220 likes | 356 Views
Academic Support and Academic Identity of African American Males Labeled Emotionally Handicapped (EH) By Cheryl T. Jeffries. Phenomenon. Increasing rates (Donovan & Cross, 2002; Fearn, 2002) Higher rates than other ethnic groups or gender (Harry & Anderson, 1999; Kunjufu, 1995)
E N D
Academic Support and Academic Identity of African American Males Labeled Emotionally Handicapped (EH)By Cheryl T. Jeffries
Phenomenon • Increasing rates (Donovan & Cross, 2002; Fearn, 2002) • Higher rates than other ethnic groups or gender (Harry & Anderson, 1999; Kunjufu, 1995) • Highest drop-out rates than any other disability group (Corbett & Clark, 2002; Etscheidt, 2002) • 10% rate of declassification (Harry & Anderson, 1999)
Research Questions • How do African American male children labeled EH see themselves in the academic community? • What kinds of academic support are offered to African American male children labeled EH in the school and in the community?
Theoretical Framework • Irvine Paradigm (1990): curriculum, tracking, disciplinary practices • Cultural difference theory (Erickson, 1976, Cummins, 1993) • Social mobility theory (Ogbu, 1983): caste-like minority & immigrant minority • Cultural capital theory (Bourdieu, 1970) • African American achievement theory (Perry, 2003)
Methodology • Selection of schools, teachers, and students • Non-participant observation • Formal interviews • Questionnaires • Content Analysis
Hargrove Elementary Schools • Established in 1998 • “C” school in 2004 (“B” school in 2005) • 81% B, 1% W, 14% H • Title I (50% reduced/free lunch)
Demerson Elementary School • Established in 1957 • “A” school in 2004 (“A” school in 2005) • 59% B, 10% W, 26% H • Title I (50% reduced/free lunch)
Hargrove Classroom • 3rd, 4th, & 5th graders • 5 students: 4 Black males, 1 Hispanic female • Small space • 6 Dell computers • Accelerated Reader (AR), Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test (FCAT) Explorer, River Deep, and Lexia • Value posters
Demerson Classroom • 4th & 5th graders • 8 students: 3 females (1 Black), 5 males (4 Black) • Medium space • 3 Compaq computers • AR, FCAT Explorer, Read 180, and Fast Forward • Value posters
Hargrove: Ms. Johnson • Female • Hispanic • Language: English/Spanish • B.A. in Special Education (EH) • 3 1/2 years experience • Self-rating: 8 • Goal: Individual Education Plan (IEP), FCAT • Vision: Attain education & job, responsible paying bills, and successful citizenship
Demerson: Ms. Terry • Female • African American • Language: English • B.A. in Special Education (EH) • 4 years • Self-rating: 5 • Goal: Confidence, academics, and emotions • Vision: Effective communication, productive citizenship, and societal conformity
Hargrove: Jerry • 10 years old • 4th grade • Language: Creole/English • Lower-class neighborhood • Household: Mother & Father • Youngest (3 sisters & 1 brother) • Career: Baseball player & grass cutter • Activities: Basketball, football, soccer, pool, cutting grass, ride bikes, movies, and deejay
Hargrove: Lamar • 10 years old • 4th grade • Language: English • Lower-class neighborhood • Household: Father • Second youngest (1 brother & 3 sisters) • Career: Policeman, mechanic, and wrestler • Activities: football, basketball, and wrestling
Demerson: Bernard • 10 years old • 4th grade • Language : Creole/English • Middle-class neighborhood • Household: Mother • Second youngest (3 brothers) • Career: Football, basketball, and police officer • Activities: Play with cat, bike-ride, create games, and arts & crafts
Student Interview Data Academic Identity Academic Support Career goals: 1. Career interests 2. Role models 3. Confidence of H.S. graduation 4. Activities Activity involvement: 1. School programs 2. Class activities 3. Outside-school activities Academic community feelings: 1. School 2. Class 3. Perception of teacher view Career Advice: 1. Necessity of school 2. Provider of advice 3. Receptivity of advice
Student Interview Data continued Academic Identity Academic Support Perception of teacher: 1. Views on teacher caring 2. Views on teacher perception School Programs: 1. Awareness of programs 2. Recommended programs 3. Participation Teacher support: 1. Academic self-view 2. School/class feelings 3. H.S. graduation 4. Views on teacher caring 5. Views on teacher perception
Teacher Interview Data Self-Perception as Teacher Perception of Black Males Reason for teaching: 1. Decision-making 2. Future length-stay Goals: 1. Goals for students 2. Year accomplishments 3. Academic achievement 4. Teaching changes Experience: 1. Likes/dislikes 2. Work experience 3. Educational attainment Black males & Success: 1. Outlook on their future, care for school, & activities 2. Teacher preferred activities for them Black males & behavior: 1. Causes in class 2. Common behaviors in class, school, and other schools
Teacher Interview Data continued Academic Support Provided Support: 1. Strategies 2. Importance of school 3. Knowledge of lives 4. Frequency of recommended activities Disciplinary Practices: 1. Methods 2. Time spent on discipline Parent Interaction: 1. Calls 2. Visits 3. letters
Findings: Teachers • Teachers used effective instructional practices • Teachers’ viewed students capable of academic achievement • Lack administrative support
Findings: Students • Self-view as good student (2 of 3) • Non-academic and academic activities • Positive future outlook • Support: Academics, careers, and activities • Teachers’ support impacted scholarly ethos, school & class feelings, and views of teachers’ perceptions of them
Conclusion • Teachers’ academic support strongest impact on students’ self-perception as academic scholar • Friends most influential of students’ activity involvement
Implications • Longitudinal study • Tape record interviews • More schools • Interview teachers and students in general inclusion settings • Interview students of varied gender and race • Public & non-public schools