430 likes | 727 Views
Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006. IntroductionName and firmPractice area and experienceFormat of the presentationQuestions after the presentation please. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006. State of the IndustryView point of Ken Simonson Economist for AGCR
E N D
1. Virginia Tech and VSCPA Accounting and Auditing Conference Construction Accounting and Auditing Update 2006
By C. Michael Wade , CPA and Director of Contractors Financial Consulting Services Group
Brown Edwards and Company,L.L.P.
2. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Introduction
Name and firm
Practice area and experience
Format of the presentation
Questions after the presentation please
3. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 State of the Industry
View point of Ken Simonson Economist for AGC
Residential real estate markets are cooling due to higher costs
Commercial activity is increasing including the Richmond district
Construction starts are slow in residential up in commercial
Steel increases continue for the future
Other commodities on the rise
Delivery delays continue also
4. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Update on the Virginia Department of Transportation
Public wants better transportation but no tax increases
Budget approved but no long term $$ for transportation
VDOT’s 6 year program has significant $$ cuts from the original plan passed by Warner
Virginia relies on Federal Gov. for funding 70% with other states average of 42%
Senate and House cannot agree on common plan
The general assembly is still trying to come up with something
September 27,2006 special general assembly session and nine new transportation bills will be introduced
5. A few statistics from CFMA
Legal form 64% S corps, 25% C Corps and 11% other form
Source of work 67% private and 33% public
Top 5 challenges of contractors ( percent listed, ranking)
Health care costs 71% ranked 3rd
Trained field personnel 66% ranked 1st
Workers Compensation costs 48% ranked 5th
Future work 47% ranked 2nd
Insurance costs 44% not ranked
Shortage of project managers ranked 4th
Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006
6. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Views from the IRS on the Industry
IRS has release new industry guide March 2005
Criminal investigations involving contractors in 2005 ….256
IRS has web site with industry specialization including construction
7. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Surety update and the Bond Market
Bond Market
Industry only bonding 40% of their work on the average
Heavy highway bonds more than 80%
Sampled contractors indicate bond credit remained the same as in 2004 ( for 2005 year)
General contractors are bonding less than 20% of subcontractors costs
Most contractors only using 1 surety company. Approximately 6% of the industry is uses more than one surety company in their programs
8. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Surety Market
For 2006 continued tough underwriting guidelines for questionable financial results
Middle market contractors <100,000 no sign of changes
Surety will be competitive for them
No significant price pressure ..some increases
Indemnity still negotiable
Mega contractors are viewed as most risky due to losses in the pass
Surety promises to sue CPA’s on misleading financial statements
9. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Accounting Principles New and Old
Percentage of Completion vs. CCM
PCM used when reasonable and dependable estimates exist with certain conditions
Contractual and estimates can be obtained
CCM use is narrow
Cannot obtain reasonable estimates under certain circumstances and
Financial position and operating results are not significantly different from PCM
1.16
10. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Accounting method vs. tax methods
Accounting methods
PCM
CCM
Tax methods
PCM
CCM
Cash method
Accrual method
Tax methods used in financial statements are under OCBOA rules
11. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Provision for Losses on Uncompleted Contracts
The most ignored rule in construction accounting
This accounting principle carries the highest risk with surety companies
80% of suits by sureties deal with this principle in some form
The calculation
Total projected loss – loss to date= contingency loss accrual on the financial statement presented
Accrual – current liability and cost included in contract revenues earned
12. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Indirect cost allocations
Cost need to be allocated to Cost of Revenues earned and preferably by contract
Classification of accounts between direct and indirect creat the most problems
Allocations need to be systematic and rational
Allocation methods are many
Presentation of these cost outside of Cost of Revenues earned cause sureties the most problem in estimating true profitability of jobs
13. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Unbilled Receivable Issues
Many accountants do not address
IRS will address in audits along with cost capitalized with these costs ( not GAAP)
The issue is cutoff and consistency with use
Many times under billing are due to unbilled receivables
It is best separate unbilled amounts for bonding
Special disclosure needed in the financial statement and policy footnote
14. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Retainage issues
Recording is sometimes overlooked
Classification between short term and long term is an issue with bonding company
Do not forget the retainages associated with subcontractors
Need to disclose amounts in the financial statement as part of receivable disclosure
15. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Contingency accruals
Contract price contingencies
GAAP Accounting – basic contract plus contract options, change orders , claims, provisions for penalties and incentives. Requires judgment in assessing probable outcomes
Tax- as a general rule everything is included even though the “all events test has not been met”. Look back will make up the difference in the year it is realized.
16. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Contract Costing Rules
GAAP Accounting – need to consider warranties, project guarantees, maintenance and other service agreements as accruable under contract costs ( cost must be foreseen to be put in estimated costs to complete on contracts)
Tax – cannot accrue as part of contract cost or others and will be disallowed until cost incurred.
Contingency costs are not deductible for tax purposes
17. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Issues in Financial Reporting Observed By Peer Reviewers
Lack of Contractor statement terminology still being found
Backlog disclosure footnote ( recommended)
90 day receivables and composition of AR
Retainage disclosures and subcontractors amounts
Provision for losses on contracts not addressed
Policy statement of costs and allocated costs
Revenue policy footnote
Related party disclosure and FIN 46 not addressed
Statement of Income not reconciled to job schedules in work papers ( a real surety risk)
Calculation for PCM not GAAP under SOP 81-1
1.40
18. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 New FASB affecting the Industry
FASB 157 Fair Value Measurements
Guidance on measuring Fair Value Only
“FMV is price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date”
Differences between entry price and exit price under FAS 141
Assets measured “highest and best use”
Liabilities measured with nonperformance considerations
Directly effects FMV determination for Business combinations FAS 141
Valuation techniques 1. market 2. Income 3. Cost approach
Input to valuation 1. observable and 2. unobservable inputs
Must prioritize inputs and consider 3 different levels
Effective for F/S issued after November 17, 2007 for fiscal years beginning after that date.
19. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006
FAS 154 Accounting Changes and Corrections of Errors
Supercedes APB 20 and FAS 3 for accounting changes
Old rules required cumulative effect of the change in year of change as separate line on the income statement
New rules require retrospective restatement of prior years for all statements presented or from the earliest practical measurement date
Change in depreciation, amortization or depletion method is now a change in accounting estimate effected by a change in accounting principle ( should only change in recognition of changes in estimated future benefits of the asset, patterns of consumption , or for information available about the future benefits)
Old rules for correction of errors and changes in accounting estimates are the same as old APB 20
Effective for fiscal years beginning after 12/31/2005
20. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 FAS 153 Exchanges or Non monetary Assets ( amends APB 29)
APB 29 stated exchanges of non monetary assets should be measured based fair market value of the assets exchanged ( resulting in possible gain or loss) with a general exception for similar production assets
The new rule eliminates the old exception and replaces it with a new exception pertaining only to assets that “do not” have commercial substance.
New definition- “commercial substance” means future cash flows of the entity are expected to change as a result of the exchange
This rule will effect and encompass PPE and other intangible assets( example under old rules “a truck for a tractor” was exempt now it is not if there is commercial substance)
Effective for fiscal years beginning after 6/30/2005
21. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Example
New asset FMV ( selling price) 10,000
Old asset FMV (appraisal or credit) 3,000
Cash or note pay for new 7,000
Cost basis of old 8,000
Acc depr of old 7,000
Basis 1,000
Entry:Cost of new asset 10,000
Acc deprec of old 7,000
Cost of old asset 8,000
Cash or note payable 7,000
Gain on disposition 2,000 ( 3,000-1000)
22. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 FAS 151 Inventory Costs ( amends ARB 43 chapter 4)
Applies consistent application of abnormal inventory as period expenses ( idle costs, spoilage, rehandling and double freight costs)
Old rules were unclear and could be interpreted and used differently ( possible capital vs. period costs)
This statement formalized consistently in the international and US community
Better defines capital vs. period costs also
Effect on contractors defines a little more the rules for inventory capitalization particularly in quarry operations or manufacturing operations)
Effective for fiscal years beginning after 6/15/2005
23. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 FAS 146 Accounting for Costs Associated with Exit or Disposal Activities ( nullifies EITF 94-3 related to employee termination benefits and certain costs for restructuring)
Old rule states…. Liability was recognized at the date of an entity’s commitment to an exit plan.
