230 likes | 381 Views
Blood Alcohol Content Testing Protocol for Pennsylvania Hospitals. Cheri Rinehart Vice President, Integrated Delivery Systems Robert Wood Johnson Executive Nurse Fellow The Hospital & Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania.
E N D
Blood Alcohol Content Testing Protocol for PennsylvaniaHospitals Cheri Rinehart Vice President, Integrated Delivery Systems Robert Wood Johnson Executive Nurse Fellow The Hospital & Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania 15th Annual Sobriety Checkpoint Conference, Days Inn Penn State May 18, 2006
Pennsylvania’s Hospitals & Health Systems: • Admit nearly 1.8 million people. • Treat more than 33 million people in an outpatient setting. • Provide 5 million ED visits. • Provide $979 million in uncompensated care. • Directly employ more than 259,000 people. • Provide $17.5 billion in direct total spending, and $33 billion with indirect total spending.
The Number of Licensed Pennsylvania Hospitals Source: Pennsylvania Department of Health
Workforce Challenges and Opportunities During the next 15 years, hospitals and health systems are facing two critical problems related to the health care workforce: • There will not be enough workers. • Those who are available will not have the skills needed in the health care system that is emerging. Source: AHA, ACHE, Futurescan, Healthcare Trends & Implications, 2005-2006
In Pennsylvania: RN Supply vs. Demand In 2000, the supply of RNs was estimated at 104,000 while the demand was nearly 110,000 (5% shortage). By 2020, the shortage will grow to 30% or 40,381 RNs. Demand Supply Source: Health Resources & Services Administration (HRSA), Projected Supply, Demand, and Shortages of Registered Nurses 2000-2020, July 2002
Percent of Total Population Without Health Insurance Coverage Source: U.S. Census Bureau, HHS Division
Percent (%) of Pennsylvania General Acute Care Hospitals with Negative Total Margins Source: FY 2002 from HAP analysis of PHC4 data, FY 2003 from HAP FY 2003 Financial Survey
Areas of Medical Underservice • 22% of the state’s population lives in a federally designated shortage area • Areas of 55 of 67 counties have shortage designations
Blood Alcohol—An Intersection of Many Worlds • Confrontation • Finger pointing • Frustration • Anger • Defeatism • Failed convictions
Stakeholders Were Fighting One Another Rather than the Problem Partners in Development of the Protocol
Issues for Hospitals • 1st Priority: Patients • EMTALA • HIPAA • Liability • Court appearances • Consents • Legal responsibilities • Payment • Crowded EDs
Issues for Police • Timeliness • Preservation of evidence • Conviction • Return to duty
Issues for District Attorneys • Chain of evidence • Timeliness • Conviction
Shared Issues • Wanted to keep drunk drivers off the road • Recidivism • Streamlining process • Wanted shared understanding • Wanted to be partners, not adversaries
What the Protocol Addresses • Consent • Probable cause • Right of refusal—individual & hospital • Release of results • Minors
What the Q&A Addresses • Notification of police • Informed consent • Avoiding subpoena • Release of results • Payment
What the Q&A Addresses • EMTALA • HIPAA • Testing kits • Medical v. legal blood alcohol • Unconscious patients
What the Q&A Addresses • Court appearances • Probable cause • Qualifications of blood drawers • Minors • Breath v. blood testing • Patient refusal
House Bill 601 • Signed into law by the Governor • Takes effect in July • Addresses cost of testing
Where Do We Go from Here? • Need to update protocol • Need to identify issues requiring regulatory or legislative action • Need to understand one another’s worlds
“Imagining something may be the first step in making it happen…