500 likes | 1.28k Views
U.S. Foreign Policy During the Cold War: 1945-1980. “ Spies, Lies, Heroes and Disgrace ” Clicker Ch. 48!. For 1950-1980, SWBAT:. Analyze USFP Guiding Principles Describe trends in U.S. Foreign Policy (USFP) Analyze major Cold War events Evaluate U.S. Foreign Policy Decisions.
E N D
U.S. Foreign Policy During the Cold War:1945-1980 “Spies, Lies, Heroes and Disgrace” Clicker Ch. 48!
For 1950-1980, SWBAT: • Analyze USFP Guiding Principles • Describe trends in U.S. Foreign Policy (USFP) • Analyze major Cold War events • Evaluate U.S. Foreign Policy Decisions
Guiding Questions/Principles • Should the U.S. place our ideals of “freedom” and “democracy” above our national (economic, security) interests? • Should the U.S. attempt to “spread” democracy throughout the world? (If so, when, where, how, and to what effect?) • What should we do when our ideals and national interests don’t coincide? • How should the U.S. deal with “hostile” nations?
What should guide USFP? • Only to spread ideals (ex: democracy) • Mostly to spread ideals (ex: democracy) • Ideals and interests equally • Mostly U.S. national interests (ex: security) • Only U.S. national interests (ex: security) Clicker Ch 48!
It’s Personal! • Think of relations between countries as relationships between people • How easy is it to influence/change behavior? • The relationship leaders have with each other has a huge impact on policy • Individual goals, values, and personality • Most leaders want to stay in power • Look strong, good to own people • What’s best for them vs. best for country
Historical Trends in USFP • Isolationism (1780s to 1890s) • Manifest Destiny (1820s to 1890s) • Internationalism (1890s to 1910s) • Return to Isolationism (pre & post WWI) • Dominant Internationalism (WWII to present) • Cold War (1945-1991) then ….
Post WWII Trends • Cold War Fears and Misunderstandings • Global Ideological Battle/Competition • Capitalism & Democracy vs. Communism • End of Colonialism • Nations around world gain independence • Growth of International Trade
1940s Timeline of Major Events • 1947: Truman Doctrine and Marshall Plan • 1947: USA creates CIA • 1947: India gains independence • 1948: Israel becomes a nation • 1948: Communists take Czechoslovakia • 1948-49: Berlin Blockade and Airlift • 1949: Communists (Mao) take over China • 1949: Soviets explode atomic bomb • 1949: NATO forms
1950s Timeline of Major Events • 1950-53: Korean War • 1954: CIA supports coups in Iran and Guatemala • 1954: Soviets establish KGB • 1954: French lose at Dien Bien Phu (Vietnam) • 1955: Warsaw Pact forms • 1956: Suez War (Israel, UK&Fr. attack Egypt) • 1956: Soviets crush liberation movement in Hungary • 1957: Soviets launch Sputnik • 1958: US forms NASA • 1958: US sends marines to Lebanon (civil war) • 1959: Communists (Castro) take over in Cuba • 1959: Khrushchev visits USA
1960s Timeline of Major Events • 1960: Soviets shoot down U2 spy plane • 1961: Bay of Pigs invasion of Cuba • 1961: Construction of Berlin Wall • 1961: Kennedy forms Peace Corps • 1962: Cuban Missile Crisis • 1962: US troop buildup in Vietnam begins • 1963: President Kennedy assassinated • 1964: Senate ratifies Nuclear Test Ban Treaty • 1968: Soviets crush revolt in Czechoslovakia, leads to Brezhnev Doctrine • 1968-69: Anti-Vietnam War Protests Peak • 1969: Apollo 11 lands on the moon
1970s Timeline of Major Events • 1972: Nixon visits China and USSR • 1972: Senate ratifies SALT I • 1973: First Oil Crisis (OPEC) • 1974: Nixon resigns over Watergate • 1975: US pulls out of Vietnam • 1979: Second Oil Crisis (OPEC) • 1979: Soviets invade Afghanistan • 1979: Iranians hostage crisis at U.S. Embassy • 1980: Ronald Reagan Elected
Was Fear of Communism Real? • YES! (but…) • Soviet spies in the West • Soviet support of communism in world • Communism and Capitalism incompatible? • At the time, very hard for either side to see middle ground • The Power of Fear • Domestic conditions impact foreign policy
Politicians Use “Fear” to Get Elected • 1952: Eisenhower elected by labeling Truman too passive against Soviets • 1960: Kennedy elected by blaming Eisenhower-Nixon for Soviets lead in missiles • 1968 & 1972: Nixon elected by taking strong anti-communist stance • 1980: Reagan elected by promising to close “window of vulnerability” with USSR
Thinking Question To what extent do politicians/leaders today use fear to help get elected and stay in office? Just because you’re paranoid, doesn’t mean people aren’t watching you.
