140 likes | 227 Views
The State of US Banking Jorge A. Solis Director of Banking State of Illinois. U.S. Mexico Chamber of Commerce 6/11/09. Conditions of United States Banks. Over leveraged Limited Access to Capital Heavy reliance of brokered deposits Low profitability Continued to be saddled with toxic assets
E N D
The State of US BankingJorge A. SolisDirector of BankingState of Illinois U.S. Mexico Chamber of Commerce 6/11/09
Conditions of United States Banks • Over leveraged • Limited Access to Capital • Heavy reliance of brokered deposits • Low profitability • Continued to be saddled with toxic assets • Low commercial loan demand • Government Intervention • Mismatched balance sheet/asset – liability • Stresses in Liquidity • Continued asset write downs
Conditions of United States Banks Continued • Unable to securitize “high risk” assets • Impaired capital due to low asset valuations • Limited management experience in handling current crisis • Yield chase resulted in significant losses
Conditions of Banks in Illinois • 434 State Chartered Banks and 41 Thrifts (largest number in country) • 85 percent of banks rated in top 2 categories • The median assets of these banks is slightly over $100 million. (ranging from $ 5 million to $ 70 billion). • Mostly privately held community banks • 35 received TARP funds
Conditions of Illinois Banks Continued • Significant concentration of commercial real estate • General reliance on core deposits • Not as exposed to high risk derivative type products • Shrinking loan demand due to current economic conditions • Operating in highly competitive market place
Conditions of Illinois Banks Continued • 6 banks (4 state, 2 national) have failed in 2009 • No consumer lost any funds in failures • Banking services resumed in all communities
Common Trends in Problem Banks in Illinois • High percentages of adversely classified assets (primarily commercial real estate loans) • Over-reliance on brokered deposits • Weak oversight by boards of directors • Heavy Concentrations of Credit • Out of market lending • Investments outside of managements core competencies
Short Term Expectations for Banks in the United States • Pain not over • Continued government intervention (control, executive pay, products and support of larger institutions) • More failures • Systemic Risk Regulation • Limited return of TARP funds • Limited appetite for purchase of their toxic assets • Need to deal with interest rate sensitivity issues in an expected near term higher rate interest rate environment • Shrinking balance sheets • Extension of FDIC Temporary Liquidity Guarantee Program
Medium Term Expectations for Banks in the United States • Risk Weighted Capital Requirements • Separation of retail (“utility banks) from investment (“casino”) banks e.g. Glass-Steagall • Better matched asset liability mix • Diversification in portfolios and funding sources • Lower LDR (loan to deposit ratio)Laddered maturities in deposit sources
Medium Term Expectations for Banks in the United States Continued • Executive pay tied to long term performance • Increased regulation • Continued shrinkage in number of banks • Need to increase capital in good times for use in bad times • Increased use of technology to reduce labor costs
Long Term Trends for Banks in the United States • Return to traditional banking • Higher (and more expensive) capital requirements • A return to more “boring” banking (e.g. “originate to hold” rather than “originate to distribute” • Fewer exotic asset classifications (CDO, CDS) • Reliance on “sticky” deposits • Reduced risk taking (more conservativelending)
Long Term Trends for Banks in the United States Continued • Less capital consuming products due to high cost of capital • Seek the un-banked in their market • Engaged and experienced Board of Directors • Fee intensive P and L’s • More careful attention to the liability side of the balance sheet
Lessons Learned • The answer to “Too Big to Fail” is to make them smaller • Government should purge banks that are big enough to hold the system ransom • There is capital and then there is Capital • If you behave like a bank – you should be regulated like one • Capital trumps regulation • Strong management is preferred over a good business model • Regulators are fallible and regrettably always one step behind
And the Good News…… • What a better time to start a bank? • -Money is cheap • -Borrowers looking for a “willing and able to lend bank” • -People are saving more • -Immediate threat of nationalization is no longer present • -Attractive Interest Rate Margins • -Pool of talented bankers available • The Government Demonstrated it can and will act quickly • Public Trust returning • FDIC Insurance Coverage expanded • Bankers and Regulators have learned tough lessons