E N D
1. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited Tempus EU-PULA, 27-28 May 2001
European Union Framework RTD
CRAFT Project Case Studies
Wroclaw University of Technology
2. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Introduction
Craft Rules
Craft Project Case Studies
Craft Project Costs
Conclusions
3. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Craft Awards
Designed to enable groups of SMEs, with no or inadequate research facilities, to engage third parties to carry out research on their behalf.
Proposals can be submitted in a two-stage process, although the first stage can be omitted.
The scheme covers a number of R&D areas.
4. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Craft Stage 1 - Exploratory Award
This enables the project to be properly scoped and for new partners to be brought on board.
Partners:
Minimum 2 SMEs, or 1 SME and one end-user (e.g. Hospital or Library) from 2 Member or 1 Member and 1 Associated State; SMEs not to have been involved in previous EC R&D projects
Project Cost
Up to 75% of cost up to 22,500 ECU
5. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Craft Stage 2 - Complete Proposal
This stage involves a full proposal justifying the expected research project.
Partners:
At least 3 non-affiliated SMEs from at least 2 Member States or 1 Member State and 1 Associated State
RTD performers, to carry out at least 40% of the research: Research Centres, Universities, private companies
1 - 2 Year Project Cost:
Total 0.3 to 2.0 MECU
Funding EU 50%
6. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES A Meat Substitute based on Quinoa
Quinoa is a botanical fruit of a herb plant, which is becoming increasing available in health stores. It is used in cooking in a similar way to grain, such as wheat. The partners on this project wanted to be able to exploit the fruit by producing a product which is a meat substitute.
The technical research was aimed at solid substrate fermentation biotechnology needed to convert the fruit into a meat substitute
7. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
Plas Farm Ltd (UK) - food producer
Old McDonnell’s Farm (IRL) - food producer
Aber Instruments (UK) - sensor for process
Camateras (EL) - Greek fish farm
Nordfeld (DK) - Danish grower of Quinoa
RESEARCH PROVIDERS
University of Westminster (UK)
Leatherhead Food RA (UK)
COSTS
150.3K
149.8K
27.0K
100K
50.2K
293.4K
183.9K
8. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Efficient Recovery of Flax Fibres
Due to the increasing world-wide pressure for alternative fibres the cotton industry alone cannot meet this demand, and synthetic fibres are economically and environmentally unsatisfactory.
The aim of the project was to carry out research in an effort to maximise the yield of flax straw and “cotton-compatible” flax fibres.
A research feasibility study on flax cultivation and processing was carried out by the research performers.
The SMEs expect to exploit by way of franchise of the cultivation and processing systems.
9. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
ICP (UK)
Straw Service (UK)
Vervaeke Fibre N.V. (B)
FIATECE (P)
LARGE COMPANIES
Cebeco Agricultural Seeds Group (NL)
Zeneca Crop Protection plc (UK)
RESEARCH PROVIDERS
De Montfort University (UK)
CITEVE (P)
COSTS
104.5K
160K
50K
85.5K
80K
20K
420.7K
79K
10. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Reduced Applications of Chemicals in European Raspberry Production (RACER)
Raspberries are a high value crop with a long establishment period that requires high capital expenditure. Growers rely on chemical control. Fungicides and insecticides, to ensure high quality fruit production.
However there is increasing pressure from retailers and consumers to reduce chemical inputs.
The objective was to provide the Industrial Partners with a new European Code of Best Practice in pest and disease control.
11. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs:
SSGF (UK)
Associazone Produttori (I)
D Periepes (EL)
Valmira Frutas (P)
Pakkasmarja (FIN)
Non EU Large Company BSZ (CH)
RESEARCH PROVIDERS
Scottish Crop Research Institute (UK)
Institute Agrario di S. Michele all’Adige (I)
Agricultural Research Centre (FIN)
Swiss Government cash: Federal Research Station (CH)
COSTS
124.43K
131.75K
23.32K
25.01K
92.07K
0.9K
154.08K
79.71K
86.1K
95.49K
12. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Investigation of the Causes of Mortality
in Oyster Production (ROMEO)
The objective of the project was to identify and combat the periodic loss in oyster hatcheries.
