1 / 57

Generalized Anxiety Disorder Lecture Overview

Generalized Anxiety Disorder Lecture Overview. Nature Epidemiology Empirically-supported treatments Pharmacotherapy Psychotherapies Efficacy data Class discussion. Significance of GAD. Worry, the central feature of GAD, is pervasive in the anxiety and mood disorders. Significance of GAD.

erica-nolan
Download Presentation

Generalized Anxiety Disorder Lecture Overview

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Generalized Anxiety DisorderLecture Overview • Nature • Epidemiology • Empirically-supported treatments • Pharmacotherapy • Psychotherapies • Efficacy data • Class discussion Treatments of GAD

  2. Significance of GAD • Worry, the central feature of GAD, is pervasive in the anxiety and mood disorders Treatments of GAD

  3. Significance of GAD • Worry has been experimentally demonstrated to prevent emotional processing and thus may maintain any disorder wherein such processing is important for therapeutic change • Successful treatment of GAD results in dramatic reduction in comorbid conditions Treatments of GAD

  4. Significance of GAD • One of the most common comorbid conditions in the anxiety and mood disorders • May be the basic anxiety disorder out of which other anxiety disorders emerge Treatments of GAD

  5. Breakdown of Comorbidity by Diagnosis Data from Moras et al (1991). Psychopharmacology Bulletin, 28(1), 1992, 27-33 Diagnoses are based on DSM-III-R criteria using the ADIS-R Treatments of GAD

  6. Current Diagnostic Features of GAD • Excessive anxiety and worry, occurring more days than not for at least 6 months, about a number of events or activities • The person finds the worry difficult to control • The anxiety and worry are accompanied by at least 3 or more symptoms (i.e. irritability, difficulty concentrating) • Causes substantial impairment or distress. • Not due to physical condition or ingestion of substance Treatments of GAD

  7. Changes in the Conceptualization of GAD Treatments of GAD

  8. Characteristics of Worry • A tendency to define ambiguous situations as threatening (Butler & Mathews, 1983) • An elevated estimation of risk (Vasey & Borkovec, 1992) • Tendency to generate negative scenarios in ambiguous situations (Macleod et al, 1991) Treatments of GAD

  9. Inter-rater Reliability Across the Anxiety Disorders Data from Brown & Barlow (1992). Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 6, 835-844. Diagnoses are based on DSM-III-R criteria using the ADIS-R Treatments of GAD

  10. Factors Accounting for Modest Inter-rater Reliability of GAD • Status as a residual category • Lack of agreement over disorder severity • Diagnostic overlap with other anxiety disorders • High rate of comorbidity (82%) Treatments of GAD

  11. Epidemiology of Generalized Anxiety Disorder • Prevalence • DSM-III: 4% (ECA study Wave II) • DSM-III-R: 5.1% Lifetime (Kessler et al, 1994) Treatments of GAD

  12. Epidemiology of Generalized Anxiety Disorder • Onset • Early onset (mid-teens) • However, some suggest that there may be two subtypes – one early onset and one later onset in response to a stressful event Treatments of GAD

  13. Epidemiology of Generalized Anxiety Disorder • Genetics • Twin study by Kendler et al (1992) • GAD runs in families • The familial association is due to shared genetic as opposed to shared environmental factors • Heritability is estimated between 19- 30% • Heritability cannot be explained by PD or major depression • *Genetic factors seemed stronger for brief as opposed to more prolonged periods of GAD Treatments of GAD

  14. Impact of GAD on Health Care Utilization GAD is second only to depression in prevalence of a psychiatric condition found in the primary care setting Treatments of GAD

  15. Impact of GAD on Health Care Utilization • GAD is the most prevalent anxiety disorder found in primary care settings (Barrett et al, 1988) • GAD patients are twice as likely (44 vs. 22%) to seek treatment in a primary care setting as opposed to a psychiatric treatment setting (Wittchen et al, 1994) • Among patients classified high in medical care utilization 40% meet lifetime history of GAD and 22% meet current GAD diagnosis (Katon et al, 1993) Treatments of GAD

  16. Common Symptom Presentations in Primary Care Among GAD Patients • Chest Pain • Among ER patients presenting with atypical chest pain, 23% met for GAD (Wulsin et al, 1991) • Among chest pain patients with normal coronary angiograms, 56% met for GAD (Kane et al, 1988) • Gastrointestinal • Among IBS patients, 34-54% meet for GAD lifetime (Walker et al, 1990; Lydiard et al, 1993) • Among IBS patients with comorbid GAD, 80% reported that their GAD symptoms preceded their IBS symptoms Treatments of GAD

  17. Basic Research on the Nature and Functions of Worry Treatments of GAD

  18. Spheres of Worry in GAD Data from Sanderson & Barlow (1986) Paper presented at AABT, Chicago. Treatments of GAD

  19. How does GAD Worry Differ from “Normal” Worry? Data from Dupuy, J.R. et al (2001). Behaviour Research and Therapy, 39 1249-1255. Treatments of GAD

  20. How does GAD Worry Differ from “Normal” Worry? Data from Dupuy, J.R. et al (2001). Behaviour Research and Therapy, 39 1249-1255. Treatments of GAD

  21. How does GAD Worries Differ from OCD Obsessions? • Worries are more in agreement with one’s belief system (egosyntonic) • GAD worries occur as verbal thoughts whereas OCD obsessions can take the form of images, ideas, or impulses; • GAD worry is perceived as less intrusive and less likely to be resisted • The content of GAD worries are not perceived as unacceptable or senseless • GAD interfere more with functioning • GAD worries are more likely to have situational triggers • GAD worries remain in the background (omnipresent) Treatments of GAD

