1 / 26

Relatedness, body size and paternity in the alpine newt, Triturus alpestris

Relatedness, body size and paternity in the alpine newt, Triturus alpestris. Trenton W. J. Garner and Benedikt R. Schmidt. INTRODUCTION. Sexual-selection─ Traditionally a. F emales judge male quality via a trait or traits.(body size, physical vigour and costly ornaments)

fonda
Download Presentation

Relatedness, body size and paternity in the alpine newt, Triturus alpestris

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Relatedness, body size and paternity in the alpine newt, Triturus alpestris Trenton W. J. Garnerand Benedikt R. Schmidt

  2. INTRODUCTION • Sexual-selection─ Traditionally a. Females judge male quality via a trait or traits.(body size, physical vigour and costly ornaments) b. A male that possesses the trait optimum represents the best choice for every female. (Andersson 1994) Q: Selection for a single optimum should rapidly exhaust any adaptive variation in a population? Q: How adaptive genetic variation can be maintained in a population where strong sexual selection favours a certain phenotype?

  3. INTRODUCTION • Sexual-selection─ Recently a. Each individual female has her own ‘best’ mate. b. The combination of male and female genotypes etermines the mate-choice optimum. (Zeh 1996) Adaptive genetic variation is maintained because each individual has its own best mate. (Tregenza & Wedell 2000)

  4. INTRODUCTION • Males of the two newt species (Triturus vulgaris &T. cristatus) develop large dorsal crests during the breeding season. (Halliday 1977) • Large-crested males are able to signal quality both through theheight of the crest and the vigour of their courtship. (Green 1991; Gabor & Halliday 1997)

  5. Triturus vulgaris male

  6. INTRODUCTION Triturus alpestris─ • Develop no or relatively small and invariant crests during the breeding season. (Arntzen & Sparreboom 1989) • Exhibit courtship behaviours that lack many of the strong vigour signals. (Arntzen & Sparreboom 1989) • Polyandry has been detected in this species. (Halliday 1998; Rafinski & Osikowski 2002)

  7. Triturus alpestris Female Male

  8. larva

  9. INTRODUCTION Triturus alpestris─ • The roles of phenotype and genotype in the mating system of T. alpestris? (1) Does relatedness influence paternity? (2) Does male body size influence paternity? (3) Does female body size influence paternity? (4) Does polyandrycan influence offspring fitness? fitness：fecundity and hatching success

  10. MATERIAL & METHODS • Experimental protocol Newts were collected after migrating to the pond verge but before entering the water. ↓ Measuremented their weight. ↓ Divided males into two groups. [large (L) and small (S)] ↓ Paired

  11. Larger(L) Smaller(S) ( 1, 2, 3, 4,…13 ) ( 1, 2, 3, 4,…13 ) MATERIAL & METHODS Pair pattern Male(N=26) Female (N=13) Ramdam ML1 + MS1 + F?? a trio And so on (Total：13 trios)

  12. All males→cuted tail tip→frozan at -80℃ MATERIAL & METHODS ↓ Trios were placed in plastic tubs filled to within several centimetres of the rim with aged water. ↓ After undisturbed for a 3 day, removed all males.

  13. MATERIAL & METHODS ↓ Trios were placed in plastic tubs filled to within several centimetres of the rim with aged water. ↓ After undisturbed for a 3 day, removed all males. ↓ Placed anchored plastic strips into each tub(female will wrap their eggs in it). → Checked it every 1-3 days ↓ At regular intervals, Added several Rana sp. larvae and zooplankton to each tub as food for females.

  14. MATERIAL & METHODS ↓ After 18 day,there were more than half of all female stopped depositing eggs.→Removed all females. ↓ Eggs were kept indoors, in 0.5 l tubs containing aged tap water. ↓ Recorded the total number of eggs and the total number of eggs hatching for each clutch. ↓ Larvaewere sacrificed and stored individually at -80 °C for geneticanalysis.

  15. MATERIAL & METHODS (b) Molecular analysis DNA was extracted from tail tips and sacrificed larvae. ↓ PCR(Ta3Caga1 and Ta1Caga4.) ↓ Electrophoresed

  16. MATERIAL & METHODS (c) Data analysis genetic similarity (r-values) between adults within trios. ↓ using the program Kinship v. 1.3.1, with cross (1–13) as the group variable and results displayed by group. Relatedness of males to females was entered into the model as a categorical variable (more versus lessrelated) Test the hypotheses that female mass, difference in mass among paired males and male relatedness to females affect the proportion of offspring sired. ↓ using a generalizedlinear model with binomial error.

  17. MATERIAL & METHODS (c) Data analysis Tested whether multiply sired clutches are primarily fathered by a given relatedness category. ↓ Fisher’s exact test Tested for differences in fitness components between singly and multiply sired clutches. ↓ Two-sample t-test.

  18. RESULTS ★ ★ 1.The mean and variances of both fitness components did not differ significantly between multiply and singly sired clutches.

  19. RESULTS 2. The relatedness of females to males had a statistically significant effect on the proportion of offspring sired. when it was entered as a continuous variable. 3. Female mass and difference in mass between the males did not significantly affect the proportion of offspring sired.

  20. DISCUSSION 1. Paternity in the alpine newt is significantly influenced by parental genetic similarity butnot body size. Our study did not control for the number of permatophores transferred to the female. as was also the case with sand lizards (Olsson et al. 1996). Female choice for inbreeding avoidance,and inbreeding avoidance has been implicated in a variety of mating systems. Inbreeding negatively affects：reproductive output, survival, fitness…. There is no sexual selection on male body size in these newts.

  21. DISCUSSION Larger females did not exhibit more multiple paternity than smaller ones. Female body size does not correlate significantlywith the number of eggs deposited.so It is unlikely that increased male interest and affect paternity patterns. Furthermore, pre-insemination, female preference for genetically dissimilar males.

  22. DISCUSSION 2. Our comparison of multiply and singly sired clutches revealed no differences in fecundity or fertility. Polyandryaffords no fitness benefits to newts.

  23. DISCUSSION If less-related males are preferred, or, at least, more successfulfathers, then why should females mate with more-relatedmales? Female multiple mating resulted in increased fecundity and fertility, and multiple mating is probably driven byfertility assurance. (Osikowski &Rafinski 2001) Benefits from multiple spermatophores may be detectable only over a longer mating and subsequent oviposition period than we provided. Provides no evidence against the fertility-assurance hypothesis because of the experimental procedures.

  24. DISCUSSION Female mate choice in this species can be explained as a form of pre-insemination mate choice for genetic compatibility: (relies primarily on chemical communication and a female preference for genetically dissimilar males.) what is the phylogenetic distribution of female choice for genetic compatibility v.s. condition-dependent traits in the genus Triturus? In future：1. incorporating a phylogenetic approach focusing on the occurrence of female choice for genetic compatibility are required, 2. potentially confounding effects of fertility assurance need to be accounted for.

  25. Thanks for your attention

More Related