The project developed a model hatchery and nursery for controlled tests on larvae and algae.
The project involved the analysis of environmental factors when rearing oyster larvae including, feeding, seawater quality and causes of disease in relation to mortality. Bioremediation of seawater and probiotic improvement in algae cultures in parallel with improving the overall health of the oyster seed and larvae will ultimately improve production and thus profitability.
13. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
Seawater Shellfish (Whitstable) Ltd (UK)
SATMAR SA (F)
Guernsey Sea Farms (UK)
Lissadell Shellfish (IRL)
Tinamenor SA (E)
GAEC Les Ferrange (F)
RESEARCH PROVIDERS
University of Kent (UK)
IFREMER (F)
University of West Brittany (F)
Station Bioblogique, Roscoff (F)
CEFAS Conwy (UK)
COSTS
84.36K
77.57K
27.86K
21.45K
17.82K
25.01K
90.32K
53.4K
14.0K
51.9K
44.51K
14. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Mercury Free Catalysts for
Polyurethane Product Providers
The objective of the project was to understand how the choice of catalyst for PU manufacture affects the reaction and properties of a chosen PU system and to derive a predictive model to select the optimum catalyst for a given system.
It was hope to find an alternative catalyst to the hazardous mercury catalyst currently used.
This involved the development of mathematical models for a range of PU systems, including, rigid and flexible foams, elastomers and surface coatings.
15. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
Quartex (UK)
Allrim (F)
Tectrade (DK)
SPU (FIN)
Dr D A Delis (EL)
Liquid Plastics (UK)
KMZ (UK)
ICOA (UK)
NITRIOL (D)
ALCHEMIE (UK)
COSTS
17.47K
33.62K
60.30K
60.00K
11.40K
11.66K
16.81K
16.44K
40.76K
16.46K
16. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES LARGE COMPANIES
OSI* (CH)
Freudenberg (D)
HEVEA (NO)
RESEARCH PROVIDERS
RAPRA (UK)
* Swiss partner’s contribution was not matched by an EU contribution as Switzerland was not a Member State
COSTS
13.82K
27.04K
21.80K
347.59K
17. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Better Process Control in Leather Production
The tanning industry uses chemical technologies to convert hides and skins into leather. This is done using closed drums, so that most of the processing is blind, the consequences being that the effects can be inconsistent and inefficient.
The first objective of this project was to develop a compact and reliable, on-line, battery operated pH and temperature measurement module to fit into existing equipment.
The second objective was to design an off-line colour measurement system to analyse solutions from the drums as an indicator of the colour take-up of the hides being processed.
18. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
Connolly Leather (UK)
W. Pearce & Co (UK)
WE & J Peabody (UK)
H Goodman & Son (UK)
Sweni Svendborg (DK)
Borge Garveri (NO)
Elmo-Calf (FIN)
Lapuan Nahka (FIN)
Talleres Olcina (E)
Juan Martinez (E)
COSTS
26.18K
20.58K
16.98K
9.40K
21.18K
19.98K
19.98K
18.78K
50.52K
15.70K
19. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES LARGE COMPANIES
Grupo Industrial Colomer (E)
Hellenic Tanners Association* (EL)
RESEARCH PROVIDERS
BLC Leather Technology Centre (UK)
Westdeutsche Gerberschule (D)
Heights Design Group (UK)
* Withdrew from the project after 6 months
COSTS
9.06K
37.00K
206.08K
52.08K
93.72K
20. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Physical Vapour Deposition of Oxide Coatings
The objective of the project was to develop the coating technology equipment to produce new metallic oxide coatings for shielding of electronic components, and for the large area environmental protection of constructional materials on a continuous coating basis.
