210 likes | 334 Views
CSC 8570 -- USI. Class Meeting 5 September 20, 2006. Research Project. Short presentation One spokesperson Five minutes Hypothesis, variables, initial experimental design PowerPoint Questions and comments from the audience. Research Teams. A: Pam & Srivani B: Karthik & Mukul
E N D
CSC 8570 -- USI Class Meeting 5 September 20, 2006
Research Project • Short presentation • One spokesperson • Five minutes • Hypothesis, variables, initial experimental design • PowerPoint • Questions and comments from the audience
Research Teams • A: Pam & Srivani • B: Karthik & Mukul • C: Archana & Sandya C. • D: Mike, Natalie, Tim • E: Pranavi, Samsha, Sandya S. • F: Kallie, Kevin, Sara • G: Anush, Jeff, Adam
Mental Models • As theories • As problem spaces • As homomorphisms of the physical world • Derived from language, perception, or imagination • As representations of representational artifacts (yoked state space) • As computationally equivalent to external representations (internalization)
Ways of Understanding • Examination of spaces • Example: Calendaring system • Relationships to: • Task analysis • GUEPs: Generative User Engineering Principles • Good and bad interfaces
Spaces • Problem space • Yoked state space • Goal space • Device space • Minimal device space
Space Diagram • Pair up by threes • Analyze the three concept maps of spaces • Prepare a union map on the transparency
Problem Space • Set of possible states • States of what? • Example: RPN as rote operations vs. visualized stack model
Yoked State Space • Goal space, device space, and mapping from goal space to device space and conversely. • Concept of representation of abstract idea by familiar artifact
Goal Space • Set of user goals for a system • Example: System is a word processor. Goal space is set of text structures: document, paragraph, sentence, line. Operations on goal space are insertion and deletion of text structures. Device space is representation of goal space elements as sequences of characters.
Device Space • Particular kind of problem space • Represents with an artifact (a device) the goal space
Minimal Device Space • A device space with exactly the set of tasks necessary for representing the goal space.
Example: Calendaring System • Goal space • Attributes: now, cyclical, linear • Intentions: • Pulse: at a particular time • Step: in a window of time • Before: by a deadline • Related: in connection with another event • Device space
Mental Models • How do they help? • Connection to GUEPs • Connection to good and bad interfaces
How Good is the Interface? • What is good? • Who says? • On what grounds?
Exploring the “Grounds” • Cognitive Dimensions (of notation) • Hierarchy of design principles • GUEPs • General design principles • Implementable design guidelines • Task analysis • Hierarchical task analysis (HTA) • ConcurTaskTrees
Leave Behind • IRB form, completed to fullest extent possible • Bibliography for research study • Concept map of spaces