80 likes | 299 Views
ERRORS AND BIASES IN ATTRIBUTION. Would you say you are good at school ? Why are you good / why not ? Have you ever failed at school ? Why was that ? Do you know someone who has never failed at school ? How is it possible ?. The fundamental attribution error (FAE).
E N D
Wouldyousayyouaregood at school? Whyareyougood/whynot? • Haveyoueverfailed at school? Whywasthat? • Doyouknowsomeonewhohasneverfailed at school? How is itpossible?
The fundamentalattributionerror (FAE) • Wearemorelikely to makedispositionalattributions (Ross 1977) • Studiessupporting: • Ross et al.1977 (p.187 A-Level) • Bierbrauer 1979 (p.187)
Once a dispositionalattribution is doneit is quitedifficult to change • FAE related to culture? • Seealso the studyby Lee et al.1977 (CC p.105)
2) Actor-observereffect (AOE): • Tendency to emphasize the situationalfactorswhenexplainingownbehaviour • Storms 1973 (p.188)
3) Self-servingbias • Ownsuccessdispositionalattribution = self-enhancingbias • Ownfailuresituationalattribution = self-protectingbias • Johnson et al. 1964 (p.189) • Reasons for SSB: • Greenberg et al. 1982: protection of ourself-esteem • Miller and Ross 1975: The effect of cognitivefactors, ourexpectations • Canalsowork at the grouplevel • Lau and Russel 1980: study of American footballcoaches and players (CC p.105) • Genderdifference?
Culturaldifferences (CC p.106) • Kashima and Triandis 1986 • Chandler et al.1990 • Watkins and Regmi 1990 Modestybias– reasons for that? • Depressedpeopleare an exception • Abramson et al. 1978 • Self-handicapping • Berglas and Jones 1978: study of alcoholics
Syllabus: THE LEARNING OUTCOME RELATED TO ATTRIBUTION ERRORS • Discusstwoerrors in attributions • Discuss = Offer a considered and balancedreviewthatincludes a range of arguments, factorsorhypotheses. Opinionsorconclusionsshouldbepresentedclearly and supportedbyappropriateevidence.