1 / 71

Bandwidth Playbook

Bandwidth Playbook. Thwarting Fiber-to-the-Home Competition. John J. Downey Broadband Network Engineer Cisco Systems jdowney@cisco.com. Agenda. Speeds and Feeds Competitive Outlook (FiOS) Objectives Current & New Speed Offerings Future Evolution Options Cablevision’s Choice Configs

dusty
Download Presentation

Bandwidth Playbook

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Bandwidth Playbook Thwarting Fiber-to-the-Home Competition John J. Downey Broadband Network Engineer Cisco Systems jdowney@cisco.com

  2. Agenda • Speeds and Feeds • Competitive Outlook (FiOS) • Objectives • Current & New Speed Offerings • Future Evolution Options • Cablevision’s Choice • Configs • Cabling Ideas • Other Ideas • New Technology Cornerstones

  3. Speeds and Feeds

  4. Objectives • Use existing HFC network • Separation of tiers of service • Bandwidth usage monitoring/shaping • Security Issues - mitigate “hackers” • Number of subs per port

  5. Current and New Speed Offerings • Typically 1 tier at 3M DS by 384K US • MSOs using 1.1 to migrate to multiple tiers of service • Dial-up replacement 128K x 128K • Low to Med speed 1M x 256K or 3M x 384K • High speed 5-7M x 512-768K • Offerings from Verizon • 10x2 Mbps, 20x5, & 30x5 FTTH • New residential & commercial offerings • 15x2 - Cox • 10x1, 15x2, 30x5 - CV • 16x2 - Comcast • 20x? - RCN

  6. Usage Patterns • Changing “cap” at same price may not have linear affect • Average usage may be less than extrapolated • Customers that use a lot of P2P services may look more appealing to others outside network • Offering 15 Mbps at 100:1 oversell allows 200 subs/DS & may be fine, but needs to be observed over time • Customers paying for higher “cap” could feel compelled to get their moneys worth and use much more than previous • Usage could increase exponentially • Customers become more computer savvy • Other applications become prolific or just temporary • Equates to an over-subscription calculation that must be re-evaluated and probably decreased

  7. DS Speed Affected by: • Usable rate and frame size • Modem • Config file, CPU (PPS), & Ethernet • Transport layer • TCP or UDP • US speeds & windowing affect TCP • Max DS burst - perception is reality • VoIP jitter? • Computer OS and Windows stack

  8. US Speed Affected by: • Rate limit & other traffic DOCSIS Protocol • Map advance, DS interleaving & Modulation • Concatenation • Max concat & traffic burst settings • Modulation profiles • Fragmentation • DOCSIS 1.0 CM?

  9. Future Evolution Options

  10. Solutions • Do nothing and watch the competition erode your subscriber base • Segment the fiber nodes • FTTC, FTTH(P), FTTWAP • “Bonding” US & DS DOCSIS channels

  11. Option 1 - Same CMTS with Frequency Separation

  12. Option 1 - Same CMTS with Freq Separation • Map 2 DS freqs & 2 US Rxs into same node • Freq A serving Res subs & freq B serving new subs • Utilize 256-QAM on both DSs • 36 Mbps per DS freq (depends on frame size) • Utilize 3.2 MHz CW/16-QAM on both USs • 9 Mbps per US freq (depends on frame size) • US and/or DS load balance • Allow res subs to use under-utilized commercial US • Client-class processing "steers" Res subs to A & new subs to B • Set DS freq and/or US Ch ID in CM’s config file

  13. Scope Scope Client Entries Client Classes Client Classes Scopes Scopes Tags Tags PC X MAC Address: ab:cd:ef:01:02:03 Scope Scope Modem Tag Modem Tag INET Modem Class Res Modem Class 01:02:03:04:05:06 10.2.2.0 10.1.1.0 .2-.124 .2-.124 Modem Tag Modem Tag 01:02:03:04:05:06 scope ... PC Tag PC Class 24.1.1.0 .. .125-.255 PC tag .. . Cable Modem X Cable Modem Y 02:03:04:06:aa:06 MAC Address: MAC Address: 02:03:04:06:aa:06 ab:cd:ef:01:02:03 Separating CMs Through Client-Class Processing CMTS Provisioning Server