This involved the optimisation of all process parameters including a reliable pulsed DC power supply based on a large magnetron and the investigation of the properties of various oxide coatings, including aluminium oxide, for the deposition onto metal and insulating substrates.
21. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
HHR Anlagenbau GMBH (D)
Surface Engineering Consulting (FIN)
Surface Engineering Coatings OY (FIN)
Finnvert (FIN)
RESEARCH PROVIDERS
Teer Coatings Ltd (UK)
University of Uppsala (S)
COSTS
160.00K
60.00K
160.00K
100.00K
280.00K
200.00K
22. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Development of Refractory Inspection and Evaluation Equipment
Refractory linings are used by major industrial companies to provide thermal and erosion protection. The manufacture and installation is sub-contracted to a large number of SMEs throughout Europe.
Quality control relies mainly on expert visual inspection and rugged Non Destructive Testing (NDT) equipment.
The project brought together refractory producers, instrument manufacturers and end users to develop a quality assurance monitor for refractory inspection.
23. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs (16)
Penn Refractories (UK)
Ceramic Holland (NL)
Ceramica do Liz (P)
CNS Electronics (UK)
Foseco (FS) (UK)
Instrumentation Innovation (UK)
KSR International (UK)
JW Lemmens (B)
Morganite Thermal Ceramics (UK)
JME* (UK)
Refracta (P)
Refractarios Alfran (E)
TAB Refractories (UK)
Terres Refracttaires du Boulonnais (F)
Svenska Hoganas (S)
SAF (P)
COSTS
10.47K
11.50K
18.50K
12.00K
21.00K
12.00K
21.00K
12.33K
21.00K
12.00K
12.00K
12.00K
12.00K
21.00K
21.00K
18.50K
24. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES LARGE COMPANIES
Hoogevens Groep (NL)
Rauturuukki (FIN)
Veitsch-Radex (A)
RESEARCH PROVIDERS
ERA Technology (UK)
CERAM Research (UK)
Instituto de Soldadura e Qualidade (P)
COSTS
21.00K
21.00K
21.00K
190.26K
126.84K
98.00K
25. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Lower Cost, Reinforced Plastic Pipe
Plastics for pipelines for gas, water and oil has been restricted to small diameter pies and low pressures. Production of pipes greater than 100mm diameter and able to withstand higher operating pressures is limited by existing extrusion process and the plastic materials’ properties.
Thermoplastic pultrusion has proved to be highly successful, a novel die technology with continuous fibre reinforcement has enabled long lengths of pipe at lower costs which should compete with metal pipes.
26. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
Speedex (Engineering) (UK)
Cookson Extrusion (UK)
Vulcan Refractories (UK)
IFAP (I)
Simplast (I)
Oy Mecanor (FIN)
Flex Seal Couplings (UK)
COSTS
50.00K
50.00K
50.00K
45.00K
50.00K
40.00K
50.00K
27. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES LARGE COMPANIES
Heliflex (P)
Hepworth (UK)
Rehau (D)
RESEARCH PERFORMERS
PERA International (UK)
British Gas (UK) COSTS
45.00K
40.00K
45.00K
495.00K
120.00K
28. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Performance Measurement of
Diamond Tools for Sawing and Drilling
The aim of this project was to set standards of the performance of diamond tools used in the processing of natural stones, building and hard materials generally.
The inability of users to define a quality tool means selection is often based on price. This results in high quality goods being driven out of the market place and consumers suffer. The introduction of a quality mark is expected to improve the sales and market share of the SMEs involved in this project.
29. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
Epsilon Holdings Ltd / MTD (UK)
Golz GmbH & Co. (D)
Olssons Diamantverktyg AB (S)
Technocopi-Tasoulidis Harry S.A. (EL)
Sensor Technology Ltd (UK)
Levanto OY (FIN) COSTS
71.41K
28.98K
24.01K
68.00K
37.16K
16.89K
30. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES LARGE COMPANIES
Tyrolit Schleifmittel Werke Swarovski (A)
Lockheed Martin (UK)
RESEARCH PERFORMERS
University of Greenwich (UK)
Metallurgical Industrial Research & Technological Development Centre S.A. (EL) COSTS
64.36K
59.80K
385.73K
47.89K
31. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Fluorescent Microspheres as Labels for Ultrasensitive Analytical Measurements
Fluorescent assays are becoming very important in fields such as biochemical and clinical analysis. The sensitivity of such assays is usually limited by the ability to reject “background” fluorescence. Most background emission decays within a few nanoseconds of excitation.
