60 likes | 188 Views
BL1A Shield Plug Status Update. Jason Chak UCN Monthly Meeting July 24, 2013. Steel Blocks. 75 metric tons of steel Andy is point person for requesting/receiving quotes. TSH0134. TSH0126. TSH0130. TSH0137. TSH0139. TSH0142. Steel Block Quotes.
E N D
BL1A Shield Plug Status Update Jason Chak UCN Monthly Meeting July 24, 2013
Steel Blocks • 75 metric tons of steel • Andy is point person for requesting/receiving quotes TSH0134 TSH0126 TSH0130 TSH0137 TSH0139 TSH0142
Steel Block Quotes • If receiving cut-plates from overseas, the local costs will be: • Reworking the plates if out-of-spec • uncertainty in quality control of overseas materials • Weld prep, welding, and machining on large capacity machines • Ivor guesses $79K to $113K on top of overseas material cost
Steel Block Quotes • Project Risks: • Overseas factories • PROS: Half the price compared to local • CONS: Limited oversight, accountability or certification of workers • CONS: Potential to delay shutdown schedule to deal with any problems discovered after shipping • CONS: Potential for additional rework costs • CONS: Potential for hidden safety problems • North American machine shops: • PROS: Easier to inspect the product before shipping and ask for rework • PROS: Local laws require certification compliance, therefore safer products • CONS: Maybe twice as expensive as overseas • Risk Mitigation: • Investigate track record of each overseas supplier (Andy)
New custom blocks • Dragan is working on two custom blocks. • Should be done in the next few days • Total of 9 metric tons • Will send out for quotes afterwards TSH0146 (x2) TSH0145