  14. DS0 U0 U1 U2 U3 DS1 U0 U1 U2 U3 Option 1 - Separating CMs via FDM & Provisioning DS0 = 453 MHz @ 256-QAM DS1 = 459 MHz @ 256-QAM U0 = 20.0 MHz @ 3.2 MHz U0 = 23.2 MHz @ 3.2 MHz

  15. Option 1 - Questions to Answer • Multiple DSs broadcast because of EDFAs? • Broadcast makes it difficult to achieve 1:1 DS-to-node combining later down the road • Nodes with 1 DS Rx & 2 US Txs? • Two DSs could be sent to node • 1 US laser feeds US of 1 mac domain • 2nd laser feeds US from other mac domain • US frequency re-use possible

  16. Option 1 – Pros and Cons

  17. Option 1 - Pros • Provides simple "get up and run" approach • Only real modifications are: • Combining to map 2-4 USs to nodes • Ensure provisioning system steers them to proper US ch • US and DS load balancing possible • “Poor man’s” redundancy • Caution across cards - packet drops because no IM alignment between cards • If using mixed mode, then 2.0 CMs could burst at 64-QAM for ~ 13 Mbps

  18. Option 1 - Pros (cont) • 2 DSs at 256-QAM = ~ 72 Mbps • 2 USs at 16-QAM / 3.2 MHz = ~ 18 Mbps • Advanced phy features • Ingress cancellation and more FEC • 24-tap EQ & US interleave • A/D conversion • 5x20U has advanced spectrum management, remote analyzing and per-CM FEC counters • Available with 12.3(13) IOS & >

  19. Option 1 - Cons • Requires combining work • Requires DS and US spectrum availability • Moving to new DS requires new US • Outage could make CMs register on incorrect DS & affect registration times • CMs will need to be client-class processed with info in their DOCSIS config files • What if an US port dies?

  20. Option 2 - Separate CMTSs

  21. CMTS A CMTS B DS0 U0 U1 U2 U3 DS1 U0 U1 U2 U3 Option 2 - Diagram • Map US/DS ports from 2nd CMTS into existing nodes • Connect 2nd CMTS to core network • Provision Commercial CMs to proper freq & CMTS

  22. Option 2 - Pros • Hardware Isolation • More processing power • Future expansion and “poor-man’s” HA • Separates “high speed” customers for NOC “clarity” • Some systems use this for open access or to segregate Data form VoIP

  23. Option 2 - Cons • Second CMTS • Will CPU max out if one chassis dies? • More power draw & rack space in HE/hub • Must integrate 2nd chassis to network • Need address space for additional CMTS • CMs could lock on wrong CMTS & IP bundle • IP address depletion • Packet drops (no IM alignment between chassis) • CM offline on one CMTS & online on another

  24. Option 3 - Same as Option 1, but Utilizing ATDMA

  25. Option 3 - Same CMTS Utilizing ATDMA • Utilize ATDMA-only US ports for Commercial CMs • Only allows 2.0 CMs to "see" US port & register • Existing Res subs are blind to ATDMA port • Don't understand mac message 29 included in UCD • Need to configure provisioning to block Commercial CMs from registering on 1.x US port • Use provisioning to force specific DS freq or US Ch ID

  26. DS0 U0 U1 U2 U3 DS1 U0 U1 U2 U3 Option 3 - Diagram • DS0/U0 = TDMA (1.x mode) • DS1/U0 = ATDMA (2.0-only) • Only allows 2.0 CMs to "see" DS1/U0 & register on it

  27. DOCSIS 2.0 Benefits

  28. DOCSIS 2.0 – ATDMA Basics • Introduces “docsis-mode” concept: • TDMA (traditional 1.x mode) • ATDMA-TDMA (mixed 1.x and 2.0) • ATDMA (2.0-only) • Use “cable upstream x docsis-mode {}” to configure US channel to a desired mode • Automatically picks a new default mod profile

  29. DOCSIS 2.0 Benefits • Greater spectral efficiency • Better use of existing channels • More capacity • Provides higher throughput in US direction • Per-CM speed greater with better PPS • Robust against worst-case plant impairments • Although not part of spec, ingress cancellation allows higher orders of modulation • Opens unused portions of spectrum • Insurance for life-line services