The aim of the project was to develop novel long-lifetime fluorescent labels suitable for high sensitivity assays along with instrumentation for their detection.
32. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
Photonic Research Systems Ltd (UK)
Lambert Instruments BV (NL)
Delta Danish Electronics, Light & Optics (DK)
Molecular Probes Europe BV (NL)
Labor Diagnostika Nord BmbH & COKG (D)
COSTS
95.00K
75.00K
75.68K
15.00K
93.00K
33. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES LARGE COMPANIES
Packard Bioscience BV (NL)
RESEARCH PERFORMERS
University of Salford Enterprise (UK)
British Textile Technology Group (UK)
University of Regensburg (D) COSTS
60.00K
170.68K
121.50K
121.50K
34. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Measuring Product Conformity to Telecommunications (SDL) Specifications
IT communications standards, particularly in the telecommunications sector are becoming increasingly sophisticated and complicated. Testing is the only way of ensuring the products conform to the relevant standards and can interwork with products from different manufacturers.
The aim of this project was to develop a tool to automate the production of conformance tests to improve productivity and quality.
35. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
CSL (UK)
Kvatro (NO)
Hummingbird (D)
FSCOM (F)
S&P Media (D)
Compador (UK)
COSTS
57.00K
57.00K
57.00K
69.00K
60.00K
57.00K
36. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES LARGE COMPANIES
Telelogica (S)
Nokia (FIN)
RESEARCH PERFORMERS
NPL (UK)
COSTS
60.00K
40.00K
500.00K
37. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Accurate Verification of
Coordinate Measuring Machines using Lasers
The aim of this project was to develop a simplified method for performance verification using a laser interferometer and a novel universal artefact which can be addressed to Coordinate Measuring Machines of all sizes, types and configurations. The advantages are:
Improve understanding of current standards
Allow performance verification of large machines
Produce standardised performance tests
Reduce calibration times
38. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES SMEs
ITP Group Ltd (UK)
Intelligent Information Technology Ltd (UK)
Krypton Electronic Engineering (B)
COORD 3 S.p.A. (I)
Lister Machine Tools Ltd (IRL)
Atlas Aluminium Ltd (IRL)
COSTS
117.29K
67.70K
63.37K
113.15K
45.76K
33.87K
39. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES LARGE COMPANIES
Renishaw plc (UK)
Lufthansa Airmotive (IRL)
PTB (D)
RESEARCH PERFORMERS
Southampton Institute (UK)
University of Limerick (IRL)
University of Leuven (B)
S.T.A.N.I.M.U.C. (I)
COSTS
12.00K
21.29K
8.00K
191.76K
136.76K
138.71K
39.20K
40. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Craft Project Cost Categories
Personnel Costs
Travel and Subsistence
Sub-contracting
Durable Equipment
Comsumables
Other specific project costs (agreed with Commission)
Protection of Knowledge
Overhead Costs
41. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Craft Project Overall Costs
Total Project Costs 0.3 to 2.0 Million Euro
Up to 40% from a single partner
Up to 60% from the same country
TRD Performers:
Must be paid 100% of their costs
At least 40% of project costs
At least 50% of Personnel time
42. NJM European, Economic & Management Consultants Limited CRAFT CASE STUDIES Conclusions
Wide variety of technical projects possible:
All areas of the Framework V Programme
For example: Agriculture, Production Technology, Standards
Partnerships:
Can be large or small, but usually larger than minimum specified by the CRAFT rules
Costs: 0.3 to 2.0 Million Euro