500 likes | 797 Views
Molecular markers to aid in early diagnosis of pancreatic cancer. Michael Goggins, MD Professor of Pathology, Medicine and Oncology Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Baltimore, MD. “7th Annual Symposium on Gastrointestinal Cancers " St. Louis, Mo, 9/20/08. Disclosure.
E N D
Molecular markers to aid in early diagnosis of pancreatic cancer Michael Goggins, MD Professor of Pathology, Medicine and Oncology Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Baltimore, MD “7th Annual Symposium on Gastrointestinal Cancers " St. Louis, Mo, 9/20/08
Disclosure • Dr. Goggins has licensing agreements with Oncomethylome sciences for several DNA methylation markers
Early detection of asymptomatic disease Early diagnosis of symptomatic disease
Survival for Ductal Pancreas Adenocarcinoma Tumor Diameter Lymph Node Status p<0.0001 p<0.0001 no positive nodes < 3 cm positive nodes ≥ 3 cm Margin Status Histologic Grade p<0.0001 p<0.0001 negative margin well or moderate positive margin poor or undifferentiated
Early detection of small asymptomatic neoplasms may result in cure Best outcome: 79 patients wth small, asymptomatic, < 1 cm cancers 5- year survival 100% after surgery if PC limited to duct epithelium (CIS?) Ariyama 1997
What is the natural history of patients who present with symptoms and are ultimately diagnosed with pancreatic cancer? We do not have much quantitative information on the obstacles to diagnosis for patients with pancreatic cancer
Pancreatic CT abnormalities up to 18 months prior to a diagnosis of pancreatic cancer Chari et al, AJR 2004;182:897
How many patients would have a significantly improved outcome if they were optimally diagnosed as soon as symptoms presented?
Markers of Pancreatic Neoplasia What performance characteristics are needed for a(serum) molecular marker for the Diagnosis of pancreatic cancer
The performance characteristics of a marker often vary by population (disease stage, heterogeneity): Ca19-9 Sensitivity for resectable PC =65% (Sensitivity for unresectable PC=80%) PC AmpCA CP islet ca controls JHU unpublished
Disease prevalence 50% (e.g. pancreatic mass) Disease No Disease Positive 1,100 Negative 900 1,000 1,000 PPV: 900/1100=81% NPV: 800/900=91% Test Sensitivity: 90% Specificity: 80% (for cancer)
Disease prevalence ~10%, e.g. mid-back pain, wt loss Disease No Disease Positive 542 Negative 1558 1,800 200 PPV: 182/542=34% NPV: 1540/1558=98% Sensitivity: 90% Specificity: 80% (for resectable cancer)
What performance characteristics are needed for a molecular marker for Screening for pancreatic cancer?
General Population: Age 65: 5 year Risk PPV NPV Surveillance Epidemiology and End Result
Disease prevalence, 1% Disease No Disease 414 Positive Negative 1586 20 1,980 PPV: 18/414=4.3% NPV: 1584/81856=99.8% Sensitivity:90% Specificity: 80%
New Onset Diabetics: 3 yr PC risk PPV NPV Chari et al. Gasto 2005
Family Hx PC 3 1st-degree relatives: 3-yr PC risk PPV NPV Klein et al. Cancer Research 2004
Family Hx PC 2 1st-degree relatives: 3-yr PC risk PPV NPV Klein et al. Cancer Research 2004
Is this the right question to ask of our markers?What performance characteristics are needed for a molecular marker to Screen for pancreatic cancer?
What about the performance characteristics for a molecular marker of neoplastic precursors?
Strong Family Hx of PC, prevalence: 10% (IPMN) Test: Sensitivity: 95% Specificity: =90% (EUS or MRI) Disease No Disease 105 Positive 95 Negative 100 100 PPV: 95/105=91% NPV: 90/95=95%
Cancer of the Pancreas Screening(CAPS) clinical trials Who are we screening? Asymptomatic High risk individuals with a strong family history of pancreatic cancer and certain germline mutation carriers CAPS1:1999 CAPS2: 2001 CAPS3: 2006 CAPS4: 2008
Familial PC Screening Programs Other studies ongoing, eg. Brentnall et al (Seattle), Europac, U Pitt, Zubarik et al, (Vt)
Cancer of the Pancreas Screening Study (CAPS) 3 CAPS 3 – 1st national American multicenter screening study • EUS/CT/MRI + biomarkers (juice) • Hopkins, Mayo, MDACC, Dana Farber, UCLA • www.clinicaltrials.gov • Email: caps3@jhmi.edu • lizst.onc.jhmi.edu/caps3
CAPS 4 • Single center, long-term screening and surveillance (V foundation) • Evaluate expanded eligibility • 1 FDR, 1 SDR (eg. parent and grandparent) • BRCA2 mutation carriers • Biomarker discovery
baseline 3 months 10 mm 12 months 18 mm
Extensive PanINLobulocentric atrophy Brune et al, AJSP, 2006
Is the identification of IPMNs and PanINs in asymptomatic individuals justified when we have not proven that surveillance of these lesions leads to improved outcome?
What molecular markers are on the horizon and can they help identify cancer or advanced neoplasia?
Molecular alterations in pancreatic cancer • DNA: Somatic mutations Aberrant DNA methylation Chromosomal losses/gains • RNAs: RNAs and microRNAs • Proteins Peptides, glycopeptides • Other eg. Autoantibodies Infiltrating pancreatic ca
Normal Duct PanIN 2 PanIN 3 PanIN 1A PanIN 1B Invasive AdenoCa Intraductal Papillary Mucinous Neoplasm (IPMN) Cystic Lesion Adenoma Carcinoma in situ Invasive AdenoCa Mucinous Cystic Neoplasm (MCN)
Pancreatic cancer research:Era of systematic discovery 100% Research Activity Translational Evaluation of markers Systematic Discovery (“Omics”) Candidate Markers 0% 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 Time
Number of somatic mutations in pancreatic cancer Data figure on the pc genome
Pancreatic cancer chromosomal gains + losses Gains Losses Walter et al, Cancer Biol Ther, 2008
Quantifying mutant KRAS in Pancreatic juice: LigAMP PC CP Shi et al, Cancer Biol Ther, 2008
Discovering the cancer methylome Methylome = genome wide DNA methylation patterns
Log ratio Chr1 Chr7 Chr2 Chr8 Chr3 Chr9 Chr4 Chr10 Chr5 Chr11 Chr6 Chr12
Aberrant DNA methylation in IPMNs % Hong et al, Modern Path in press
Quantitative Methylation analysis of ERCP Brushings of common bile duct strictures
QMSP of biliary and Pancreatic duct Brushings performed to diagnose strictures Parsi et al, Clin Gastro Hep, 2008
Quantifying pancreatic juice DNA methylation alterations 5 gene panel, quantified by QMSP, CAPS2 study population Cancer Res 2006:66:1208
Candidate pancreatic cancer markers: Serum Macrophage inhibitory cytokine-1 (MIC-1) ELISA PC=pancreatic cancer CP=chronic pancreatitis Nl=normal Clin Cancer Res 2006;12:442
MicroRNA alterations in pancreatic cancer Hahn et al, Oncogene 2007;264442