230 likes | 372 Views
Mekong Institute & UNESCO Regional Office-Bangkok. Training Course on “ Training of Trainers from the Greater Mekong Sub-Region on Decentralized Education Planning in the Context of Public Sector Management Reform ”. Fundamentals of Enrolment Projections.
E N D
Mekong Institute & UNESCO Regional Office-Bangkok Training Course on “Training of Trainers from the Greater Mekong Sub-Region on Decentralized Education Planning in the Context of Public Sector Management Reform” Fundamentals of Enrolment Projections 23 February – 6 March 2009; KhonKaen, Thailand Module E5 - Session 1 Prepared by the Education Policy and Reform Unit UNESCO Bangkok February 2009
Enrolment Projection • Projection is the process of obtaining an estimate (or estimates) based on present situation, future goals and targets, and past trends • Projecting future enrolment is one of the most important tasks for education planners and managers at all levels • Enrolment for the coming school year can be projected in several ways: • using current enrolment • extrapolation based on the previous years’ enrolment trend • summing up a portion of current year’s enrolment in the grade (as repeating students) and another portion from the immediately lower grade (as promoting students), • etc.
Simulation Models • Future enrolment cannot be predicted with 100% accuracy due to several factors impacting on schooling. • Those factors are both internal (pupil, teacher, school, teaching-learning materials, assessment, …) and external (health, social, economical, cultural, migration, …) • Several projections are to be made to select one from an iterative process of target setting • The process of making projections based on different, but plausible, targets and assumptions is known as “simulation” • Simulation models are the common tools in studying education alternatives.
Analysis and Projection Model • Analysis and Projection (ANPRO) Model is one of the “simulation models” and is designed for projecting: • enrolment and graduates, • resources needed, • human resources: teachers, principals and other staff • material resources: teaching-learning materials, textbooks… • facilities and equipment: classes, classrooms, schools, … • financial resources: recurrent expenditures (salaries , utilities, maintenance) , and capital expenditures such as construction, major repairs, etc… and • available resources and possible resource gaps • ANPRO uses cohort-component method to project enrolment • Other resources needed are projected based on the projected future enrolment in schools, specifically public schools.
Cohort-Component Method (1) • Let us assume that our primary education system has 5 grades, and that the official school entrance age is 6. • Entry point to formal general education system is normally the first grade of primary education, that is Grade 1, and a group of pupils (students) who entered the education system during the same year is called “a pupil cohort” • From Grade 1, the cohort will proceed to the higher grades, and ultimately, they will conclude the primary school as “primary school graduates (successful completers)” or “dropouts” Population Aged 6 PRIMARY SCHOOL enrolment new intake Graduates Grade 1 Grade 2 Grade 3 Grade 4 Grade 5 DROPOUTS
Cohort-Component Method (2) • Not all pupils (or enrolment) in Grade 1 are “new entrants” or “new intake” of the current school year • Some of them have already attended, partly or fully, during the previous school years but are still remain in Grade 1 in this school year • Those pupils are known as “repeaters” (or repeating students) • Similarly, not all pupils in Grade 2 studied in Grade 1 during previous school year • most of them are promoted from previous year’s Grade 1 enrolment, and • a smaller group is “repeaters” from previous year’s Grade 2 enrolment • Pupils promoted to Grade 2 from the previous year’s Grade 1 enrolment are called “promotees”.
