1 / 18

Historic Range of Variability

Historic Range of Variability. “The balance of nature does not exist, and perhaps has never existed… the resultant confusion is remarkable” - Charles Elton, 1930. Jen Costanza Bio 255 October 14, 2005. Outline. Background: Equilibrium concepts vs. change and instability

devona
Download Presentation

Historic Range of Variability

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Historic Range of Variability “The balance of nature does not exist, and perhaps has never existed… the resultant confusion is remarkable” - Charles Elton, 1930 Jen Costanza Bio 255 October 14, 2005

  2. Outline • Background: • Equilibrium concepts vs. change and instability • Historic range of variability • Summary of Landres et al. 1999 and Tinker et al. 2003 • Ecological significance • Methods of assessing HRV • Challenges of spatial and temporal scale • Management applications • Future work • Discussion

  3. Context: Equilbirium and Disturbance • Clements – early 20th Century: disturbance is unnatural and disrupts progression of succession • Equilibrium views: • Watt 1947: unit pattern – succession manifests itself in space and time • Bormann and Likens, Whittaker 1950s, 60s, 70s: constant proportion of the landscape in each successional stage • Shugart, Turner et al.: disturbance extent small and recovery interval quick = equilibrium Perry 2002

  4. Landscape Dynamics Disturbance can lead to stable landscapes with variability Yellowstone 1988 Pre-1988 Yellowstone Turner et al. 1993

  5. HRV Concepts • Historic variability of a landscape and its disturbance regime – Qualitative equilibrium White et al. 2000

  6. Landres et al. 1999 Natural variability: • The ecological conditions, and the spatial and temporal variation in these conditions, that are relatively unaffected by people, within a period of time and geographical area appropriate to an expressed goal • The past as a means of understanding and predicting impacts of current management efforts • A way to balance short-term efforts and long-term goals: temporal and spatial context • Illustrates the importance of disturbance and temporal change

  7. Using HRV to Guide Management Desired Future Conditions may not correspond to Historic Range of Variability

  8. Challenges • Appropriate spatial and temporal scale • May be difficult to fully assess range of variation • Reconstructions from further back in time become difficult • Historic variation may not be relevant under today’s conditions • It may not always be possible to restore the historic disturbance regime

  9. Methods to Assess HRV • Site-specific measurements, as well as data from similar systems elsewhere • Kulakowski and Bebi 2004: • Use HRV for the Rockies to help assess likely HRV for the Swiss Alps • Wimberly et al. 2000: • Simulation models • With finer spatial extent, more variability

  10. Tinker et al. 2003 • Use landscape metrics (pattern) as measure • Compare Yellowstone before and after 1988 fires • Also compare Yellowstone to nearby Targhee NF before and after clearcutting • Spatial scale: Management areas • Temporal scale: • Yellowstone: past 300 years • Targhee: 1950 and 1991

  11. Mapping Yellowstone NP 1985

  12. 1985 1965 1945 0-19 20-39 40-59 60-79 80-99 350 0-19 20-39 40-59 60-79 330 350 0-19 20-39 40-59 1985 1965 1965 Reclassification Reclassification Reclassification Burned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Burned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Burned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Unburned Forest Historic Maps of Yellowstone NP

  13. Other Maps • 1995 YNP– after large 1988 fire • Targhee National Forest: • 1950s before clearcutting • 1991 after clearcutting

  14. Landscape-Scale Metrics

  15. Class-Level Metrics

  16. Tinker et al. 2003 - Conclusions • Large, infrequent disturbances control the landscape structure and dynamics here: 1988 fires expanded the HRV • Temporal extent matters! • Before clearcutting: Targhee NF was within the HRV for Yellowstone • After clearcutting: Targhee NF was outside HRV • We are able to say little about how landscape patterns affectfunction

  17. Future Work - HRV • Additional characterization of HRV for more landscapes, at different temporal scales • Better understanding of how scale affects HRV and the equilibrium of systems – is there any hope of generality here? • More modeling/scenarios to determine how current efforts will affect future conditions

  18. Questions for Discussion • Is HRV a worthwhile concept? • Is HRV an appropriate management tool everywhere? • Is there any hope in developing guidelines for spatial and temporal extent of HRV, besides whatever scale is “appropriate”? • Is Yellowstone NP at equilibrium over the time period studied? Might the 1988 fires lead to a directional shift in landscape pattern? • Why were many of the class-level metrics for the Targhee within the HRV for Yellowstone? • Is landscape pattern the best metric to use in assessing HRV? Would managers want to restore the pattern or the process? • How could we assess HRV for local landscapes in the Southeast? • How could HRV be useful in studying climate ch. impacts?

More Related