1 / 17

Using Multiple Methods to Gauge Success in an Internship Experience

Using Multiple Methods to Gauge Success in an Internship Experience. Karen Kopera-Frye Jeanne Hilton Human Development and Family Studies University of Nevada . Goals of the Presentation. Background on the academic program Mission Vision Programs

ewan
Download Presentation

Using Multiple Methods to Gauge Success in an Internship Experience

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Using Multiple Methods to Gauge Success in an Internship Experience Karen Kopera-Frye Jeanne Hilton Human Development and Family Studies University of Nevada

  2. Goals of the Presentation • Background on the academic program • Mission • Vision • Programs • Overview of our undergraduate program of assessment to date • Challenges faced in revising and implementing an internship experience for seniors • We will be sharing examples of internship materials…sign up if you want copies

  3. HDFS Department…Mission • Demonstrate knowledge of the bio-psycho-social elements of the human lifespan, with in-depth expertise in at least one developmental stage • Demonstrate knowledge and application of the interplay of issues and processes in diverse family systems • Critically evaluate and apply theory to the contexts of research and practice in the field

  4. Areas of Focus in the Department • Early Childhood Education Program • Human Development and Family Studies Program • Child and Adolescent Development • Adult Development and Aging • Family Studies • Certified Family Life Educator • Masters in HDFS

  5. Vision of the Department • Focus HDFS programs on a theme such as prevention and resilience • Strengthen the HDFS master’s program • Participate in an interdisciplinary doctoral program that serves the needs of HDFS majors

  6. Overall assessment of undergraduate program • Senior online exam to evaluate knowledge gained • Mosaic focus groups with graduating students to evaluate their view regarding the relevance of the curriculum in their educational experience • Internship supervisor ratings to evaluate application of theory and knowledge in the real world setting • Alumni and employer survey to evaluate the effectiveness of the program in preparing students for professional roles

  7. Preliminary assessment findings… • Senior online exam • suggests that students (77%) retain knowledge from core courses across a 4-5 year span • Mosaic focus group • students were mostly positive about their experience, however • Two course needed modification • More career advisement • More consistency in classes taught by LOAs • Internship • was disorganized and needed to be revised before data could be collected • Alumni survey • Over 90% of students were pleased with the program and currently employed in their field of expertise

  8. Assessment of graduate program • The graduate assessment plan was submitted in May, 2003 • The master’s program is under major revision based on the latest strategic plan • Will add a prevention track that includes collaboration with CASAT • Will add a research track for students who want to enter a terminal degree program • Will reconsider the professional paper option • Plan to recruit aggressively • To date, the primary method of assessment is a mid-program review of each student by the graduate faculty • Data collection will begin this spring • Other assessment tools will be developed as the program evolves

  9. The HDFS Internship Experience Then and now…

  10. History of the HDFS Internship • Formal process was in place with contracts, site visits and evaluation • Over time, LOAs taught the class and the original procedures and intents were lost • This became evident when we first attempted to use the internship for assessment in 2002 • So…we first had to revise the internship before we could collect data

  11. Challenges we faced • Many students did not get started in the field until half-way through the semester • No site visits were done • Scheduled campus meetings with students were erratic (at best) • Minimal guidelines and instructions, and unclear expectations were provided to the students • Sites were not necessarily relevant to career goals, and students often just did busy work

  12. Revision of the Internship • The leading professional organization for family studies is the National Council on Family Relations (NCFR) • NCFR is implementing a certification process for family life educators (CFLE) • CFLE found similar problems with internships across the country and is in the process of developing a standardized handbook for internships • We were involved with the development of the CFLE handbook and adopted many of the preliminary forms and procedures for the HDFS handbooks • Preliminary copies of the CFLE internship materials…pass around

  13. In November 2003, HDFS was given official designation as a CFLE program • Therefore we are in the process of further refining the internship experience to meet CFLE guidelines • Current goals for the student include… • Apply the knowledge and theory gained in the program to the internship experience • Comply with accepted ethical and professional standards in the field • Demonstrate expertise and experience in at least one of the 10 substance areas required for the CFLE

  14. Goals for assessment are to evaluate students’… • Application of knowledge/theory • Professional growth and integrity • Ability to network for future career opportunities • Revisions thus far… • Handbooks and standardized assessments have been implemented • A directory of potential sites has been developed • Site partnerships are being developed based on career opportunities and the fit of the experience with student-employer needs • Students prepare formal proposals and contracts for their internship • Pre-screening and orientation of the student takes place the semester before the internship begins • An ongoing internship coordinator has been assigned who works closely with the department chair to oversee the quality of the program

  15. Assessment tools • Handout…Site Supervisor’s Handbook • Student orientation • Roles and responsibilities (expectations • Mid-term Supervisor Ratings (quantitative) • Final Evaluation (qualitative) • Explanation of the competency matrix • Competency matrix • Ten substance areas listed across top • Competencies are listed down the side

  16. Preliminary Findings • Mid-term supervisor ratings on 13 students • Almost all rated the student above average or outstanding • Comments were extremely positive, suggesting that most students were an asset to the organization • Only one concern was voiced… • The supervisor was concerned because the student did not submit a contract until mid-term • The LOA teaching the class did not provide any of the other data to the coordinators • She has since been replaced with a permanent internship coordinator who will be collecting the data this spring for the first time

  17. Future Directions • The internship assessment is still being refined • To comply with the strategic plan • To comply with CFLE standards • To find a data collection process that ensures reliable and consistent data from the sites • We would like to add student feedback and anonymous aggregate site supervisor feedback about the experience to our process • Discussion…how does our assessment of the internship process compare with what your unit is doing?

More Related