90 likes | 171 Views
The Nature-Nurture Debate. Leslie Price 1/29/08. What is the Nature-Nurture Debate?. The question of whether a child’s development is most influenced by genetics (nature) or environment (nurture). Nature. The argument that biological factors have the strongest influence on development
E N D
The Nature-Nurture Debate Leslie Price 1/29/08
What is the Nature-Nurture Debate? • The question of whether a child’s development is most influenced by genetics (nature) or environment (nurture).
Nature • The argument that biological factors have the strongest influence on development • Any capabilities or limitations are innate • “genetic blueprint” for development exists
Nurture • The argument that environmental factors have the strongest influence on development. • Environmental influences: • Family • School • Peers • Culture
Interactionism (Hebb 1949) • A range of genetic influences can be expressed differently in a range of potential environments • Both nature and nurture influence development, but one may be predominant at a certain point in life. • Heredity and environment cannot be separated • Maybe they shouldn’t be separated • This is what psychologists believe today
Why is this debate important? • Implications for schooling, parenting, etc. • i.e. nurture and parenting parents could completely shape children’s behavior • i.e. nature and parenting nothing parents could do to improve behavior
Twin Studies • Study identical twins raised separately and fraternal twins raised together • Similarities genetics or combination of genetics and similar experiences • Differences must be due to environment • Adoption studies
What do Psychologists believe today? • Most psychologists today agree that both nature and nurture play a role in development. • Do not know the extent of either.