1 / 25

Liberty and Rights

Liberty and Rights. by OC Cunz. What do you think?. What is the difference between liberty and rights?. Definitions. Liberty In short is one among many Human Rights or Derechos Humanos (Burke) The positive enjoyment of various social, political, or economic rights and privileges

ely
Download Presentation

Liberty and Rights

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Liberty and Rights by OC Cunz

  2. What do you think? What is the difference between liberty and rights?

  3. Definitions • Liberty • In short is one among many Human Rights or Derechos Humanos (Burke) • The positive enjoyment of various social, political, or economic rights and privileges • The limits within which a certain amount of freedom may be exercised. • Rights • Justifiable claim laid by one individual upon another or upon society in general (Laws) • Paternalism • Interference with a person’s liberty of action justified by reasons referring exclusively to the welfare, good, happiness, needs, interests or values of the person being coerced.

  4. Liberty and Rights: What are they? • Liberty: • Self-Determination • Political / reasonably free from external political constraint • Social / self-determination

  5. Liberty and Rights: What are they? • Rights: • Natural Rights: As per our nation’s founding documents • Stoic Philosophy: Whatever happens, it is by divine will • Natural Law: Keeping with human nature • Human Rights: • Political guarantees respecting the freedoms of individuals • Is a prerogative, granted by law pertaining to citizens of that nation living under that law.

  6. Liberty and Rights: What are they? • Right to work • Right to be paid for work • Right to a speedy trial • Political Rights • US Constitution and its Amendments • Right to vote

  7. - Liberty and Rights are somewhat like oxygen. It’s difficult for people to know for sure what they really are until they are deprived of them. Liberty and Rights

  8. John Stuart Mill • Utilitarian Centric Perspective • “The ultimate appeal on all ethical questions” • Liberty of Thought and Discussion • Liberty of Individuality • Limits of Authority of Society • Applications • The only warranted infringement upon one’s liberty is solely for self-protection

  9. Edmund Burke • Liberty must be balanced with established tradition • Liberty has to be constrained somewhat or there will be chaos • Need to control individuals • Paternalism - community should decide what is best

  10. Is REAL liberty purchased? • Be sure real liberty is purchased at no other price • Is there a “free government”? • Is there a price of liberty? • Can elected officials really run a “free Govt” • Reps of the constituents • Burke: • Supposed to LEAD? -or- be “instruments”? • Burke finds middle ground: • “Let us add, if we please, but let us preserve what they have left…” -text pp343

  11. James W. Nickel - Human Rights - Right holder: The person who benefits from or are protected by the right - Addressee: The ones upon whom the right imposes obligations or duty

  12. Universal Declaration of Human Rights - U.S. has not ratified these treaties - - Adopted in 1948 by UN general assembly - If not binding is it cause to go to war over infractions? - If it is cause for war: Are they criminals for what they were doing? Are they war criminals to be tried as such?

  13. Universal Declaration Articles No arbitrary detention • Japanese internment camps? • Guantanamo detainees? Fair and Public Trial • Can you really give Manson/Hitler/Sadam a “fair trial” by a jury of peers?

  14. International Treaties/Laws • Are you bound to International Treaties and Laws that your country does not ratify? • Can you try members of foreign nations who commit crimes based on International Treaties their country has not ratified?

  15. Inalienable Rights • People are born with certain rights afforded them by being of the human race. • Nickel says: • Also means these rights can’t be bargained away by the right holders • What about legally waived rights (5th Amendment) in exchange for cooperation (lesser sentencing)

  16. Gerald Dworkin - Paternalism: Interference with a person’s liberty of action justified by reasons referring exclusively to the welfare, good, happiness, needs, interests or values of the person being coerced.

  17. Interference in the liberty of Action • Self protection or the protection of others • …the individual’s own good is never a sufficient warrant for the exercise of compulsion.

  18. Death Penalty • Assuming: • Costs associated with administering the death penalty were not astronomical • Appeals did not take 20+ years • Is prescribing the death sentence warranted for an individual who has been sentenced to life without parole for their crimes? • Keep in mind: Killing the felon does not reduce the threat of the individual nor does it increase the protection of the populous.

  19. Paternalistic Interferences • Laws requiring license to engage in certain professions • Laws against dueling (Article 114 UCMJ) • Laws making suicide a criminal offense • Not allowing assumption of risk as a defense to an action based on the violation of a safety statute • Not allowing as a defense to a charge of murder or assault the consent of the victim - Discussion: Who rides a motorcycle?

  20. Laws against Dueling • Why? • Acting of their own free will & both are acting in self defense with no intent of harming anyone not in the duel. • What about Dr. Kevorkian? • Euthanasia? • Painless taking of a life to end suffering • Terri Schiavo • Abortion?

  21. Pure vs. Impure Paternalism • Pure: class of persons whose freedom is restricted is identical with the class of persons whose benefit is intended. • Impure: restricting freedom of others in the effort to increase the protection of a class of persons. • 40 hr work week? • What about salaried employees? • Are they a consenting victim assuming the risk or is it a loop-hole?

  22. Killing to stop a Murder • Is the man who kills to stop a murder in violation? • At what point do we assume too much responsibility for the determination of the welfare of others? - Mill: Left to themselves, greed will rule. Everyone acting in their own self interest degenerates the commons, need some sort of governing body to regulate and conserve the commons. - Individual interests are in conflict with the common good

  23. Man-Tracking Proposed • Human GPS tracking devices embedded at birth as crime reduction tactic. • Ignoring • Technical aspects (say you could not detect them for retrieval) • Religious aspects (mark of the beast, etc.) • Kidnapping, lost children, criminal apprehension, POW locations, etc. • “WE’RE TALKING ABOUT PEOPLES LIVES HERE!!!”

  24. Does self-determination have a place? - Self determination = greed (Freedom to not wear a helmet) • Restriction is a lesser of two evils than the bad outcome and is therefore justifiable. • Paternalism is justifiable only to preserve a wider range of freedom for the individual in question. • If you booze you loose

  25. Fin Questions?

More Related