1 / 38

INTRA-HOUR SCHEDULING

INTRA-HOUR SCHEDULING. Troy Simpson – Bonneville Power Administration John Schaffroth – Pacificorp Power Matt Richard – Portland General Electric Marilyn Franz – Nv Energy. Panelists Disclaimer.

flint
Download Presentation

INTRA-HOUR SCHEDULING

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. INTRA-HOUR SCHEDULING Troy Simpson – Bonneville Power Administration John Schaffroth – Pacificorp Power Matt Richard – Portland General Electric Marilyn Franz – Nv Energy

  2. Panelists Disclaimer • The views and information presented by the panelists does not necessarily express those of their companies and is subject to change. • All items should be verified as in effect at time of use. • No liability will be accepted for incorrect or incomplete information.

  3. Intra-Hour TSR Parameters Comparison

  4. e-Tag Transaction Intra-Hour Parameters

  5. e-Tag Transaction Intra-Hour Parameters

  6. Overview of Intra-Hour Scheduling Pilot 6

  7. Intra-Hour Scheduling Pilot – Phase I (cont’d) Phase I of the pilot was implemented on December 1, 2009. The purpose of this pilot was to evaluate and verify wind generators’ ability to implement and submit mid-hour schedule changes in response to over generation. During Phase I, BPA assessed the value of the pilot through an evaluation criteria of events and customer contacts to determine interest and value (both through e-mails and phone calls). Phase I has been extended for an undetermined length. 8/16/2014 7 7

  8. Intra-Hour Scheduling Phase I Scope Review Criteria identified in the Business Practice: Purchasing Non-firm NERC Priority Code 1-NS transmission rights prior to submitting an e-Tag Submitting a new within-hour non-firm e-Tag request between the top of the hour and 15 minutes after the hour Must be a wind resource Must be an export When generation for wind resources exceeds the existing schedules For service beginning on the half hour Must have a 10 minute ramp

  9. Intra-Hour SchedulingSystem Changes Integrated e-Tags into EMS New Transmission Product Non-Firm Priority 1-NS New e-Tag Validation For any intra-hour request (Start Time <> :00) Request Type Start Time Stop Time Start Ramp Duration Stop Ramp Duration 9

  10. Example of Intra-Hour Scheduling Effect Hour Ending 11 scheduling window closes Hour Ending 11 intra-hour scheduling window closes Hour Ending 11 intra-hour schedule 3 2 1 10

  11. Intra-Hour Scheduling Phase I Results(Through 4/16/10)

  12. Intra-Hour SchedulingCustomer Feedback Survey respondents identified several benefits of using intra-hour scheduling: mitigation or reduction of DSO 216 limit events minimizing generation imbalance minimizing forecasting error Respondents also identified several obstacles to initial participation in intra-hour scheduling: balancing authority restrictions to export only and POR within BPAT BA the need to complete modifications to other BA transmission tariffs availability of appropriate transmission rights type of e-Tags that can be used short scheduling window 8/16/2014 12 12

  13. Intra-Hour SchedulingCustomer Feedback Respondents identified some areas that BPA should consider for future phases: the ability to buy back generation (we interpret this to mean to decrease schedules) include all types of participation such as e-Tags within the BPA Balancing Authority, non-wind exports, imports and wheel through e-Tags allow the use of existing firm rights more time flexibility. Wants to submit revised schedules right after close of hourly ramp if wind really picks up instead of waiting to 00:25. 8/16/2014 8/16/2014 13 13 13

  14. Intra-Hour SchedulingNext Steps Evaluation of Possible Future Changes Options Include: No Changes Allow Wind Exports to Adjust Schedules Allow Transmission Wheels Allow Non-Wind Exports Allow Imports and Internal Schedules No Timeline or Decision Yet Regional momentum for increased scheduling flexibility. 14

  15. More Information www.transmission.bpa.gov Business Practices Wind Information 15

  16. Intra-hour Scheduling May 11, 2010 John Schaffroth

  17. PacifiCorp’s Intra-hour Business Practice • Started on December 1, 2009 • 10 minute ramp • Tag submittal timeframe • Not restricted to wind