New rule says… liability recognized when the liability is incurred
Conclusion– liability is not recognized at the date of commitment to a plan
Effect on contractors if businesses are sold or liquidated regarding employee liabilities or restructure costs (FAS141)
Effective for fiscal years ending after 12/30/2002
24. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 FAS 144 Accounting for Impairment or Disposal of Long-Lived Assets (supersedes FAS 121 and APB 30)
Two types of Long Lived assets to evaluate
LL Assets held and used
For LL assets to be held the rule is ….impairment loss is recognized if the carry amount is not recoverable from its undiscounted cash flows…. which is measured by the difference of carrying amount of the asset and the fair market value
This rule eliminates goodwill for consideration
Probability weighed cash flow estimated approach can be used to determine FMV
Assets identified as not being used but not for sale ( out of date or business changed)
You still must depreciate the assets
25. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 LL Assets to be sold
Value of LL assets held for disposal is the lower of the carry amount or FMV less cost of sale
LL Assets disposed of other than by sale
Requires depreciation to be abandoned
Impairment loss be recognized at date of exchange of similar asset or distributed to owners or spin off (measured by carry valve vs. FMV)
CPA’s need to inquire about the status of equipment to apply this standard
Effective date for fiscal years ending on or after 12/15/2001
26. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 FAS 143 Accounting for Asset Retirement Obligations
Statement addresses the recording of obligations associated with the retirement of long lived assets and the associated retirement costs
Statement applies to all entities
It applies to the legal obligations associated with retirement of LL assets that result from acquisition, construction, development and the normal operations of LL assets
A legal obligation is a obligation that a party is required to settle as a result of laws, statute, ordinance or written or oral contract.
Obligations are to be recorded at FMV in the period it is incurred if a reasonable estimate can be made
This can be tricky in determining “ the period it is incurred”
If you sold or retired at this moment … Would you have an obligation?
For contractors it may include environmental clean up etc on sale of related assets
Concrete and quarry operations…. Evaluate and book clean up for environmental and reclamation purposes???
Effective date …way back when fiscal years beginning after 6/15/2002
27. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 FAS 142 Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets (Super cedes APB 17)
Goodwill and other intangible assets no longer amortized
Impairment is now tested annually for fair value
A two step process (1) screen for impairment (2) measures the impairment
Other intangible assets that have finite useful lives will continue to be amortized over their useful lives
Unamortized intangible assets( have no finite life) must be tested annually by comparison of FMV to carry value
Specialized disclosures require changes in carry value, segregation of amortized and non amortized assets and 5 year amortization disclosure
Effective date way back when .. Fiscal years beginning after 6/30/2001
28. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 FAS 141 Business Combinations (Super cedes APB 16 and FAS 38)
All business combinations are accounted for by the purchase method . Three things to do:
Determine acquiring entity
Determine cost of acquired entity
Determine allocation of cost and liabilities of acquired entity
Three requirements Must now separate other intangible assets from Goodwill ( must identify)
Much better guidance on identifying the intangible assets
Disclosures require reasons for business combination and allocation of purchase price
Allocation rules did not significantly change but there are changes ( study the examples)
Effective fiscal years ending after 6/30/2001( way back when)
2.10
29. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Financial Interpretations ( FIN’s)
FIN 48 Accounting for Uncertainty in Taxes
Requires evaluations of uncertain tax positions if client is examined by the IRS
Need to incorporate the tax effect into the tax provision
Evaluation should be based on the merits of a technical tax position
General rule -It is greater than 50% chance it would happen on examination
CPA exposure- IRS examination results in additional tax not booked in previous financial reports for which you knew of the issue – misleading financial statements
Effective date - NOW
30. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 FIN 46R Consolidation of Variable Interest Entities
( A Simple View Point)
Rules require three items:
Identification of variable interest entity (VIE)
Identification of variable interest ( form of support)
Identification of primary beneficiary (PB)
If all three are present and identifiable then VIE is consolidated with the PB
FIN46R provides test and rules for identifying the three requirements above
USE PPC Related Party Program as practice aid ( Appendix 2E)
Effective Now and it effects most all contractors is some fashion
31. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Guidance Related to Natural Disasters ( Technical Practice Aid TPA section 5400.05)
This TPA gives you guidance for the following issues-
Classifications in the income statement for losses incurred in a natural disaster (ND) ie Hurricanes !!!