Repeaters Repeaters (3) Dropout Dropout PopulationAged 6 Newintake Grade 1 Grade 2 2005/06 (2) Repeaters (1) Promotees Repeaters PopulationAged 6 Newintake Grade 1 Grade 2 2006/07 Cohort-Component Method (3) • Once a child entered the education system (primary Grade 1), he/she becomes a “pupil” and has three destinies for the coming year: (1) a higher grade (is promoted to Grade 2) (2) the same grade (repeats in Grade 1) (3) out of school (drops out during, or at the end of school year)
Cohort-Component Method (4) • Grade 1 enrolment in year 2005/06 has two components: • New intake in 05/06 (from school age population), and • Repeaters (from the same grade, Grade 1 in 2004/05) • Grade 1 enrolment in year 2006/07 also has two components: • New intake in 06/07 (from school age population), and • Repeaters (from the same grade, Grade 1 in 2005/06) • Thus, Grade 1 enrolment in coming year, 2007/08 can be estimated through: (a) how many pupils will enter into Grade 1 in 07/08 from the school-age population, and (b) how many pupils will repeat in 07/08 from the current year Grade 1 enrolment • Grade 1 enrolment in 2007/08 is: Grade 1 enrolment = New intake + Repeaters from in 2007/08 in 2007/08 2006/07 cohort
Cohort-Component Method (5) • Similarly, the Grade 2 enrolment also has two components: • Promotees (from the lower grade, Grade 1), and • Repeaters (from the same grade, Grade 2) • Grade 2 enrolment in the next year is estimated through: (a) number of pupils who will be promoted from the current year Grade 1 enrolment, and (b) number of pupils who will repeat the current year Grade 2 enrolment • “How many children will enter as new intake?”;“How many pupils will be promoted?” and“How many pupils will repeat?” should be estimated from the past behavior of the cohort • The technique of estimating each component using the common experience of the entire cohort is known as“cohort-component method”
Cohort-Component Method (6) • Most of those who entered Grade 1 for the first time (the new intake or entrants) are from the population at the school entrance age (say 6-year olds) • If there are X number of children aged 6 in the catchment area of a primary school, and the school received Y number of new entrants, the apparent intake rate (AIR) can be calculated as: Y AIR = ---- x 100 X • AIR is also known as Gross Intake Rate (GIR) or Gross Admission Rate (GAR) • From the above equation, number of new entrants, Y is: Y = AIR x X • Therefore, number of new entrants can be estimated by multiplying the “apparent intake rate” with “population at the school entrance age”
Grade 1 Grade 2 120 110 2005/06 18 Repeaters 96 Promotees 10 Repeaters 100 Pop. Aged 6 105 Newintake 123 ? 2006/07 Cohort-Component Method (7) • Since the repeaters in 2006/07 are coming from the 2005/06 cohort (of Grade 1 enrolment), the “Grade 1 repetition rate for 2005/06” is defined as: No. of Repeaters in 2006/07 Repetition rate (2005/2006) = ---------------------------------------- x 100 Total enrolment in 2005/06 • For example: • What are the AIR in 2006/07, percentage of repeaters in Grade 1 in 2006/07, and Grade 1 repetition rate for 2005/06?
Cohort-Component Method (8) • In this example, Grade 1 enrolment in 2006/07 school year is 123. Of them: • 18 are repeaters (who were in Grade 1 during 05/06) and • 105 are new intake (who have never been to school) • Again, there are 100 children aged 6 in the school catchment area, and thus, the “apparent intake rate for 2006/07” is 105%(i.e., 105 / 100 x 100) • Out of 123 Grade 1 enrolment in 2006/07, 18 are repeaters and percentage of repeaters is 14.6% (i.e., 18 / 123 x 100) • Out of 120 Grade 1 enrolment in 2005/06, 18 pupils are repeating in Grade 1 in 2006/07 school year • Therefore, Grade 1 repetition rate for the 2005/06 cohort is15%(i.e., 18 / 120 x 100), and • Grade 2 repetition rate for 2005/06 is9.1%(i.e., 10 / 110 x 100)