  18. Outline of BP • Tag is not restricted to wind generation, can be for anything • It must be a new schedule, no extensions or adjustments to existing tags • Tags submitted between xx:05 and xx:20 for that operating hour

  19. Outline of BP (cont.) • OASIS reservations are all new Hourly Non-firm Point-to-Point (no redirects) and must be purchased before tag is submitted • Ramp duration xx:25 – xx:35 • PSE’s are only allowed one tag per hour (including mistake tags)

  20. Where to find it

  21. Where to find it (cont.)

  22. Where to find it (cont.)

  23. Questions?

  24. Future Actions • PGE intends to continue allowing intra-hour transactions as a normal practice • PGE will continue to support the Joint Initiative and WECC to promote and enhance region wide acceptance of intra-hour transactions

  25. PGE Intra-Hour Transactions

  26. Intra-Hour Transactions at PGE • February 1, 2010 - PGE modified its OATT to enable intra-hour scheduling in Section 13.8 and 14.6 • February 15, 2010 PGE began excepting intra-hour transactions • Two Business Practices Posted on OASIS • Intra-hour Transmission Reservations • Intra-hour Requests for Interchange • Practices align with BPAT and PACW • As of April 20th PGE has transacted 36 intra-hour schedules worth about 1500 MWhs

  27. PGE OATT Change • Intra-hour scheduling changes will also be permitted if authorized by the Transmission Provider in a business practice and such intra-hour scheduling changes are made in accordance with the timeline contained in such business practice provided that all parties to the interchange transaction agree to the modification.

  28. Intra-hour Business Practices on PGE OASIS

  29. Intra-hour Transmission Reservations Business Practice • Use Hourly Non-Firm if new TSR needed • Obtain within the first 15 minutes of the intended hour or anytime before • Charged for the entire hour • Use any existing non-firm, firm, PTP or Network reservation • Redirects are also acceptable • An Intra-hour Transaction will not bump any other transaction regardless of its reservation type • New TSR is dependent on sufficient ATC

  30. Intra-hour Requests for Interchange Business Practice • Must be submitted as new e-Tag for each hourly use • Must be submitted between XX:00 and XX:15 • Start Time must be XX:30 • Stop Time must be XX:00 of next hour • Straddle Ramp duration will be 10 minutes • Limited to one transaction per customer per hour • Will not be allowed to bump any implemented transaction • Curtailments in the intra-hour time frame will be consistently applied and under the terms of the PGE OATT • Transaction may be import, export or wheel as appropriate on any PGE posted path • Transactions are processed on a best efforts, as available, first come first served basis

  31. Future Actions • PGE intends to continue allowing intra-hour transactions as a normal practice • PGE will continue to support the Joint Initiative and WECC to promote and enhance region wide acceptance of intra-hour transactions

  32. Intra-Hour Transmission/Within-Hour Transactions Marilyn Franz NV Energy

  33. TOPICS • Why did NVE create Intra-Hour Scheduling Business Practices? • What is required? • How many Intra-Hour/Within Hour Scheduling Transactions have occurred • NVE next steps

  34. Request for Intra-Hour BP • Following event on PACE • Response to Interconnection Reliability • Response to Intermittent Resources • Flexibility as able to respond

  35. Intra-Hour Transmission BP • Submitted after the start of the hour • Single hour – Hourly Service • Existing (Eligible) Customer • Valid Path • Available Transfer Capability (ATC) exists • Preconfirmation flag • Redirects for one hour • Intra-Hour Transmission Resales prohibited • Offer/Bid Price for full hourly rate

  36. Within-Hour Transactions BP • No Reliability events underway (USF, etc.) • Have a Transmission Service Reservation • ATC exists - No Bumping • Submitted btwn XX:05-XX:20 • Allowing 10 minutes prior to start for processing • Minimum duration 30 min. • Max duration 45 minutes • All Entities with Approval Rights must approve

  37. Going Forward • Develop Tools/Validations • Review other TP Business Practices • Participate TP Forums • WestConnect • WesTTrans • ISAS • Work Towards Standardization • Future FERC OATT Filing

More Related