Asset impairment evaluation for ND ( FMV vs carry value)
Liability recognition for non impairment losses associated with ND such as additional expenses required due to ND ( environmental issues etc)
Accounting for insurance recoveries ( income and reinvestment)
Additional disclosure requirements
32. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Engagement Risk For Contractors
Understanding the Entity and Its Environment
Understand the construction industry
Know your client and their financial objectives and motives objectives
Identify the entities business risk
Many contractors lack proper internal accounting controls ( A significant Fraud Risk Factor)
33. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Auditing Variable Interest Entities
December 2003 Issuance of FIN 46R
Issues are common to small and medium size businesses
Note these related Staff Positions
Para. 13 FIN 46 on reporting VIN’s
Calculation of expected losses FIN 46
Evaluating holders of equity interest to determine if they have direct or indirect interests FIN 46R
Implementation issues related to Leasing Transactions
34. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Provisions in Engagement letters to eliminate certain accountants liability with the client
AICPA ethics committee issues new ruling interpretation ET sec. 101.01
Certain types of liability provisions in engagement letters violate independence issues( i.e. elimination of actual damages from negligence or the client’s negligence)
Other liability provisions would not impair independence ( i.e. client’s knowing misrepresentations or willful misconduct or fraudulent behavior
Be sure you research unique changes you are making to your engagement letters to assure you are not jeopardizing your independence
2.20
35. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Internal Control Deficiencies
Most common deficiencies noted
Considerations of job site visits as it relates to controls on the job site
Internal control considerations related to bidding and estimating
Lack of sufficient evidence to support estimated cost to complete and controls designed to arrive at those estimates
Other Issues
Lack of competent personnel
Documentation related to income recognition
36. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Companies are changing auditors at record rates
Be advised to conform to the requirements of AU Section 315
Get permission from the client to make inquiry
Make inquiries with the predecessor
Allow review of work papers if needed
Association with press releases in today’s business environment
Just a word of caution …Don’t be associated if misleading
37. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Risk of Fraudulent Reporting and Improper Accounting Estimates
Review all significant of Contracts ( encouraged during review engagements)
Job Site visits to determine the status and completion percentage of a contract in progress ( not required by highly recommended)
Auditing contract costs
Components of contract cost related to original bid
Proper classification of costs between contracts
Sufficient audit procedure on contract costs
Estimated cost to complete
Need to consider types of contracts
Fixed price ( high risk)
Cost plus ( lower risk)
Construction management ( can be high risk based on contract)
Design build ( more like cost plus) (lower risk but depends on contract)
38. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Compilation and Review Engagements
Fraud and illegal acts
SSARS 12 requires understanding with client in the form of an engagement letter
“Need to include separate paragraph in the engagement letter addressing your responsibility for detecting fraud”
Rise in litigation risk in Compilation Engagements related to fraud
Perform procedures in STRICK CONFORMAMCE with SSARS with appropriate documentation
Re assess client acceptance and continuance
Talk to client about fraud and their risk and yours
Address in engagement letters
39. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Industry Developments
Rising Interest rates, Energy costs , debt levels and softening housing market
Heights risk on issuing financial statements over recognition of income and going concern issues
Viability and liquidation risk
Overvaluation of assets and working capital short falls effecting job continuance and provision for loss considerations
40. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Inventory obsolescence ( as if effects service contractors, quarry operators and manufacturers)
Customers with high levels of debts and negative working capital issues
Signals going concern issues and provision for losses on uncompleted contracts
Impairment and recoverability of assets
Equipment not in use ( FMV write downs)
41. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Layoffs and Lack of Qualified Help
Ability of contractor to complete work – going concern possible
Outsourcing ? – not considered a big risk to the construction industry
Raising capital and Baby Boomer Transitions
More difficult for the construction industry
Consolidators are on the rise again mainly in the capital markets
Be careful of buyers who do not understand the industry
Observation -Pension plans are being liquidated or transitioned in to plans more controllable for funding by employers
42. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Mergers and Acquisitions are heating up
FAS 141 has changed accounting methods for M&A
Internal controls are perceived weaker with M&A transactions
Possibility of worsened financial performance with contractors consolidated as in the past
Statistic- 80% of buyers are paying more than exit price FMV
Attacks on IT
Fraud risk to accountants
Know your clients computer controls
43. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 Improper Accounting to be aware of
Revenue recognition ( percent complete measurements)
Accounting for insurance contracts ( self insurance arrangements with under funded liabilities)
Business combination accounting ( to much value on amortizable intangible assets)
New Bankruptcy laws
Positives – easier collection of debts
Negative – harder to rid debt under ch. 11
Word of caution – screen the law firms and get approved by the bankruptcy trustee before you pick up your pencil!!
2.40
44. Construction Accounting and Auditing Update for 2006 THE END
If you have questions or concerns I would be glad to talk to you individually