U.S and Soviet Espionage • 1940s: Steve Nelson and Clarence Hiskey gave USSR info on Manhattan Project • Nathan Silvermaster mole in US govt. • Soviet agent Andrei Schevchenko pressured defense workers to give high tech secrets • Hundreds of Soviet agents in US
U.S and Soviet Espionage • Alger Hiss (1950) • Ethel and Julius Rosenberg convicted in 1951 for sharing atomic secrets; executed 1953 • U2 spy flights over USSR (began 1957) http://www.infoplease.com/spot/spies1.html
U.S. and Soviet Espionage • Pop Culture Reflects Tensions • “Bond. James Bond” (by Ian Fleming) • First Book published 1953 (Casino Royale) • First Movie Dr. No (1962) • Dr. No wants to destroy a U.S. moon rocket • 2nd Movie From Russia with Love (1963) • Bond helps a Soviet corporal defect http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ii1tc493bZM
Thinking Question How are foreign policy events/issues reflected in pop culture today?
How & Where was Cold War Fought? • Military Technology • Arms Race and MAD • In Space • Newly Independent Countries • Aid, ideas, and war • Kennedy’s inaugural address 1/20/61 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xE0iPY7XGBo at 1 min
Arms Race & Space Race • Technology = Power • Atomic Bomb • Hydrogen Bomb • Fear of Missile Gap (ICBMs) vs. Reality
Arms Race & Space Race • Sputnik (1957) • NASA (1958) • Kennedy’s promise “…because it is hard” • Land on moon by end of 1960s • Moon landing in 1969 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4VIBmVZPWmI at 8 minutes
How Far Did U.S. Go to Prevent the Spread of Communism? • 1940s: Truman Doctrine (1947) to “contain” Communism (Kennan’s idea) • 1950s: John Foster Dulles’ policy of “brinkmanship” (Allen Dulles at CIA) • 1960s: Dean Rusk promotes “Domino Theory” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domino_theory
What Does this Lead to? • World Divided: • First World (U.S. and W. Europe) • Second World (U.S.S.R and Satellites) • Third World (poor, developing countries) • U.S. willing to SUPPORT ANY GOVT. as long as NOT COMMUNIST • U.S. Sponsored Military Dictators • U.S. Sponsored Coups & Assassinations • Short-term and Long-term Implications? • Lessons for Today?
Newly Independent Countries • Third World: Democracy vs. ??? • Often US did not favor repression over democracy • These areas had no established democratic institutions (govt, media) • US supported anti-communist dictators in an effort to prevent communist dictators • Coups and assassinations • Stability Trade Freedom?