  30. DOCSIS 2.0 Benefits • IUCs added for 1.x/2.0 mixed environment • 9 = a-short, 10 = a-long, 11 = a-ugs • Better statistical multiplexing • 6.4 MHz channel is better than 2, 3.2 channels • Increases US capacity to 30.72 Mbps • Enhances flexibility when used in combination with Virtual Interfaces • 1x1 MAC domain makes more sense

  31. DOCSIS 1.1 Phy Change (PRE-EQ) • US equalization is supported on all cards for 1.0 and 1.1 • 8-tap blind equalizer • 1.1 allows 'pre-equalization' where EQ coefficients are sent allowing a CM to pre-distort its signal • Cab up x equalization-coefficient • Supported on all linecards and releases that support 1.1 • Requires 1.1 capable CMs, but not .cm file • Configurable option • 2.0 increases the equalizer tap length from 8 to 24 • Supported on U cards in ATDMA mode • Off by default

  32. Amplitude Ripple/Tilt • 6.4 MHz ATDMA signal exhibits severe in-band tilt at US port • Pre-EQ in CM can compensate for nearly all tilt

  33. Option 3 – Pros and Cons

  34. Option 3 - Pros • Allows 2 stacked US channels • Only appears as one for Res customers • Allows less ports to be used since ATDMA USs operate at 27 Mbps usable speed • If spectrum is available, 2.0 CMs could use a 6.4 MHz channel & 64-QAM, if clean enough • Leverages 1 CMTS that’s already installed

  35. Option 3 - Cons • Requires new “high speed” users to have 2.0 CMs • Requires provisioning work to "block" 2.0 CMs from registering on Res freq • If Res subs buy their own 2.0 CMs, they could lock to commercial US w/o provisioning interdiction • Use TLV 39=0 for res CMs • Forces 1.x mode even if they are 2.0 capable • Can’t utilize load balancing • Configure mixed-mode with utilization-based LB • May require dynamic freq hopping or mod changes

  36. Cablevision’s Choice

  37. New Architecture Idea Using Option 3

  38. New Architecture Information • DS0-DS3 are 1x2 MAC domains – Regular Tier • DS4 is 1x8 MAC domain – Power Tier • USs use connector assignments & freq stacked • Boost Configuration: • US: Up to 27 Mbps per node • DS: ~25 Mbps @ 64-QAM or ~35 Mbps @ 256-QAM per 8 nodes • Could be further segmented down to 4 nodes • 4 US ports not used

  39. Questions to Answer • Back-office procedures & implementation, what happens when: • New CM registers on wrong DS • Catastrophic failure on entire node • Residential sub buys their own 2.0 CM • CMs move between DSs and/or US ports • Physical implementation • Is DS spectrum available for 256-QAM • Can US laser handle multiple carriers and higher modulation schemes

  40. CMTS Configuration

  41. Lab Testing Procedures and Verification • uBR10k with PRE1 running 12.3(9a)BC4 • Verified the following features: • Dual DS and US frequency to same node • Virtual Interfaces • ATDMA-only US • Frequency Stacking • 1x2 and 1x8 MAC domain • CM config file with specific DS freq configured • Used Cablevision’s CMTS config as much as possible • Broadband Access Center for Cable (BACC) used for provisioning, DHCP, ToD and TFTP

  42. interface Cable8/1/0 cable downstream modulation 256qam cable downstream frequency 603000000 cable downstream channel-id 0 cable downstream rf-power 58 cable upstream max-ports2 cable upstream 0 connector 0 shared cable upstream 0 frequency 25008000 cable upstream 0 channel-width 3200000 cable upstream 0 minislot-size 2 cable upstream 0 modulation-profile 23 no cable upstream 0 shutdown cable upstream 1 connector 2 shared cable upstream 1 frequency 25008000 cable upstream 1 channel-width 3200000 cable upstream 1 minislot-size 2 cable upstream 1 modulation-profile 23 no cable upstream 1 shutdown interface Cable8/1/4 cable downstream modulation 256qam cable downstream frequency 609000000 cable downstream channel-id 4 cable downstream rf-power 58 cable upstream max-ports8 cable upstream 0 connector 0 shared cable upstream 0 frequency 28496000 cable upstream 0 channel-width 3200000 cable upstream 0 minislot-size 2 cable upstream 0 modulation-profile 23 no cable upstream 0 shutdown cable upstream 1 connector 2 shared cable upstream 1 frequency 28496000 cable upstream 1 docsis-modeatdma cable upstream 1 channel-width 3200000 cable upstream 1 minislot-size 2 cable upstream 1 modulation-profile 221 no cable upstream 1 shutdown CMTS Linecard Configuration

