340 likes | 738 Views
DACRYOCYSTORHINOSTOMY EXTERNAL VS ENDOCANALICULAR DCR (ECL-DCR). Introduction. Epiphora is a relatively frequent problem in ophthalmology . Standard surgery is Dacryocystorhinostomy. Recent advent of laser technology. Inclusion Criteria.
E N D
DACRYOCYSTORHINOSTOMY EXTERNAL VS ENDOCANALICULAR DCR(ECL-DCR)
Introduction • Epiphora is a relatively frequent problem in ophthalmology . • Standard surgery is Dacryocystorhinostomy. • Recent advent of laser technology.
Inclusion Criteria • Primary acquired nasolacrimal duct obstruction with / without chronic dacryocystitis • Patent canaliculi • Normal eyelid function • Patients age less than 40 years
Exclusion Criteria • Sac pathology • History of previous sac surgery • Lacrimal fistula • Turbinate hypertrophy • Gross deviated nasal septum • Nasal Pathology(Atrophic Rhinitis,Polyp)
Pre-Operative Evaluation • History • Clinical evaluation • Examination of lids • Assessment of punctum • Examination of sac area • Nasal examination • Diagnostic Tests • Flourescein Dye Disappearance Test • Lacrimal syringing
Follow up • At 10th day, one and six months post surgery • Results were graded as : Full Success – NO TEARS NO INFECTION NO REFLUX Partial Success - LESS TEARING THAN BEFORE PARTIAL REFLUX Surgical Failure - PERSISTENT TEARING CLOSED OSTIUM
Steps Of External DCR 1. Skin incision 2. Bone osteotomy 3. Dissection of sac flap 4. Anastomosis of flap
Procedure for ECL-DCR • Anesthetise the nasal cavity with 10% Xylocaine spray • Dilate the punctum • Probing. • Feel the bone.
Procedure • Keep the initial power at 7 watt. • Insert the 600µ fiber into the cannaliculus upto the lacrimal bone. • Focus endoscope in a way that the middle turbinate remains in central vision when the red aiming beam is seen above or in front of the anterior end of middle turbinate • Press the laser footswitch maintaining moderate pressure against bone with the DCR cannula.
Procedure • Fire the laser. • On any resistance from the bone or sac, increase the power. • Manipulate the cannula and keep firing the laser to increase the size of the opening (4-5mm). • Syringing at the end of the surgery with normal saline water, then with dilute povidone iodine solution or Betadine,
Major Postoperative Complication External DCR – Scar Related
ECL DCR– Osteotomy Related Major Postoperative Complication
Results • The Success in the External DCR : -Immediate mucosa lined fistula via the closure of the mucosal flaps.
Results • The failure in the laser DCR group : - Anatomic variations - Post-operative inflammation and fibrosis. • Inability to create an adequate opening. • Wrong selection of patients.
External DCR - The Gold Standard • Large bony osteotomy. • Lacrimal sac is exposed -canalicular DCR. • Success rate of 95%
Limitations of External DCR • Per-operative haemorrhage • Surgery is lengthy (variable). • Risk of sump syndrome. • Re-do surgery -fibrous tissue. • The cutaneous scar.
Laser Procedures in DCR • Advantage over Surgical Approach- - Cutaneous Scarring is eliminated. - Minimal tissue disruption. - Minimal bleeding. • CSF leaks unlikely. • Can be used in deabilitated patients.
Definitive edge of Endocanalicular DCR • Laser energy is directed away from eye • Ophthalmologist friendly. • Nasal endoscopy and Instrumentation unneccesary.
Conclusions Which procedure to choose????
Conclusions PATIENT SELECTION -Right procedure for right patient
Conclusions • DISCUSSION WITH PATIENT • Viable option treatment. • Discuss the advantages and disadvantages with patients.
Conclusions FOLLOW UP… More frequent and regular follow-up for ECL-DCR patients
If two different techniques give the same result, use the one that is easier and faster But if a more difficult and longer operation yields a superior result, use it .