW Wind Energy System Grays Harbor 650 MW Horizon 125 MW Natural Gas CT/CCCT TransAlta 1404 MW Coal 248 MW CCCT Baseload Coal Suez Chehalis 520 MW Goodnoe Hills 125 MW Mint Farm 286 MW Calpine Hermiston 630 MW
BC Hydro Load Centers - Interties Puget Sound Energy Snohomish PUD Seattle City Light Tacoma Power 5,000 MW est. Avista Spokane, WA BPA Public Power Customers Idaho Power NWE PacifiCorp Walla Walla, WA PacifiCorp PGE Portland, OR John Day (PACI) Big Eddy (PDCI)
Constrained Flowgates BC Hydro Hydroelectric Projects Wind Energy Systems Thermal Powerplants
Who are the Anchor Tenants? • Any resource can be the anchor tenant • Needed to initiate the BA certification process • Realize cost savings • Fossil fuel resource can support wind integration • In-hour shaping • Between hour shaping • Back-off generation during off-peak hours • Wind can provide other opportunities • Enable RPS opportunities • Further cost savings through avoidance of integration charges • Potential wind farm diversity to improve capacity factor
Contractual Structure • Contractual Arrangement • The Balancing Authority • Execute BA Services Agreement • The BA will not engage in commercial transactions • The BA will offer services to enhance the value of member generators • The BA generators can be “interconnected” through transmission and dynamic schedules • The Generators • Execute the BA Services Agreement (cross contracts) • The Generators will sell to end-users • The Generators will address pooling opportunities • Advise was to not limit participants • No “Anti-trust” issues identified • The purpose is to facilitate commerce – enhance competition • A bid structure will need to be designed for services • Information sharing as long as such doesn’t impact competition
Procedural Next Steps • Simple Start • Stage this Concept • Arrange Policy Representation (NIPPC) • Allow for full Expansion • NERC certification • Process requirements • WECC recognition • Process requirements
Procedural Next Steps • The IIBA would need to • Become a member of the WECC • Become a member of the PNSC • Become a member of the NWPP • Reserve Sharing Group • Consider signing the Western Interconnection Agreement (release of liability) • Consider joining ACE Diversity Interchange
Timeline • Other questions? • Define policy/PR needs for this effort. • Execute Balancing Services Agreement (December 2007) • Initiate certification process (January 2008) • Engage in BPA’s wind integration pilot (Q1 or Q2 2008) • Other “next steps”?