1 / 15

A New Theory of What? Humanizing the Firm in the Time of the Precariat

A New Theory of What? Humanizing the Firm in the Time of the Precariat. JC Spender ESADE / LUSEM. complementary methods for examining ‘humanizing’ - ‘ dignitizing ’ - human work. 1 /13. from method to substance ‘theory of the firm’ as socio-political entity - but which society ?. society

evadne
Download Presentation

A New Theory of What? Humanizing the Firm in the Time of the Precariat

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. A New Theory of What?Humanizing the Firm in the Time of the Precariat JC Spender ESADE / LUSEM IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference

  2. complementary methods forexamining ‘humanizing’ - ‘dignitizing’ - human work IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 1/13

  3. from method to substance‘theory of the firm’ as socio-political entity - but which society ? society (markets) ‘firms’ production functions individuals - rational society (democratic capitalism) socio-economic institutions & private-sector ‘firms’ individuals - ‘human’ society (environment) ‘firms’ social systems system elements - rational economic model systems theory model humanizing model human being = a-rational, unique ? politics, sympathy, morality, emotion heterogeneity/agency/practice rationality - simple or behavioral or … homogeneous IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 2/13

  4. ‘rights’ - State, individual and owners’ • humanizing (top level) - ‘society’ using power, regulation and other institutionalized constraints over private sector firms • humanizing (bottom level) - e.g. legislation to protect employees’, customers’ and others’ ‘rights’ against the rights and powers legally granted to private-sector owners • firms straddle state’s constrained rights to shape the firm and the firm’s constrained rights to shape the individual’s practice • framing the private-sector firm (middle level) - back to the etic/emic conference target IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 3/13

  5. figure - ground reversal bottles or glasses ? IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 4/13

  6. IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 5/13

  7. k-presences and k-absences that define ‘the BCG firm’ (Example1) • interplay of k-presence and k-absence • portfolio, life cycle, time • firm (as cash machine) synthesized by executive agency • judgments - allocation, dogs • managing as agentic repairing - complementing rational designing IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 6/13

  8. Porter’s firm (Example 2) • firm not industry • ‘force’ = power to disturb the firm’s rent-stream • many dimensions of ‘force’ - multi-layered, multi-timed • firm arises from agentic ‘positioning’ in a multi-dimensional force/time context IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 7/13

  9. principal-agent theory’s firm ? (Example 3) • Jensen & Meckling 1976 • single period • perfect markets • Fama 1980 • multi-period • imperfect markets • mutual learning • ‘firm’ arises from principal’s and agent’s time-full mutual learning and preparedness to adjust their utilities IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 8/13

  10. ‘ToF’ as defined k-absences to be filled by agency • diagnostics - framing entrepreneurial ‘opportunity space’ • executive’s ‘bounded agency’ • T methodology - fact-driven analysis • U methodology - coup d’oeil, augenblick • preparation, history, theory (von Clausewitz) • ‘added value’ - endogenous growth T U etic K-presence rationality emic K-absence imagination IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 9/13

  11. emic firm analysis &construction TMT’s moral/ ethical scruples executive agency funding limits business model technological advance government standards labormarket - Precariat competitor’s marketing • might, can, should, want - LCAG’s 4 emic dimensions • Balanced Scorecard - 4 etic? dimensions • Spender - Industry Recipes (1989) - 12 emic dimensions unoccupied strategic opportunity-space IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 10/13

  12. after the entrepreneur’s vision comes harnessing others’ reason & agency • decision to participate - a matter of reason or persuasion ? • incentives (extrinsic and intrinsic) - or rhetoric ? • others offer both reason & agency • firm (profit) arises from the subordination of others’ agency - not from instructions guiding others’ reason • ‘docility’ - becoming ‘another’ • beyond logos and into ethos& pathos • stasis theory, argument theory, inventio • work (1) ‘toil’ - work (2) ‘fulfillment’, ‘flow’ IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 11/13

  13. Precariat - new meaning of ‘work’ • not ‘participating’ in 20th century-style work - e.g. long-term employment contracts, training, pensions, health-care • not having one’s agency managed by others • ‘living by one’s wits’ in today’s democratic capitalism • undergrad business education - post-crisis, economic history, time • graduate - staffer’s diagnostic tools (von Clausewitz) • leadership - should BSchools teach rhetoric once again ? IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 12/13

  14. summary • humanizing (top level) - public control of private-sector firms’ activities • humanizing (bottom level) - counter-balance owners’ legal rights • mid-level synthesizing of T and U (Barnard 1938) • rhetorical engagement of others’ agency + reasoning • private-sector firms’ legitimate seizures - quasi-monopolies & employees’ agency • humanizing mid-level - owners & managers acknowledging and remunerating the value added by others - both toil & fulfillment • U - agency - rhetoric - practice - value-adding • extending the BSchool agenda - diagnostic tools + rhetoric & art IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference 13/13

  15. ‘theory of the firm’ - academic concept or real value-add ? IESE 2nd Theory of the Firm Conference

More Related