Cohort-Component Method (9) • Of 120 Grade 1 enrolment in 2005/06 school year, 96 were promoted to Grade 2 in 2006/07 school year • Therefore, percentage of pupils promoted from the 2005/06 Grade 1 cohort is, 80% and it is known as “promotion rate” (i.e., 96 / 120 x 100) • In this example, 80% of the 2005/06 Grade 1 cohort was promoted to Grade 2, and 15% is repeating in Grade 1 • Where are the remaining 5% or 6 pupils (120 – 96 – 18) from 2005/06 cohort? • The remaining 6 pupils are no longer in school (or they have dropped out while studying in Grade 1) • Thus, the dropout ratefor the 2005/06 Grade 1 cohort is5%(i.e., 6 /120 * 100) • The dropout rate can also be obtained by subtracting promotion rate and repetition rate from 100%, that is, dropout rate = 100% - promotion rate – repetition rate = 100% - 80% - 15% = 5%
Cohort-Component Method (10) • Promotion rate is denoted by “p”, repetition rate is denoted by “r”, and dropout rate is denoted by “d”, and the three rates are known as “student flow rates” • As seen in the example, the famous relationship among the three student flow rates is: • Therefore, if two out of three student flow rates are known, the remaining one can be calculated from the above equation • We must be careful not to independently set values for all three while setting targets on student flow rates • That is, targets on any two out of three student flow rates must be set meaningfully p + r + d = 100 %
Cohort-Component Method (11) • If the “promotion rate” for Grade 1 in 2005/06 school year is known, the number of “promotees” in Grade 2 in 2006/07 can be calculated as: promotees = G1 enrolment 05/06 x G1 promotion rate 05/06 (2006/07) = 120 x 80% = 96 pupils • Similarly, from the repetition rate for Grade 2 in 2005/06 (9.1%), and , Grade 2 enrolment in 2005/06 (110), one could estimate number of repeaters in Grade 2 in 2006/07 school year as: repeaters = G2 enrolment 05/06 x G2 repetition rate 05/06 (2006/07) = 110 x 9.1% = 10 pupils • Therefore, total Grade 2 enrolment in 2006/07 school year becomes: G2 enrolment 06/07 = promotees in G2 + repeaters in G2 = 96 + 10 = 106 pupils
Cohort-Component Method (12) • Lets assume that there are 98 children aged 6 in the catchment area of the school and the AIR is targeted at 100% in 2007/08 • How many students would the school have in Grade 1 and Grade 2 in 2007/08 school year, if the student flow rates in 2006/07 are same as in 2005/06? Grade 1 Grade 2 enrolment enrolment 2006/07 106 123 r = 15% p = 80% r = 9.1% 98 children aged 6 AIR = 100% ?? Repeaters ?? Repeaters Promotees ??? New Intake ??? 2007/08 enrolment ??? enrolment ???
Cohort-Component Method (13) Grade 1 Grade 2 enrolment enrolment 2006/07 • And, what would be the enrolment in Grade 1 and Grade 2 in 2007/08 school year, if the promotion and repetition rates for the Grade 1 in 2006/07 become 87% and 10%? 106 123 p = 80% r = 9.1% r = 15% 98 children aged 6 AIR = 100% 10 Repeaters 18 Repeaters Promotees 98 New Intake 98 2007/08 enrolment 108 enrolment 116
Enrolment in Grade 1 Let us recapitulate some calculation made in this presentation: Grade 1 Population New Intake = Aged 6 x Apparent Intake Rate (AIR) in 2006/07 in 2006 Repeaters from Grade 1 2005/06 G1 = enrolment x G1 Repetition Rate enrolment in 2005/06 G1 enrolment = New Intake + Repeaters in 2006/07 in 2006/07 from 2005/06 G1
Enrolment in Grade 2 Enrolment Promotees Repeaters Grade 2 = from 2005/06 + from 2005/06 (2006/07) Grade 1 Grade 2 PromoteesGrade 1 Grade 1 from 2005/06 = enrolment x Promotion Rate Grade 1 (2005/06) (2005/06) Repeaters Grade 2 Grade 2 from 2005/06 = enrolment x Repetition Rate Grade 2 (2005/06) (2005/06)
Enrolment in Other Grades Enrolment Promotees from Repeaters from 2006/07 = 2005/06 + 2005/06 Grade i Grade (i-1) Grade (i) • Such a simple calculation procedure is applied in all ANPRO Models for enrolment projection! Promotees from Grade (i-1) Grade (i-1) 2005/06 = enrolment x Promotion Rate Grade (i-1) (2005/06) (2005/06) Repeaters Grade (i) Grade (i) from = enrolment x Repetition Rate 2005/06 2005/06 2005/06
How to Calculate Student Flow: A Working Example • Let us assume that our primary education level has 6 grades (Grade 1 to grade 6) and the following flow rates remain the same for the coming years: • Then, we can calculate the (selected) measure of efficiency for the primary education as following:
Provincial Education Planning, UNESCO-Bangkok & MOE-Thailand (August 2007)