  22. Basic Research on the Nature and Functions of Worry • Conceptualization of worry as a coping strategy to avoid threatening material (Borkovec, & Hu, 1990; Borkovec et al (1993) Treatments of GAD

  23. Borkovec & Nau (1990) Data from Borkovec & Nau (1990). Behaviour Research and Therapy, 28, 69-71. Treatments of GAD

  24. Basic Research on the Nature and Functions of Worry • Worry is negatively reinforcing by allowing the patient to cognitively avoid the negative affect • A significant consequence of this avoidance is the inhibition of emotional processing thereby resulting in the maintenance of anxious meanings despite daily exposures to threat material Treatments of GAD

  25. Evidence Supporting the Threat Avoidance Function of Worry • Phobic patients who think worrisome thoughts just prior to exposure to phobic images show no cardiovascular response to those images; Whereas phobics who think neutral or relaxing thoughts just prior to exposure display significant cardiovascular response (Borkovec & Hu, 1990). Treatments of GAD

  26. Evidence Supporting the Threat Avoidance Function of Worry • Worry after exposure to a stressful event results in a failure to process emotional material (Butler et al; 1995; Wells et al, 1995) Treatments of GAD

  27. Evidence Supporting the Threat Avoidance Function of Worry • GAD participants but not normal controls significantly endorse the item “Worrying about most things I worry about is a way to distract myself from worrying about even more emotional things” (Borkovec & Roemer, 1995) Treatments of GAD

  28. Evidence Supporting the Threat Avoidance Function of Worry • GAD patients show higher prevalence of traumatic experiences than controls • GAD patients overpredict aversive outcomes and drastically underpredict their ability to cope with potential threats suggesting that they are not processing evidence that the world offers them Treatments of GAD

  29. Evidence Supporting the Threat Avoidance Function of Worry • GAD patients show a preattentive bias to threat cues outside of awareness; • GAD patients display a rapid cognitive avoidance of detected threats such that explicit memory for threat material is reduced but implicit memory for the same material is increased Treatments of GAD

  30. What Are the Threats That GAD Patients Are Avoiding? • Negative attachment experiences • Current interpersonal problems • Trauma Treatments of GAD

  31. How Does Worry Inhibit Emotional Processing? • Lessened attentional resources for processing other information (Mathews, 1990) • Difficulty shifting thought away from negative thought activity (Parkinson & Rachman, 1981) • Less mismatch between information expected and information received Treatments of GAD

  32. Status of Psychotherapy Outcome Research in GAD • Systematic development and evaluation of psychotherapies for GAD have lagged behind that for other anxiety disorders • Early treatment research on GAD focused on somatic anxious experience and the use of relaxation to provide a generalizeable coping response to stress and anxiety Treatments of GAD

  33. Reasons for the Slow Progress in Psychotherapy Development • Historically, GAD has been an ambiguous disorder • Diffuse forms of anxiety did not fit into prevailing behavioral perspectives as readily as the other anxiety disorders Treatments of GAD

  34. Reasons for the Slow Progress in Psychotherapy Development • Although exposure methods accrued considerable evidence for efficacy when circumscribed fear-provoking stimuli could be identified, their relevance was less clear for GAD wherein external triggers for anxiety were more obscure, pervasive, and constantly changing Treatments of GAD

  35. Pharmacological Treatments for Generalized Anxiety Disorder • Benzodiazepines • Antidepressants • Buspar Treatments of GAD

  36. Things to Know About the Pharmacotherapy of GAD • More well-controlled trials than any other anxiety disorder; • Many of the earlier studies include patients who may not meet current criteria for GAD • Most use the Hamilton anxiety as their major outcome measure Treatments of GAD

  37. Things to Know About the Pharmacotherapy of GAD • Benzodiazepines (22 – 62% reduction on Hamilton) offer a modest short-term beneficial effect relative to pill placebo (18 to 48% reduction); • Benzodiazepines are associated with (a) cognitive impairment; (B) withdrawal effects; and (c) rebound anxiety • Buspar has been shown to have similar rates of improvement with fewer negative side effects Treatments of GAD

  38. Contemporary Cognitive Behavioral Treatment of GAD • Procedural Components • Self-monitoring • Cognitive restructuring • Applied relaxation • Coping desensitization • Worry Exposure Treatments of GAD

  39. Summary of Randomized Controlled Clinical Trials in GAD Data based on Gould et al (1997). Treatments of GAD

  40. Variation of CBT Procedures Treatments of GAD

  41. Efficacy Estimates at Posttreatment Data from Gould et al. (1997).Behavior Therapy, 28, 285-305. Treatments of GAD

  42. Efficacy Estimates at Follow-up Data from Gould et al. (1997).Behavior Therapy, 28, 285-305. Treatments of GAD

  43. Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment of GAD • Current Status of Outcome Research • CBT was associated with low drop-out rates and reductions in medication taking • At best only 50% of patients achieve recovery status Treatments of GAD

  44. Efficacy Data • Butler et al (1991) • CBT • BT • WL Control Treatments of GAD

  45. Butler et al (1991)HEF Results Treatments of GAD

  46. Butler et al (1991)Non-trial Therapy during FU Treatments of GAD

  47. Efficacy Data • Power et al (1990) • Diazepam • Pill placebo • CBT • DZ + CBT • PL + CBT Treatments of GAD

  48. Power et al (1990)Responder Results Treatments of GAD

  49. Efficacy Data • Barlow et al (1992) • Progressive muscle relaxation • Cognitive therapy • Progressive muscle relaxation + cognitive therapy • Wait-list Treatments of GAD

  50. Barlow et al (1992)Completer Analyses (N = 44) Treatments of GAD

More Related