  43. interface Cable8/1/1 cable downstream modulation 256qam cable downstream frequency 603000000 cable downstream channel-id1 cable downstream rf-power 58 cable upstream max-ports2 cable upstream 0 connector 4 shared cable upstream 0 frequency 25008000 cable upstream 0 channel-width 3200000 cable upstream 0 minislot-size 2 cable upstream 0 modulation-profile 23 no cable upstream 0 shutdown cable upstream 1 connector 6 shared cable upstream 1 frequency 25008000 cable upstream 1 channel-width 3200000 cable upstream 1 minislot-size 2 cable upstream 1 modulation-profile 23 no cable upstream 1 shutdown interface Cable8/1/4 cable downstream modulation 256qam cable downstream frequency 609000000 cable downstream channel-id4 cable downstream rf-power 58 cable upstream max-ports8 cable upstream 2 connector 4 shared cable upstream 2 frequency 28496000 cable upstream 2 channel-width 3200000 cable upstream 2 minislot-size 2 cable upstream 2 modulation-profile 23 no cable upstream 2 shutdown cable upstream 3 connector 6 shared cable upstream 3 frequency 28496000 cable upstream 3 channel-width 3200000 cable upstream 3 minislot-size 2 cable upstream 3 modulation-profile 23 no cable upstream 3 shutdown Configuration (cont)

  44. Concerns • IP Address Implications • How to prevent IP address exhaust during ranging onto incorrect DS freq • CM issues with multiple DS & US freqs? • Long time to register (CMs cache DS freq) • Power level when 2nd US freq added? • CMTS performs pwr on per-US freq & CW • Analog front-end could overload & cause harmonics • Per-CM speeds

  45. Concerns (cont) • Maybe laser clipping from adding additional freqs and higher modulation schemes • How to scale 1x8 and 1x2 MAC domains as utilization increases? • Take into account RF connections, provisioning, etc. • Bandpass filters in plant • US diplex filter range • 5-30, 5-40/42, 5-55, 5-65, …

  46. Another Idea to Utilize All “JIBs” DSs 0-3 = 603 MHz MC5x20 DS0 U0/C0 U1/C2 1x2 DS 4 = 609 MHz 1x8 DS4 U0/C0 U1/C2 U2/C4 U3/C16 U4/C8 U5/C10 U6/C12 U7/C18 DS Splitter 1x2 DS1 U0/C4 U1/C16 DS Combiner US Splitter • Requires: • 2 DS frequencies • 2 US freqs in each node • One US freq per DS • 4 US ports not used 1x2 DS2 U0/C8 U1/C10 1x2 DS3 U0/C12 U1/C18 All USs at 28.5 MHz All USs at 25 MHz

  47. Using All US Ports (4, 1x3s and 1, 1x8) DSs 0-3 = 453 MHz MC5x20 DS0 U0&1/C0 U2/C2 1x3 DS 4 = 459 MHz 1x8 DS4 U4/C2 U5/C6 U6/C10 U7/C14 U0/C16 U1/C17 U2/C18 U3/C19 DS Splitter 1x3 DS1 U0&1/C4 U2/C6 DS Combiner US Splitter • Requires: • 2 DS freqs • 3 US freqs in some nodes and only 2 in others 1x3 DS2 U0&1/C8 U2/C10 DS3 U0&1/C12 U2/C14 1x3 All USs at 28.5 MHz All USs at 25 MHz

  48. Cabling Ideas

  49. Maxnet II Picts

  50. Maxnet II Picts

More Related