Iran www.solarpaces.org/_Libary/map-iran.jpg
Iran • Both Russia and Britain have ties • 1921-1941 Reza Shah dictator • Some reforms but harsh rule • WWII occupied by Britain, Soviets, & USA • 1941 Mohammad Reza Shah in power • Promises constitutional monarchy, but… • 1951 Nationalize oil industry (from UK) • 1951 Dr. Mossaddeq becomes PM • Very nationalist, but not communist
Iran • US and UK Fear communist leanings • 1953 CIA sponsors coup of PM • Reza Shah solidifies power • Shah of Iran in power (1941-1979) • Corrupt dictator, but some reforms • Seen as “puppet” of US • Islamic fundamentalists take power (1979-present) initially promised democracy http://www.mideastweb.org/iranhistory.htm
Guatemala http://www.geographicguide.com/caribbean-map.htm
Guatemala • 1931-1944 led by dictator (Ubico) • 1944 virtually bloodless revolution • Ubico flees to live in USA • 1945 Juan Jose Arevalo Bermej elected • Rejected Marxism but claimed to be a “spiritual socialist” • US cuts off military aid • 1952 Jacobo Arbenz Guzman elected • First peaceful, democratic transfer of power
Guatemala • Arbenz plan to redistribute land • 2% owned 70% of land • Owner paid value based on taxes • 1.6 million acres • U.S. Based United Fruit Co. • World’s biggest banana producer • Biggest landowner in Guatemala • Launches PR campaign against communists
Guatemala • 1954 CIA trains and equips force to overthrow govt. • Uses propaganda and bombs capital • U.S. picked leader takes over (Castillo Armas) http://www.geo.mtu.edu/~jaherric/Documents/map_guatemala.gif
Guatemala • Almost 100% of United Fruit’s land returned • Peasant farmers forcibly removed • 1,000s jailed or to camps • Castillo Armas hero in US • Guatemala Civil War 1960-1996 • 50,000 “leftists” killed during 1970s • 1977 USA cuts military aid • 200,000 civilians killed
1950s Lesson from Guatemala? • Latin American govts. wanting independence from US were viewed with distrust, suspected of communist leanings • Countries cannot be neutral but must pick sides (US or USSR) • Often play both sides! • US will intervene to protect interests
Cuba geology.com/world/cuba-map.gif
Cuba • 1940s: Democratically elected govts. • 1952: Coup led by Batista, US supports • Corruption in govt.; more dictatorial • July 1953 Castro coup fails • Jailed (serves 3 of 15 years) • After release met Che Guevara • Dec. 1956 Castro reenters: Civil War • US encouraged Batista to leave
Cuba • 1959 Fidel Castro takes power • US recognized, but soon tried to remove • Castro was nationalizing US companies • April 1961 Bay of Pigs invasion • CIA sent 1,500 Cuban exiles to invade • Total Failure for US • Oct. 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7YkJxQT_0Y
Cuba • Castro is longest serving dictator in Western Hemisphere (1959-2008) • Brother Raul Castro took over • Castro claims 638 assassination attempts
Vietnam • French colony after WWII • Wanted independence • South leader Ngo Dinh Diem • Corrupt, dictatorial, but not communist geology.com/world/vietnam-map.gif
Vietnam • Defeats France at Dien Bien Phu (1954) • Vietnam split at 17th parallel • 1963 US supports military coup of Diem • Increased instability, US troops increase
Vietnam 1963 Kennedy considers pulling out 1964 Gulf of Tonkin Incident 1968 Nixon elected with “secret plan” to end war Bombs Cambodia illegally 1970 Anti-war Protests peak 1973 Most US troops pull out
US Troops in Vietnam 1961 – 2,000 1963 – 16,000 1964 – Gulf of Tonkin Resolution 1965 – 184,000 1966 – 385,000 1969 – 542,000 1973 – Most forces leave 1975 – US evacuates embassy; remaining forces leave
Costs of Vietnam Total deaths 58,000 300,000 wounded Cost of $150 billion 570,000 draft dodgers 563,000 less-than-honorable discharge 1975 – Communists unite Vietnam
Lessons of 1945-1980? Consider both Short-term and Long-term Goals National vs. Corporate interests Our ideals and national interest can conflict – What then? Military engagement should be last resort Nationalism is not Communism “Nation-building” is hard, if not impossible Defense Sec. Gates speech (Feb. 2011) Leadership & personality matter!
How can the US deal with “rogue” leaders/countries? • Military force and/or covert operations • Economic sanctions and trade • More Trade = More Freedom? • Moral persuasion • The Power of Social Networking! • Concept of BATNA (R. Fisher & W. Ury, 1981) • “Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement" • Analyze the needs/values/motives of other side • What is likely to happen if you walk away? • Are leaders doing what’s best for them or country?
How did we do? SWBAT: • Analyze USFP Guiding Principles • Describe trends in U.S. Foreign Policy (USFP) • Analyze major Cold War events • Evaluate U.S. Foreign Policy Decisions