1 / 83

ISO New England Environmental Advisory Group (EAG) Teleconference Final Draft Slides 12-02-09

ISO New England Environmental Advisory Group (EAG) Teleconference Final Draft Slides 12-02-09. December 4, 2009 9:30 – 11:30 AM. Agenda. Introductions and Administrative. Jim Platts. 2010 EAG Teleconferences/Meetings. Proposed Dates Feb 12 Apr 16 Jun 11 Jul 9 or Aug 13 Oct 8 Dec 17

frankiej
Download Presentation

ISO New England Environmental Advisory Group (EAG) Teleconference Final Draft Slides 12-02-09

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. ISO New England Environmental Advisory Group (EAG) TeleconferenceFinalDraft Slides 12-02-09 December 4, 2009 9:30 – 11:30 AM

  2. Agenda

  3. Introductions and Administrative Jim Platts

  4. 2010 EAG Teleconferences/Meetings • Proposed Dates • Feb 12 • Apr 16 • Jun 11 • Jul 9 or Aug 13 • Oct 8 • Dec 17 • Please register for each meeting through ISO TEN • Meetings will be on the ISO-NE calendar with the registration link to ISO TEN: https://isone.cyberu.com/client/isone/default.aspx

  5. RSP10 PAC Meetings • The following PAC meetings are planned: • December 16, 2009 – Inter-Area Planning, Draft Economic RSP09 Study Results, Vermont Needs and Solution Studies, Transmission Updates, and CMP Transmission Owner PAC Meetings • January 21, 2010 – Transmission System Needs, NEWIS, Short-Run Load Forecast, Interface and LMP Duration Curves, Western MA Project Cost Estimates and Controls • February 24, 2010 – RSP10 Scope of Work, State and Long-Run Load Forecast, Transmission Update, Stakeholder Process for Submitting Economic Study Requests • Watch for additional items that may be added to the PAC agendas

  6. Interregional Planning Stakeholder Advisory Committee (IPSAC) Meeting • December 18, 2009 • Sheration Hotel, Bradley Airport, Windsor Locks, CT • Preliminary Agenda: • 10:00 Administrative • 10:15 Vermont-New York New Interconnection • 10:45 Environmental Issues • 11:15 Northeast Natural Gas System Update • 11:45 Common Economic Database and Analysis • 12:00 Lunch • 1:00 NYISO/PJM Market Efficiency Analysis • 1:30 NYISO/PJM Reliability Analysis • 2:00 NYISO/ISO-NE Production Cost Analysis • 2:30 NCSP Report and Other Interregional Planning Activities • 3:15 Summary and Next Steps • 3:30 Adjourn • Register at: http://www.iso-ne.com/calendar/detail.action?eventId=101179&link=yes&filter=off

  7. Review of Ozone Exceedance Days in New England with Data Provided from EPA and CT DEP Jim Platts

  8. Ozone Exceedance Days in New England Source: 2008 Annual Report on Air Quality in New England, U.S. EPA Region 1

  9. Connecticut Ozone 8-Hour Data Source: 2008 Annual Report on Air Quality in New England, U.S. EPA Region 1

  10. Maine Ozone 8-Hour Data Source: 2008 Annual Report on Air Quality in New England, U.S. EPA Region 1

  11. Massachusetts Ozone 8-Hour Data Source: 2008 Annual Report on Air Quality in New England, U.S. EPA Region 1

  12. New Hampshire Ozone 8-Hour Data Source: 2008 Annual Report on Air Quality in New England, U.S. EPA Region 1

  13. Rhode Island Ozone 8-Hour Data Source: 2008 Annual Report on Air Quality in New England, U.S. EPA Region 1

  14. Vermont Ozone 8-Hour Data Source: 2008 Annual Report on Air Quality in New England, U.S. EPA Region 1

  15. New England Summer Peak Loads vs. Ozone Exceedances

  16. Exceedance Days = 38 Source: John Moskal, EPA Region 1

  17. Exceedance Days = 30 Source: John Moskal, EPA Region 1

  18. Exceedance Days = 37 Source: John Moskal, EPA Region 1

  19. Exceedance Days = 24 Source: John Moskal, EPA Region 1

  20. Connecticut Peak Ozone Violations* onNew England Peak Load Days *Source: CT DEP. New EPA standard is 75 parts per billon (ppb) established March 2008

  21. ISO-NE Peak Day NOx Emissions Analysis (Continued from prior EAG meetings)

  22. Review of Purpose and Chronology • Purpose • Examine NOx emissions on ISO-NE’s historic peak load days to provide a better basis for estimating future NOx emission reductions from energy efficiency during peak load periods • Chronology • June 12th EAG meeting: ISO-NE proposed to analyze the five highest peak load days for the years 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008 • August 14th EAG meeting: Presented some preliminary results based on ISO proprietary generator NOx rates • October 16th EAG meeting: Presented preliminary results for all 20 days based on EPA data and ISO data, for generators not in EPA database

  23. Today Presenting Preliminary Final Results • Using EPA plus ISO NOx data • Variations in NOx hourly rates for all 20 peak load days • Calculation of peak hour and daily NOx emission rates for NE generation system • Using all ISO NOx data • Results of calculating peak hourly NOx rates for a theoretical 500 MW generation decrement for all 20 peak days • Top 500 MW in bid stack • Top 500 MW adjusted for conventional hydro • Top 500 MW adjusted for conventional hydro and transmission constrained resources • Two questions for the EAG: • How to package these preliminary results • How will they be used?

  24. Review of Key results Shown Previously to EAG

  25. New England 20 Peak Days’ Hourly NOx Emissions

  26. New England 20 Peak Days’ Cumulative Daily NOx Emissions Peak Days: Yr/Mo/Day

  27. New England Hourly NOx Emissions vs. System Generation August 2, 2006 – Highest Peak July 18, 2008 – Lowest Peak

  28. Preliminary Observations – New England Peak-Load Day NOx Emissions: 2005 to 2008 • Peak hour NOx emissions ranged from 6 to 13 tons over the 20 highest peak-load days • For the all-time peak load day (8/2/06), at the peak hour, operating emergency generators added approximately 3 tons, or 12 total tons the day • Cumulative daily NOx emissions over the 20 peak days ranged from 122 to 228 tons, including emergency generators that operated on the all time peak day • Daily NOx emissions show a similar pattern to daily system generation, i.e. increasing and decreasing as the load builds and declines throughout the day

  29. Graphs for 20 Peak Days: System Peak NOx vs. System Generation and Hourly NOx Rates

  30. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/19/2005 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate* *Hourly change in NOx emissions (lbs) divided by hourly change in system generation (MWh)

  31. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/26/2005 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  32. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/27/2005 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  33. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 8/05/2005 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  34. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 8/11/2005 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  35. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/17/2006 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  36. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/18/2006 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  37. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 8/01/2006 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  38. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 8/02/2006 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  39. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 8/03/2006 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  40. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/26/2007 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  41. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/27/2007 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  42. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 8/02/2007 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  43. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 8/03/2007 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  44. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 8/07/2007 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  45. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 6/09/2008 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  46. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 6/10/2008 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  47. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/08/2008 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  48. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/09/2008 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  49. ISO-NE Peak NOx Analysis – 7/18/2008 Hourly System NOx vs. Generation Hourly Incremental NOx Rate

  50. Variables Possibly Affecting NOx Rates • Sudden load changes • System topology • Unit commitment • Forced outages • Transmission out-of-service • Economic dispatch • Dispatch of energy limited hydro • RMR units – 2nd contingency protection • Imports/Exports

More Related